The self-proclaimed "new political moment" seems not to be reflected in the actions of certain public officials. One example of this is the nominations to the Supreme Court of Justice (TSJ) of candidates whose records are severely questioned for human rights violations. Such is the case of lawyer Hennit Carolina López Mesa, who aspires to become one of the justices of the country's highest court, despite the fact that her judicial career carries dozens of maximum sentences in cases involving political prisoners.
This time, the judge's name did not make headlines because of complaints of judicial irregularities filed by relatives of political prisoners. Her public reappearance was due to institutional reasons, as she was once again included in the list of 1,066 admitted candidates published this Friday, November 20, by the Judicial Nominations Committee of the National Assembly to renew the TSJ, after the restart of a process that had been frozen in June of this year.
López Mesa is the 27th Terrorism Trial Court judge in the city of Caracas, where the only courts of this kind, created in 2012, operate. Under her office fell the most emblematic cases of restrictions on freedom for political reasons, such as Operation Gedeón and the 2018 drone attack against Nicolás Maduro — case files for which dozens of people remain detained and whose relatives have denounced subjection to crimes against humanity, such as torture and cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment.
Who is the judge
Few details can be found about the judge. Her Wikipedia biography does not indicate where she studied, when she began working in the Venezuelan justice system, nor does it even include a photograph of her.
Her digital footprint is practically nonexistent: there are no traces of her professional profile on LinkedIn or of personal accounts on Instagram or Facebook. The only public references to her career come exclusively from the rulings and judicial documents bearing the lawyer's signature, which have been exposed by relatives of political prisoners.
On January 5, 2026, the NGO Realidad Helicoide published a photograph of the judicial candidate for the first time. The revelation of her face gained relevance because the most emblematic cases of alleged attacks against Nicolás Maduro fall under her court — files in which, according to complaints from human rights organizations such as Foro Penal and Justicia, Encuentro y Perdón, the accused lost hope of freedom amid trials plagued by irregularities.
From Realidad Helicoide, they pointed out that López Mesa acted under the influence of Cilia Flores, Nicolás Maduro's wife. Following the events of January 3, which included a United States military incursion into Venezuela, the NGO reported that the judge "can no longer hide behind institutional anonymity. Her name and her face join in a single truth: she is an active accomplice to the worst crimes against humanity."
The organization added that, even if it is argued that the judge was only following orders from superiors, "orders do not exempt from guilt when they are executed with such care. She heard prisoners recount the torture they suffered and, even so, she signed. Not once or twice, but dozens of times," the text reads.
López Mesa's actions were also documented in the reports of the UN Independent International Fact-Finding Mission on Venezuela, where she is identified by first and last name within the analysis of the pattern of irregularities in the special terrorism courts and the lack of investigation into complaints of torture against detainees.
The maximum sentences handed down by the judge
The institutional conduct of Judge López Mesa, at the head of the First Special First-Instance Trial Court with jurisdiction over cases linked to crimes associated with terrorism at the national level, accumulates the judicial prosecution and conviction of at least 49 people for political reasons, which we have been able to record at Efecto Cocuyo.
Her management of this specialized court stands out for the repeated imposition of the maximum penalty of 30 years in prison, the use of collective sentences, and the dismissal of complaints about physical and medical violations against the defendants under her judicial custody.
López Mesa's role gained particular relevance in the criminal proceedings against Emirlendris Benítez, a merchant detained on August 5, 2018. During the trial, the defense and the defendant's relatives consistently denounced that Benítez suffered torture and cruel treatment that caused her a miscarriage at four months of pregnancy, as well as serious physical aftereffects that confined her to a wheelchair due to spinal damage and biopolymer infiltration.
The judge maintained a policy of restrictions regarding Benítez's health, systematically denying transfer authorizations for consultations with trusted specialist doctors. Likewise, after an evaluation carried out at the José María Vargas Hospital by a neurosurgeon, the judge withheld the official medical report without allowing access to the document to either relatives or defense attorneys, finally issuing a guilty verdict on August 4, 2022, after a prolonged procedural delay.
In the early hours of that same August 4, 2022, López Mesa issued a verdict in the drones case, the alleged assassination attempt against Nicolás Maduro that occurred in 2018, imposing the maximum penalty of 30 years in prison on 12 of the 17 defendants in the case.
This group that received the maximum penalty was made up of Juan Carlos Monasterios, Argenis Valera, José Miguel Estrada, Oswaldo Castillo, Alberto Bracho, Brayan Oropeza, Henribert Rivas, Yolmer Escalona, the aforementioned Emirlendris Benítez, Yanin Pernía, National Guard Major General Alejandro Pérez Gámez, and Colonel Pedro Zambrano.
For the five remaining citizens, the judge set lesser sentences distributed as follows: 24 years in prison for Ángela Expósito, 20 years for José Eloy Rivas, 16 years for General Héctor Hernández Da Costa, 8 years for former deputy Juan Requesens, and 5 years for Wilder Vásquez. Additionally, in the same ruling, the judge ordered the capture and international extradition requests for Julio Borges, Osman Delgado Tabosky, Adriana Bronbin, Virginia Da Silva, Rayder Russo, Josser López, Yilbert Escalona, Gregorio Yaguas, and David Beaumont.
Months later, on December 9, 2022, under the same legal argument linked to the 2018 Bolívar Avenue event, the First Court against Terrorism presided over by López Mesa issued a new collective guilty verdict. On this occasion, it once again imposed the maximum penalty of 30 years in prison on three citizens: Spanish national María Delgado Tabosky; her husband, retired Italian-national military officer Juan Carlos Marrufo; and retired Colonel Juan Francisco Rodríguez.
The specific grounds of the evidence supporting this decision were not publicly broken down by the court at the time of the ruling, adding to the previous case files questioned by the defense.
Added to that case file is the ruling issued on May 22, 2024, for the so-called Operation Gedeón, a proceeding in which López Mesa convicted 29 defendants to sentences of between 21 and 30 years in prison, imposing the maximum penalty on some twenty of them, among civilians and military personnel detained since 2020.
Based on the case files documented in these proceedings, the record of penalties issued by the judge yields a consolidated total of at least 49 citizens sentenced, the majority of whom received the maximum penalty of 30 years in prison. Her nomination now enters the period for citizen challenges that opens this Saturday, November 21, and will extend until December 5, before the National Assembly proceeds with the definitive appointment of the justices scheduled for December 11.
Author's note: Image taken from the Realidad Helicoide video. AI was used only to improve the resolution, without altering physical features.