The doubts and expectations opening up one week before the Donations Law takes effect

rss · La Tercera 2026-11-22T10:00:00Z es
Just over a week after the transitional benefit allowing donations to be made in advance while paying only half of the corresponding tax came into effect, the Internal Revenue Service (SII) has issued a series of circulars and resolutions in recent weeks to clarify how this mechanism included in the Reconstruction Law will operate. However, the law firms that manage the assets of middle- and high-income individuals have seen inquiries multiply long before, especially since the so-called "mega-reform" was published in the Official Gazette on October 17, which includes cuts to the corporate tax and is considered one of the key victories of Finance Minister Jorge Quiroz. "There is enormous interest in taking advantage of the new benefit. The past month has been intense and inquiries have multiplied. It is very likely that three times more money will be collected for the treasury than projected by the Finance Ministry," says a lawyer at a firm that manages large estates. While the government's public expectations point to collections of around US$300 million from the transitional incentive, Finance Ministry sources privately confide that this figure could easily be exceeded. The transitional mechanism, which begins this December 1 and will be in effect for one year, allows access to the 50% reduction on the donation tax for those individuals who wish to...
Just over a week after the entry into force of the transitional benefit that allows donations to be made in advance and only half of the corresponding tax to be paid, the Internal Revenue Service (SII) has issued a series of circulars and resolutions in recent weeks to clarify how this mechanism included in the Reconstruction Law will operate. However, the law firms that manage the estates of middle- and high-income individuals have seen inquiries multiply long before, especially since the so-called "mega-reform" was published in the Official Gazette on October 17, which includes cuts to the corporate tax and is considered one of the key victories of Finance Minister Jorge Quiroz. "There is enormous interest in taking advantage of the new benefit. The last month has been intense and inquiries have multiplied. It is very likely that three times more money will be collected for the treasury than projected by Finance," says a lawyer at a firm that manages large estates. While the government's public expectations point to collections of some US$300 million from the transitional incentive, Finance sources privately confide that this figure could easily be exceeded. The transitional mechanism, which begins this December 1 and will be in force for one year, allows access to the 50% reduction of the tax on donations made by those who wish to advance part of their inheritance and transfer it to relatives. The law currently establishes that donations and inheritances pay a tax with a progressive rate, whose maximum is 25% for amounts exceeding 1,200 Annual Tax Units, just over $1,000 million. According to the law, this mechanism does not allow donating more than 50% of the donor's estate. "For example, if a person has an estate of $400 million, the maximum they could donate is $200 million to take advantage of this benefit and pay only half of the corresponding tax," the SII details. The donation must be made to persons who have a succession relationship with the donor (those who could inherit or receive assets in a future succession upon death), such as spouse, civil partner, children and grandchildren, among others. These are known as "forced heirs" or "assignees of the fourth of improvements," the latter being those who can benefit from an "improvement" of 25% of the inheritance, according to the will of the testator or donor. Jaime del Valle "The mechanism is very beneficial because not only is the tax rate halved, but also because taking advantage of it today implies a saving in the base, assuming an assumption of estate growth. Anticipating the inheritance tax today has an opportunity cost that is offset by the rate reduction, but if the donor dies in 20 years, for example, the asset base could be double in a scenario of reasonable compound growth, which implies—in that example—a maximum effective rate not of 12.5%, but half," explains Jaime Del Valle, founding partner of Fuensalida and Del Valle Abogados. The objections According to the circulars and resolutions issued by the SII, the measure—unlike general donations—does not require prior judicial authorization, called insinuación, but only a public deed before a notary, and allows donating half of any type of assets: money or species, movable or immovable property, located in Chile or abroad. Jaime Del Valle believes that a complex legal externality of the tax incentive is that it does not "converse" adequately with the civil rule that protects forced heirs or legitimarios, and says there are two aspects that are not covered and that are neither tax-related nor under the SII's scrutiny. By way of example, the lawyer believes it is possible that, in this transitional window, one of the heirs could receive more than the law allows, to the detriment of other forced heirs, since there would be no controls to prevent it. "First, previous donations are not accumulated, so someone could end up affecting the 'legítima' and receiving more than the law allows; and second, the sanction is unclear in case the maximum percentage to be donated is not respected. The donation could not take advantage of this special law, but the tax was paid and the donation was made, the assets were transferred, eventually