Suddenly, a voice interrupts the conversation. "Air raid alarm has been voiced in Kiev." David Rieff is in a hotel in the Ukrainian capital when a Russian missile attack begins. Dramatically, the war interferes with his reflections. It is no minor detail: the American essayist has been describing the collapse of an idea, or an illusion, that shaped the West for decades: the conviction that war would eventually become an anachronism.
-We are returning to the historical norm, he says over Zoom.
The son of writer Susan Sontag and sociologist Philip Rieff, the 76-year-old writer plans to spend a few months in Ukraine. This is nothing new for him: he has worked in conflict zones and humanitarian crises, from Bosnia to Sudan.
-I have spent several years of my life in war zones, he says.
Author of Against Memory and In Praise of Forgetting, Rieff seems to have inherited part of his father's skepticism and a certain liberal outlook from his mother. In Chile, UDP Ediciones has just published The Triumph of the Therapeutic, one of his father's most influential essays, who died in 2006. Originally published in 1966, the book is an erudite essay that acutely describes a profound transformation of society stemming from Freud: the decline of Judeo-Christian culture before the "therapeutic culture." The pursuit of well-being is no longer according to norms, discipline, or a certain idea of sacrifice, but rather in terms of subjectivity. Thus, the "political man" is replaced by "psychological man," whose purpose is individual psychic well-being. His models are no longer saints or ideologues, but therapists, experts on the self. He is not interested in utopia or eternity, but in inner experience.
"This loss of collective horizons of meaning has as its correlate a radical privatization of well-being. Unlike religious man, who found his place in the community of faith, or the classical citizen, who found it in shared civic life, psychological man seeks his stability in an essentially individual and private way, mediated by therapeutic categories," writes Carlos Peña in an incisive introduction.
August 31, 2022
Interview with David Rieff, American political analyst, journalist, and cultural critic.
Photo: Andrés Pérez Andres Perez
-My father died in 2006, and I don't think he would have been so surprised by our cultural realities, by the victory of a certain radical subjectivity, says David Rieff.
-When he wrote this book, in the 1960s, that subjectivity had another form, but the underlying problem was the same: the triumph of subjectivity, of relativism, of the idea that one can invent oneself. It seems to me one of the great themes of our era. For me, the most radical version is the trans movement. My father could not have imagined it, but I think we are on the same line, although there are evident differences.
The book polemicizes with its time. To what extent is it still relevant?
I think its vision is a fairly accurate portrait of the current situation. Obviously, there was something he did not understand: when he spoke of radical subjectivity, he thought in individual terms. I don't think my father took seriously the possibility that groups and movements would also appropriate those subjective ideas. Now we have the triumph of that radical subjectivity, but also of a very Balkanized collective consciousness. You identify by your gender, by your race, or by other affiliations, not only by the nation. I think of the famous phrase by José Vasconcelos, the motto of UNAM: "Por mi raza hablará el espíritu" ("Through my race the spirit shall speak"). Vasconcelos was thinking of the cosmic race, but today it seems we have a thousand races.
Your father has a skeptical vision, but he seems to lament the disappearance of the religious world.
Yes. With all his skepticism toward the psychoanalytic and therapeutic world, he had a much more religious and traditional view of life and culture. He thought the disappearance of the Judeo-Christian world was a great defeat. For him, that world was infinitely preferable to the post-Christian world. But he did not believe there was any way to go back. In a certain sense, it is a book of mourning, like much of his work. My father did not have the happiness of the authentic pessimist. The great pessimists usually have a good sense of humor. I think of Beckett or Cioran. I met Cioran, and he was always making jokes. My father was not. He was a witness to what he considered the defeat of civilization, without the joy of the Beckettian pessimist.
In certain trans activism discourses, for example, denying a person's identity is presented not simply as an opinion, but as an attack on their health, even as a form of extreme violence. We live in a culture that seeks well-being and values subjectivity, but at the same time seems to be permeated by anxiety and malaise. How do you see that paradox?
I think many young people feel lost and anxious for concrete reasons, such as climate change. In Europe, much of the political energy is in the extremes, both in the hard right and the radical left. There is a fairly deep fear in the experience of youth in many countries. And there is also the collapse of the middle class. There are material reasons for the psychological situation. My father, however, saw something important: the radical place health would occupy in our civilization, almost like a creed. Now this is even more evident, because of the relationship established between psychological malaise and physical health. In certain trans activism discourses, for example, denying a person's identity is presented not simply as an opinion, but as an attack on their health, even as a form of extreme violence. My father did not know the trans movement, inclusive language, or contemporary gender movements, beyond feminism, but he had identified the link between subjectivity and health.
It seems to me that left-wing parties are much more focused on gender and cultural politics, and less on unions or material living conditions.
The therapeutic language has also taken hold in politics.
Of course. It seems to me that left-wing parties are much more focused on gender and cultural politics, and less on unions or material living conditions. For me, that is a mistake. I am quite materialist in that sense, though not Marxist; perhaps a Weberian materialist. The curious thing is that both the hard right and the hard left are obsessed with cultural matters. Their positions are irreconcilable, but they share that shift toward culture. That is why I think capitalism is not too worried about woke discussions: they change nothing fundamental. There are political causes like Palestine, of course, but much of youth criticism is cultural, not material.
August 31, 2022
Interview with David Rieff, American political analyst, journalist, and cultural critic.
Photo: Andrés Pérez Andres Perez
Just as your father spoke of the triumph of the therapeutic, you have spoken of the triumph of trauma.
