Chile's green hydrogen boom is drifting further and further away

rss · La Tercera 2026-11-22T10:00:00Z es
In May 2025, the French petrochemical giant Total entered environmental review for the largest investment project ever announced in Chile: H2 Magallanes, which aimed to produce green hydrogen and ammonia in the southern region, with an investment of US$16 billion. Amid the obvious enthusiasm for the megaproject, clean energy expert Michael Liebreich, founder of Bloomberg New Energy Finance and chairman of Liebreich Associates, abruptly punctured the expectation: "I doubt it will ever be built." The prediction of this specialist, globally recognized as a skeptic of the hydrogen economy, made sense a year and a half later, on November 12, when the French multinational formally requested the termination of the evaluation procedure before the regional Environmental Evaluation Service (SEA). In short, it canceled it. Faced with the news, Liebreich doubled down this week: "Its economic viability did not pass even the most basic analysis. Green hydrogen was always going to prove too costly to produce ammonia for the local market; and, if the intention was to export it to Europe, the European carbon price would have to be many times higher than the current one for the operation to be profitable," he told Pulso. The fall of H2 Magallanes adds to the one announced in January of this year by the American company AES, which withdrew its INNA project, also intended for the production of green hydrogen and ammonia, this time in the Antofagasta region, which contemplated investing US$11 billion. Although the companies did not point to price as the fundamental variable in their respective decisions, for those who know the industry, it is inevitable when assessing their economic reasoning. The price remains an as-yet unbearable burden for this industry, once conceived as an energy lifeline to tackle climate change, to fulfill that role. It is still much more expensive to produce a kilo of green hydrogen than those energy products made from fossil fuels. And if to this is added a geopolitical context that is not exactly cooperative in the line of decarbonizing the world, with the world's leading economy presided over by someone, Donald Trump, who has declared that global warming is "a hoax," the incentives for these types of technologies to take their first steps based on government aid are even smaller. Because what is clear is that green hydrogen today is not economically profitable, so it requires state support for its promotion. However, its promoters, acknowledging the economic difficulties, insist that it is an indispensable technology for decarbonization, just as it was argued only four years ago by former German Chancellor Olaf Scholz and former Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida, and which led the world's richest economies to develop national strategies to carry it forward and to materialize massive investments in that direction. Chile, considered favorable territory for its implementation due to its clean energy potential, has its strategy, but so far only multimillion-dollar projects — fewer and fewer — and limited concrete investments. Of the major initiatives expected, there remain HNH Energy in Magallanes for US$11 billion, to produce green ammonia, and Volta in Antofagasta, green hydrogen for US$2.5 billion. The problem with green hydrogen Green hydrogen (known as H2V) is a clean fuel obtained by separating the hydrogen and oxygen molecules of water through a process called electrolysis, using electricity from renewable sources such as solar or wind energy. In turn, green ammonia is produced by combining green hydrogen with nitrogen extracted from the air through a sustainable chemical process that does not emit carbon dioxide. Both are called "green" because they come from renewable energy sources and generate no waste other than the oxygen released as a byproduct, so they do not cause greenhouse gas emissions. The hydrogen produced is stored as compressed gas or as a liquid in airtight tanks. To export it, it must be shipped in tanker vessels, so it requires a port. H2V is used as a fuel for various purposes, but given its still high cost, it is applied in high-volume areas, so it would work best in the mining industry, in heavy-tonnage trucks, buses, ships, or even airplanes. There are examples in the world: London's public transport buses run on green hydrogen. Here in Chile there are still pilot-phase experiences: in 2023, the miner Anglo American launched the country's first hydrogen bus and uses forklifts with that fuel, and in September 2026, Walmart announced a future development of a truck fleet and an H2V plant and, together with Copec, launched the first hydrogen fueling station. Ammonia, in turn, is used for agricultural fertilizers, as an industrial refrigerant, as a liquid fuel in internal combustion engines and turbines, and as an input for pharmaceutical and chemical products, such as nitric acid. But these fuels must compete with all other energy sources, in a market where the so-called gray and blue hydrogen already exist, which can be used for the same purpose. Gray hydrogen is produced from fossil fuels, such as natural gas, which at high temperatures is converted into hydrogen and carbon dioxide, the latter being released into the atmosphere, so it is a greenhouse gas: each ton generates about 10 tons of carbon dioxide. Blue hydrogen, meanwhile, is also produced from natural gas, but much of the CO2 is captured and stored. When it comes to prices, the differences are substantial. Various international consultancies agree that the LCOH (levelized cost of hydrogen production) in the case of gray hydrogen fluctuates between US$1.5 and US$2.5 per kilogram, blue sits between US$2 and US$3.5 per kilo, and green, between US$3.5 and US$6. The LCOH depends less on the chemical process and more on three variables: the price of the energy source (between 60% and 70%), capital expenditure on equipment (in the case of green, electrolyzers represent 10% to 15%) and regional infrastructure (storage, ports, transport, another 20% to 30%). By region, H2V costs also vary. In the Middle East, it is obtained at between US$2.5 and US$3.5 per kilo, in China between US$3 and US$4.5, in India from US$3.5 to US$5, in the United States in a range of US$4 to US$6, and in Europe, between US$5 and US$8, according to the consultancy Ecosense. Skeptics believe these costs could come down, but never enough to compete with the alternatives, unless a high price is applied to carbon. The