During a recent visit to Shenzhen, China, entrepreneur Elon Musk participated virtually in a technology summit held in the US. In his remarks, he expressed great admiration for China’s economic and technological development and stated that “probably at some point in the coming years, there will be some geopolitical bumps in the road over a certain country that starts with the letter T.” Although Musk did not explicitly name the country, his comment has been widely understood as referring to Taiwan. This was not the first time that Musk showed a poor understanding of relations across the Taiwan Strait. He previously suggested that the Republic of China (Taiwan) could be a special administrative zone of China, compared relations between Taiwan and China to those between the state of Hawaii and the US, and even referred to Taiwan as an integral part of China. These comments ignored Taiwan’s historical development and democratization. I respect Musk’s observations on China’s development and understand the strategic importance of maintaining stability in US-China relations. However, portraying Taiwan as the source of friction in US-China relations only contributes to muddling the true nature of the Taiwan Strait issue. First, Taiwan is not a political bargaining chip for use by other countries. Neither the ROC (Taiwan) nor the People’s Republic of China (PRC) is subordinate to the other. Since the establishment of the PRC, it has never governed Taiwan. The people of Taiwan have made great efforts over the years in the pursuit of political liberalization and democratization. After completing its first direct presidential election in 1996, Taiwan has seen three changes of governing party, establishing a mature democratic system. Taiwan is a political entity collectively shaped by its 23 million people, and continues to advance democracy. Therefore, its future should be determined by its people.
China claims that Taiwan is part of its territory. This is a political position of the Beijing authorities, but it cannot change the objective status quo that neither the ROC (Taiwan) nor the PRC is subordinate to the other. Moreover, it cannot supersede the free will of the Taiwan people. Although different views exist in the international community on Taiwan’s legal status and diplomatic recognition, the reality of democratic Taiwan’s existence cannot be ignored. Second, the key to peace across the Taiwan Strait lies in opposing unilateral attempts to change the status quo by force or coercion, not demanding that Taiwan make concessions for the sake of great-power relations. In the event of geopolitical friction across the Taiwan Strait, the international community should identify the true source of risk. Characterizing Taiwan’s existence as a potential obstacle to US-China relations merely diverts attention from the real issues that need to be addressed. Taiwan has always striven to maintain peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait. It remains willing to engage in dialogue with China on the basis of parity, dignity and noncoercion. However, China continues to expand its military activities, conducting gray-zone intrusions in the Indo-Pacific and engaging in extraterritorial interference and transnational repression. These actions have raised significant concerns within the international community. In recent years, the importance of peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait has been repeatedly emphasized at Group of Seven (G7) summits and other international venues. This demonstrates that the world pays close attention to the issue of cross-strait security. Additionally, Taiwan is an important partner in global technological and economic resilience. In a recent article in Foreign Affairs, titled “America’s AI Ambitions Depend on Taiwan,” I pointed out that Taiwan was a trustworthy partner to the US in AI supply chains and a vital force in America’s efforts to enhance its technological competitiveness. Taiwan plays a crucial role in global supply chains spanning such industries as cutting-edge semiconductors, chip design, advanced packaging, AI servers and ICT. AI development relies on chips, computing equipment and comprehensive industrial ecosystems. Taiwan’s technology, talent and manufacturing capabilities form an important part of global technological innovation. All of this comes not just from Taiwan’s economic contributions but also from the long-standing trust fostered between Taiwan and its international partners. Musk is one of the most influential technology entrepreneurs. His breakthroughs in electric vehicles, space technology and AI demonstrate the immense potential of transnational partnerships on innovation. Thus, I hope he will gain a better understanding of Taiwan’s role from the perspective of technological collaboration. Businesses are free to choose which markets to invest in, but people have the right to shape and determine their own political future. These two issues belong to different spheres, and should not be conflated in relevant discussions. Expressing appreciation for China’s economic development does not mean one has to negate Taiwan’s democratic achievements. And hoping for peaceful coexistence between the US and China does not mean one has to sacrifice Taiwan’s security or the freedom and dignity of its people. Taiwan is neither a geopolitical obstacle nor a bargaining chip for great powers. Taiwan is willing and able, and has the responsibility, to work with the international community to maintain peace, drive innovation and create prosperity. Indeed, US-China ties that genuinely benefit the world should be built on both respect for the choices of the Taiwan people and a commitment to maintaining peace and stability across the Taiwan Strait. Lin Chia-lung is Minister of Foreign Affairs.