Yes. I have a project to write a book that, as a tribute to my father, could be called The Triumph of the Traumatic. I think we have moved from the therapeutic to the traumatic as the organizing idea of psychological life, of inner life: trauma as the source of all unhappiness. First I have to write a small book about Ukraine, and I have commitments here in Kiev, but it is a project that interests me a great deal.
He adds:
-There is something curious: everyone presents my parents as completely different intellectual figures. My mother, Susan Sontag, was a left-wing person; my father was more or less on the right, though he was anti-populist. My father would have hated Trump and Milei. With Kast, being Catholic, I imagine he might have felt a certain sympathy. But I find ideas of my mother's that are not so far from my father's, especially her critique of the metaphorical view of the world. For example, when someone speaks of "cultural genocide," or holds that words can be as violent as physical violence, they are using a metaphorical vision. And metaphor can also be a form of subjectivity. My mother's two books on illness are books against metaphor. So, in a sense, for the first time in my life I am going to write a book where I have to confront my parents' ideas.
You agree with them...
Yes, above all because it seems to me there is a catastrophic inflation of metaphors, there is a therapeuticization of the world. And that is the triumph of subjectivity.
Populisms
You have been very critical of Donald Trump. How would you define him ideologically?
I do not see him as a fascist. It seems almost an injustice to the fascists, because the fascists had ideas—bad ideas, but at least ideas. Trump has no ideas: he has desires. He wants money, he wants power. He has no principles. Trump is a disaster; his immigration policy seems to me a tragic injustice. I think he should go to jail, but I don't think he will. And we must not forget that he has two years left.
In any case, I was very glad about Lula's victory. I don't admire him that much, but he seems infinitely preferable to the Bolsonaro family, whom I consider a mafia family.
However, he has just received an important electoral blow.
Yes. In domestic politics, from January 2027, with the new Congress, they will probably be able to curb many of his excesses. But the American president is almost a king in international politics. I don't know how much he will help Ukraine. I hope at least that he cannot cancel certain necessary programs and budgets.
For a while there was talk of a rise of populist right-wingers. In light of the defeats of Trump, Orbán, and Bolsonaro, could that wave be entering decline?
Yes, absolutely. Right-wing populism is seductive for many people, especially in an era of middle-class crisis in rich countries or countries with strong economies, like the United States, Chile, Argentina, or Brazil. But there is something those populists did not understand: corruption bothers people. It seems to me that corruption is a central factor in Trump's defeat and also in Orbán's case. Brazil is different, because the PT is not free of corruption problems either. In any case, I was very glad about Lula's victory. I don't admire him that much, but he seems infinitely preferable to the Bolsonaro family, whom I consider a mafia family.
Rieff adds another point:
-The other issue is that the cultural battle can be very attractive at the beginning of a term, but people eventually get tired of the cultural battle. When there is an economic crisis and the price of fuel doubles, the culture wars take a back seat. People return to worrying about their material conditions. I don't know, however, whether we are witnessing the end of populism. There are also very populist figures in the Democratic Party, though from the left. It is possible that we will simply move from a right-wing populism to a left-wing one.
The old world order
Is Donald Trump breaking the international order? How do you gauge the crisis of the West?
Yes, there is a crisis, but for me we are returning to the historical norm. There was a time, after the Second World War, when very intelligent and cultured people believed we could put an end to war, that it would become something anachronistic and that the world of human rights would triumph. Now we know we lived in an illusion. It was a period of comparative peace, because there were many wars. I think our world resembles more the world as it has almost always existed.
Trump seems a disaster to me, but to think that an order established in 1945 could retain the same authority in 2026 is completely naive. For decades we shared, in one way or another, something of Fukuyama's vision: not necessarily the end of history, but the end of tragedy.
Trump is a disaster in many ways and his government is, in my judgment, the most corrupt in American history. But I do not think he single-handedly destroyed the 1945 order. He is a manifestation of the decadence of that system.
Rieff says he does not share "the idea that the future of our entire civilization depends on justice in Palestine. Nor do I share, though I am committed to Ukraine, the claim that the future of the democratic world depends on what happens here. If it were said that the future of Europe, or of European peace, depends on Ukraine, I would agree much more. But for someone in New Delhi, Beijing, or Santiago de Chile, will their whole world change according to the outcome of this war? I don't think so."
And what role does Trump play in the collapse of that order?
Trump is a disaster in many ways and his government is, in my judgment, the most corrupt in American history. But I do not think he single-handedly destroyed the 1945 order. He is a manifestation of the decadence of that system. He has done things I consider terrible, like betraying Ukraine. But one must not romanticize the past either: Biden was possibly more Zionist than Trump. Not everything changed with Trump. In a certain sense, Trump makes me think of the end of the Roman Empire. I don't say it literally. All empires eventually disappear and others take their place. It is a romanticism, even a narcissism, to believe that our system will be the exception.
You don't believe in the idea of progress either?
I don't believe much in progress. There is technological progress, evidently, but also new risks. Industrialization led us to the climate crisis, and artificial intelligence has completely changed war. It is much better to go to the dentist in 2026 than in almost any other era, but that does not mean history moves in a single direction. Every era has its achievements and its defeats.
Rieff observes that "every day someone says they are 'on the right side of history,' but history has no ideas. It is a fantasy we use to justify our positions. It seems to me that the Greeks, with their cyclical view of history, were closer to the truth than the cultures derived from the monotheisms, with their idea of advancing toward the promised land or toward the end of history."
David Rieff's answer is interrupted by a mechanized voice heard in the hotel: "Air raid alarm has been voiced in Kiev." And the communication is cut off. Hours later, Rieff will report:
-The attack was horrible, but it happened in a neighborhood of Kiev quite far from my hotel.