carbon price is an economic tool that assigns a monetary value (generally per ton of carbon dioxide equivalent) to greenhouse gas emissions. "There is no way clean hydrogen can compete with gray or black hydrogen (produced from gas or coal, without mitigation measures). Decarbonizing the current consumption of 100 million annual tons of hydrogen will always require a carbon price. Likewise, green hydrogen will never be cheaper than blue; it will always need a higher carbon price, probably much higher," warned Michael Liebreich, who, to tackle decarbonization, favors electrification as the great way out. The counterfactual For those more attached to economic doctrine, price determines the future of green hydrogen. But the pro-H2V camp presents data that at least nuance that difficulty. "It will never be as efficient as electrification," admits Marcos Kulka, executive director of H2 Chile, the trade association that groups the companies promoting green hydrogen in the country. "But it has characteristics that make it unique in those things that cannot be electrified, because a lot of energy is needed, for heat, or because the size of a battery would be unviable. That is where hydrogen and its derivatives come into play; that is why we talk about fuels for aviation, for the maritime industry (ammonia or methanol) and industries that are difficult to decarbonize such as steel, cement, or petrochemical industry inputs," says Kulka. A report by the Hydrogen Council and the consultancy McKinsey, called Global Hydrogen Compass 2026, is promising in that regard. Among its findings, it states that "hydrogen has a renewed strategic value by facilitating the resilience of the whole system and industrial growth, beyond decarbonization." In the new global context generated by the fuel crisis, the need for energy and food security, resilience, and industrial growth becomes more relevant. "More than 60% of the committed investment (in H2V) is concentrated in areas where security and growth equal or exceed decarbonization as the main motivations," says the report. It also says that investment in green hydrogen this year grew to US$130 billion in 570 projects, of which 90% are under construction or already operating. Operating capacity grew 70%, to 1.7 Mtpa (million tons per year) and is expected to reach about 3.8 Mtpa next year. China leads, accounting for more than half of the initiatives, followed by Europe, with 35%. And it concludes by stating that if the existing policies in the various economies, such as China, the United States, Europe, the Middle East, and India, are implemented, firm H2V demand could nearly double by 2030. Chilean strategy in the hot seat The McKinsey report, however, only mentions Chile for the expected projects and for the cancellation of INNA. But it also highlights the country for being one of the 15 nations that has drawn up a plan on the matter. In this case, the National Green Hydrogen Strategy presented by the Piñera administration in 2020, framed within Chile's commitment to achieve carbon neutrality by 2050. The original objectives of this strategy were to have 5 GW of electrolysis capacity under development by 2025, produce the cheapest green hydrogen in the world in 2030, and be among the three largest hydrogen exporters in 2040. The Boric government complemented the strategy with an Action Plan 2023-2030, which kept the last two goals, since in 2025 the 5 GW of electrolysis capacity was not achieved: there were approved or under-evaluation investments of 8.6 GW, totaling almost US$40 billion, but in operation only small pilot projects. The former Energy Minister Juan Carlos Jobet, in his address at Enade last month, pointed to green hydrogen as, within the energy sector, one of the industries that could drive Chile's growth toward 2050. He made one caveat: "if we do things right and the technology advances, we can produce hydrogen and its derivatives, and export that abundant energy to other countries of the world." However, the current government has not shown the same drive as the two previous administrations. "Five years ago, governments around the world seemed more committed to climate action than today. And that is part of the problem: the lack of ambition of governments, which send signals to the markets and that leads projects to make decisions. I miss a short-term signal from the government, as there was under Piñera and Boric," comments the former Energy Minister of that last administration, Diego Pardow. In that sense, Pardow acknowledges that the traditional fuel "will always be cheaper," but the essence lies in the externality that this entails, which is the greenhouse gas and the consequent global warming. "The internalization of that externality depends on governments," he opines. Therefore, he recalls that the Chamber of Deputies approved a bill sent by the previous government and now in the Senate, providing a tax benefit for green hydrogen production, which consists of the investor who produces having a tax credit that can be transferred to demand (mining, refinery, cellulose, petrochemical), since at the beginning it will not be able to deduct it because it will not have profits. Because the promoters know that without incentives, at least for now, there will be no major investments. "If the project is approved in the Senate, it could trigger the first projects," says Kulka, of H2 Chile. But the signals from the current administration have not been so encouraging. President Kast, in line with other global leaders, has not spoken about climate change or strategies against global warming. Even less about green hydrogen. Asked by what the current government has done to prevent green hydrogen projects from continuing to be canceled, his Energy Minister, Ximena Rincón, states that this "remains an opportunity for Chile," but makes clear that its success is subordinate to factors beyond Chile: "The development of this industry depends mainly on the conditions and maturation of the global market." Because, in line with what is happening in the world, Rincón argues that "the main challenge of green hydrogen remains its economic competitiveness against other alternatives," so she does not assure that the bill will be expedited, but only that her ministry "will continue contributing technical background to the debate," since they believe that the development of the industry "must sustain itself on its own through its capacity to be competitive and respond to a real market demand."

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Knowledge Graph

Entities
Highlight