The saxophonist who secretly recorded the ‘magic’ of John Coltrane in the early 1960s

rss · EL PAIS 2026-11-22T04:00:00Z en
John Coltrane solo on stage in a tiny club of barely 100 people, in the early 1960s. Blowing his saxophone facing the wall, not looking at the audience. Experimenting without limits, free, in a kind of intimacy. Exhausted after an interminable solo. These are the images etched on Frank Tiberi’s retina — then a 32-year-old saxophonist who played clubs in Philadelphia and worked as a hired musician in city musicals. What Coltrane could do left him astonished. “I wanted to learn from him, as all musicians do,” the now-98-year-old Tiberi says by phone from his cabin outside Boston. Tiberi was sure very early on that this man named Coltrane was destined for greatness. He had already seen him perform live as a member of Miles Davis’s quintet in the late 1950s. The freedom with which the author of Giant Steps improvised was astonishing. When Coltrane began playing with his own band in the early 1960s — after overcoming his heroin and alcohol addiction and embracing a spirituality that would shape his work — Tiberi wanted to capture his magic, drink from it, trap it so he could deconstruct and analyze it. That summer of 1960 he bought a portable tape recorder, a Concertone TR-100 Transicorder fitted with a small microphone, and began following Coltrane through the small Philadelphia and New York clubs where he played. He would sit in the front rows, or near a speaker. With his recorder covered by a cloth bag placed on his lap, he would slip the microphone under his coat. Those furtive recordings, hidden for 60 years and around which a small legend had grown, now see the light in an edition that Impulse/Universal released on November 6, as part of that profitable inclination to dig through archives to rescue historical documents. A heads-up: the music heard on the Tiberi Tapes is of questionable quality. The recordings are diffuse, murky, somewhat muffled. They occasionally pick up the clink of glasses, laughter, or conversations from people nearby. But they capture, critics and experts say, all the magic of Coltrane in the early 1960s. “He played the songs each time in a different way,” Tiberi recalls. “It was really exciting to watch him.” “I kept those recordings to myself for a long time — I was very selfish,” he admits. Frank Tiberi made the recordings between 1960 and 1964, in the years before A Love Supreme, Coltrane’s masterpiece, when the North Carolina–born saxophonist was beginning to drift toward free jazz. Tiberi remembers that the clubs he frequented in those days were small, with bench seating and not even any tables. There was no cover charge, drinks cost a dollar, and Coltrane had not yet become the legendary figure he is now. Waiters walked along the benches to take orders, and Tiberi had to be careful not to be caught recording. He developed a rare skill: flipping the tape over blindly without taking the recorder out of the bag. You could record a maximum of 30 minutes per side. He accumulated 80 tapes containing around 26 hours of music. He kept them safe at his home for many years and at first showed them to no one. “I was worried they might be stolen,” he confesses, “I had to keep an eye on them.” Gradually he loosened up and began showing them to musicians he toured with on bus trips — among them colleagues from the Woody Herman Orchestra, the band he would later lead from the late 1980s after Herman passed the baton. He showed them to major players; saxophonists such as Joe Lovano and George Garzone. Thus the buzz around the recordings began to grow. Tiberi is a musician with a long career of his own behind him. He started young, at age eight, playing the clarinet. He later switched to tenor sax. At 15 he had to play live to bring money home: “My father died, we had to support the family.” By 20 he was already a member of a band, Bob Chester’s. In the 1950s he was playing with jazzmen such as Benny Goodman and Dizzy Gillespie. He has worked as a session musician and been in several bands throughout his career. He still plays at 98. He did so just a month ago, he says enthusiastically, at the Mad Monkfish in Cambridge, Massachusetts. He also continues to teach at the Berklee College of Music in Boston. Over the years his students were among the privileged few to hear those old Coltrane recordings. They also helped the legend around the Tiberi Tapes grow. Stacked in boxesKen Druker remembers perfectly the first time he accessed the tapes. It was 2000 and the current vice president of the Verve Label Group was already living in New York. He had just started working at the legendary company. Druker today has a job many jazz lovers would dream of: he digs through archives and dusts off old recordings. A friend who had played in the Woody Herman Orchestra told him that Tiberi wanted to contact the label to discuss doing something with those old recordings. It was in early 2001 when Tiberi showed up at the New York offices carrying his boxes. “They weren’t shoeboxes, but they looked like them!” Druker recalls, laughing, in a video call. The first thing they told Tiberi was that the tapes had to be saved — transferred to a digital format. And so they did. They went to studios the company had in Edison, New Jersey, and worked all weekend transferring the tapes to CD. Ravi Coltrane, the legendary saxophonist’s son, stopped by the studio. They made copies and tried to reach an agreement, but releasing the material was ultimately discarded. The sound quality wasn’t good enough. At that time vinyl hadn’t yet returned with the force it has now, streaming hadn’t arrived, and the only way to release it was on CD. They decided it wasn’t the right moment to do so. But sound technology has evolved in recent years. Engineers now have tools that didn’t exist at the turn of the century to remove noise and improve quality. To publish the recordings around the artist’s centenary — he was born on September 23, 1926 — they explored the possibility of using AI, but ultimately did not resort to the “Beatles solution,” as Druker puts it, referring to the Beatles’ song Now and Then, released in 2023 and reconstructed with the help of artificial intelligence. By 2026, moreover, they had several channels (streaming, vinyl, CD) to market the recordings. And the rights issue posed no problems. Coltrane was an Impulse artist during the years Tiberi recorded him, and both his widow, Alice Coltrane, and his son, Ravi Coltrane, agreed. Druker points out that the Tiberi Tapes allow listeners to hear a very different John Coltrane from other live recordings released. In that period he was experimenting in those small clubs; there is “an intimacy” not seen on other records. The recordings that now come to light include pieces such as a rendition of the fiendish, vertiginous Giant Steps played at a slightly slower tempo — 228 bpm — which lets Coltrane take a more melodic solo. There is also a recording of one of the movements of A Love Supreme. Until now, Druker says, the mythology around the recording of that album described Coltrane arriving at the studio with charts none of his musicians had seen, which they received on the day of the December 1964 session. Well, on the Tiberi Tapes there is audio of one movement of A Love Supreme, Resolution, recorded on September 18, 1964 at Pep’s, a club in Philadelphia — three months before entering the studio. The band performing is his canonical lineup, with McCoy Tyner on piano, Elvin Jones on drums and Jimmy Garrison on bass. That night they played Resolution in a different key than the album, in B-flat.“Perhaps the problem with these recordings, given their sound deficiencies, is that they don’t allow us to appreciate the spontaneous interaction among the musicians and the breakdown of traditional roles for each instrument,” explains Mariano Peyrou, writer and poet devoted to Coltrane who published the essay Free Jazz. The Blackest Music in the World two years ago and who had known about the Tiberi Tapes for some time. “We hear Coltrane, but not the timbral subtleties of his sax. And, more importantly, the double bass is not audible, nor are the low frequencies of the drums and piano, so the interactive element is captured unsatisfactorily.” Still, the value of the recordings as a historical document, as testimony of an era, is undeniable. “For me,” Peyrou adds, “Coltrane is an absolute model of what an artist should be. He is utterly personal, has his own language and never stops evolving. He has an astonishing level of introspection,” and that combines with an enormous capacity to connect with others. Tiberi had no personal relationship with Coltrane. He remembers greeting him once, when the genius — taken by liver cancer at 40 — was stowing his sax in McCoy Tyner’s car trunk; Tyner was a pianist Tiberi did know and whom he called on several times during his career to play live. At 98, the veteran saxophonist still lives outside Boston, Massachusetts, and attends his Berklee classes once a week. “I live alone,” he says, “I have a small cabin, I’m in a protected area, I’m content.” He leads a quiet life: he likes to cook, mow the lawn, and rake the dead leaves in the yard. “Coltrane, for me, is the epitome of the saxophonist,” he states. “Everyone followed him in those years, and now, you know, just mentioning him makes people raise their eyebrows.”Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition
Highlight