sold or the money spent. And there is no incentive for the SII to pursue nullities or retroact on acts, which at that point may be unviable… and, moreover, refund tax for a donation that had no effect. A serious breach of a civil rule protecting the family can, in practice, end up in no man's land," the lawyer warns. According to the SII, to determine the amount on which the tax must be applied, the value of the assets at the time the donation is made will be considered, according to current rules. For example, for the appraisal of real estate, the fiscal appraisal will be taken into account; for immovable property, its current market value will be considered; for shares or securities, the average recorded during the six months prior to the date of the donation. In the case of the value of vehicles, their current appraisal will be taken into account. "Meanwhile, the value of the donor's total estate will be determined by subtracting the total of their liabilities credited from the total of their assets valued according to what has already been mentioned," the SII explains. However, one of the big doubts of jurists corresponds to the valuation of assets in different dimensions. In a comment on a circular in public consultation, the partner of the Legal and Tax Area of PwC Chile, Loreto Pelegrí, estimates that there is an asymmetry in the valuation of assets and liabilities. In her view, the legal methodology can produce relevant asymmetries, particularly when a property is considered at its fiscal appraisal and the mortgage credit associated with it is computed at its effective outstanding balance. Loreto Pelegrí "In this way, a null or even negative tax estate could be determined for a person who economically maintains a positive estate. It is requested to specify the treatment of liabilities directly associated with assets whose legal valuation differs significantly from their commercial value, the way of imputing said liabilities, and the treatment of situations in which the literal application of these rules determines a negative net estate," Pelegrí maintains on the SII's comment page. The president of the Tax Commission of the College of Accountants of Chile, Juan Alberto Pizarro, adds that the SII's circulars should clarify some valuation criteria, especially when it comes to appraising shares of corporations. "There it becomes more complex because the company has to be valued as a whole and doubts arise as to what type of balance sheet is considered, methodologies, discount rates... In short, criteria for the valuation of equity rights and shares become necessary," Pizarro affirms. While Mónica Justiniano, partner at Laport Justiniano Asesores Tributarios, values that the draft circular included guiding criteria to give taxpayers certainty about the application of the General Anti-Avoidance Rule (NGA), she believes the possibility should have been included for the donor to freely reorganize their estate, with the only limitation being that as a result of that implemented reorganization they do not end up paying less donation tax. Mónica Justiniano, partner at Laport Justiniano Asesores Tributarios. But beyond the circular, Justiniano points to the law itself. "While it is a requirement of the law that the donor must declare the percentage of the total estate donated to each assignee and this declaration can be audited by the SII, we estimate that this situation can carry a disincentive, given the need to value 100% of the estate, due to the economic costs this implies, even when the portion to be donated is much lower," the lawyer complains. A specialist says that another formula was suggested to Finance, which was not considered, but which, he affirms, could be corrected in upcoming legislation: proving to have at least double what is donated, given the 50% limit. Thus, for example, if a taxpayer wants to donate $100, they must prove they have $200, but without having to appraise or declare their entire estate. The Internal Revenue Service details that the valuation of the donor's estate may consider the values in force within the 90 days prior to the date of filing the sworn declaration and, additionally, imposes that the assets included in the balance sheet of the company whose rights are donated be prepared at the latest on the first day of the calendar month prior to the one in which the donation deed is signed. "We estimate that this one-month deadline can be complex to meet for operating companies or holding companies with several layers of companies; (it is complex) to have the information available at such a close date, since there is certain information, such as the valuation of investments at proportional book value, that they do not record monthly," Justiniano explains. An influential lawyer in the market believes that another major disincentive emanating from the circulars is the obligation to make a single notarial deed for all donations intended to be made in this transitional window. "This forces one to reveal which heirs you leave more or less to," he questions. Another jurist agrees on the same point. "What the Internal Revenue Service proposes is restrictive and senseless. I may want to donate something different to my son Pedro than to my son Juan, and something different to my aunt María, and, ridiculously, I have to put them all in the same deed and make them all come to sign. If I want to donate something more to one of my children later, taking advantage of the transitional window, I could not. It is too restrictive," concludes the same lawyer, with whom other consulted specialists agree.

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Knowledge Graph

Entities
Highlight