Dogma vs. pragmatism: the dispute within Milei's orthodox government that intensifies with the latest noise from the plan

rss · La Nacion 2026-11-22T06:03:10Z es
Under Mauricio Macri's government, the dispute was between hawks and doves. Under Javier Milei's government, it is between hawks. There are the dogmatists, led by a president who becomes increasingly philosophical in his speeches, and the pragmatists, headed by Senator Patricia Bullrich. They all coexist under the umbrella of orthodoxy, but with every tremor in the libertarian program —in this latest stage, with country risk rising above one thousand points and a rising dollar— the differences over how to fight the electoral year are exacerbated. All officials converge on the idea that going for a "money plan" at this point would mean heading into disaster, into failure. Injecting funds into the street or subsidies is not even an option for this administration, which has made austerity its own emblem. That is why all wings of the ruling party agree that the margin for applying measures, or for change, is "minimal." However, the way of facing the coming months exposes differences in the discursive line of each of the parties. Over these weeks, in which it became known that 32,290 companies closed since the start of the administration through July, that inflation hit 2.2% in October, that country risk reached 1,070 points and the dollar $1,595, and that private estimates foresee a technical recession, Milei deepened his defense of his plan and of the anarcho-capitalist ideas with which he arrived at the Presidency. He said that Argentina is "on the verge of...
During Mauricio Macri's government, the dispute was between hawks and doves. In Javier Milei's government, it is between hawks. There are the dogmatists, led by a president who is increasingly philosophical in his speeches, and the pragmatists, headed by Senator Patricia Bullrich. They all coexist under the umbrella of orthodoxy, but with every tremor of the libertarian program —in this latest stage, with country risk rising above one thousand points and a rising dollar— the differences over how to fight the electoral year are exacerbated. All officials converge on the idea that going for a "money plan" at this point would mean going toward a disaster, a failure. Injecting funds into the street or subsidies is not even an option for this administration, which has made austerity its own emblem. That is why all wings of the ruling party agree that the margin for applying measures, or for change, is "minimal." However, the way of facing the coming months exposes differences in the discursive line of each of the parties. Over these weeks, in which it became known that 32,290 companies closed from the start of the administration through July, that inflation came in at 2.2% in October, that country risk reached 1,070 points and the dollar $1,595, and that private estimates foresee a technical recession, Milei deepened his defense of his plan and of the anarcho-capitalist ideas with which he arrived at the Presidency. He said that Argentina is "on the doorstep of a golden liberal century" and that he will be reelected in the first round. He defended unrestricted economic openness. He stated that Argentina has an openness coefficient of 30%, but promised it will go to one of 90%. He said that brands must compete because that "brings order, fosters investment, and lowers prices," and so that domestic production "specializes, exports, and is sustainable over time." He venerated Adam Smith, Friedrich Hayek, Milton Friedman, Jesús Huerta de Soto. He asserted that liberals "do not talk about trickle-down effects" and that regulating "means killing increasing returns." He described himself as "a stoic inspired by King Solomon." Milei, during the event in La Boca for Tesla's arrival in Argentina CapturaMilei is clinging to his method, as is his Deregulation Minister, Federico Sturzenegger, the "colossus." The two feed each other with slogans from a theoretical world they share, which often inflames the spirits of another part of the Cabinet, more down-to-earth, but which does not dare to challenge Milei. "I don't know if the President is on another wavelength. He is convinced that this is the way. We have to see whether people will keep believing," justifies an official from the pragmatic wing. From the ministry most influenced by Milei, Economy Minister Luis Caputo defends the plan to the hilt in the media and on social networks, and looks for external factors to explain the setbacks, although government sources say that he and his team are thinking about what actions could be executed. Bullrich, a politician to the core, does not wear herself out over liberal theory but over how to win the elections in 2027, amid polls that put the government in very tight numbers with Peronism. The senator is convinced that measures must start being announced now, which will take shape throughout this year until the elections. Her moves make noise, but she does not intend to stop. Yesterday she published a video that is the "intro" of other materials with her idea of an "economy closer to the people," always within orthodoxy. Behind closed doors, according to what LA NACION was able to find out, Bullrich tells her own people that work must be done on the interest rate, on the taxes paid by lagging sectors —such as industry and construction— that Argentina's level of openness with China should be reviewed, whether it is the same as with Brazil and Europe, when China "steamrolls any country in the world," among other matters. "There are certain things you have to put in perspective. Argentine companies are carrying 60 kilos on their backs and are different from the companies over there, which are on anabolics," she was heard saying —more or less in these words— by people who were with her. Focused on moving social media and making material that also reaches an audience different from the one she already won over when she was a Cambiemos minister, Bullrich has added new, young people to her team. There are economic advisors with whom she speaks frequently about the problems and the solutions she has in her head. Her people say she had a conversation or two with Carlos Melconian, but that he is not the one advising her, nor will he be. Melconian has already said he wants to be president, and Bullrich does not share leadership. "Argentina has two universes [the government and Kirchnerism]. Patricia is in one and proposes measures within her universe. But it is clear what is happening: what she says is different from what Milei says," says someone who knows her perfectly. At the government's political table, Bullrich is not the only one thinking about a relaxation of the program within the parameters of fiscal order. But, for the moment, she remains the only one who dares to say it out loud. Three or four more officials join her, who very quietly acknowledge that pragmatism is needed to win the election. "On the record nobody speaks, some do off the record, but it doesn't help much. There comes a point when everyone says 'we'll win in the first round,'" they complain in the Bullrich camp. Among the officials who believe decisions must be pushed forward, but who choose not to get involved in Economy Minister Luis Caputo's territory (and therefore even less in Milei's), there are nuances with Bullrich regarding timing. The government's political table PresidenciaShe considers that a scheme of announcements toward 2027 should begin now, even with a plan for the years that would involve reelection. Other members of the Cabinet argue that, since the margin of maneuver to not alter fiscal balance is limited, time must be managed and the measures must not be "burned" a year before going to the polls. "It is clear that relief measures must be applied, but when? One must be patient because there are not many possibilities within fiscal balance. And what if we burn the bandwidth too early? It is a great dilemma. One must be precise about the moment," sketches an internal source. They say that General Secretary Karina Milei is aware of the noises and the dissimilar outlooks, but stays on the sidelines. "She does not make statements about the economic program because, within the management of the government, she knows that is not something she defines; the President defines it," says a voice that backs her. Karina Milei at a Christmas fair for entrepreneurs at the Palacio Duhau PresidenciaNevertheless, already in the race toward 2027, Karina Milei is raising her profile and accelerating her appearances at events to get closer to the people. They seek to position her as a complement to her brother. "She is going out into the street to listen. Of course we know that she goes to organized settings that do not represent all of reality, but the reception is good," enthuses another official from her inner circle. By Paula Rossi

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Knowledge Graph

Entities
Highlight