The end of the week left Peronism with two key takeaways for understanding how it will face next year's electoral process. The first is that, although it has not yet been confirmed by Congress, in the PJ they take it as a given that the PASO primaries will be suspended. This will force them to organize an internal party election or reach a unity agreement. The second is that the Cristina Kirchner–Sergio Massa partnership is stronger than ever and that this tandem will begin to build an alternative to Axel Kicillof in parallel.
The event in San Fernando, where different strands of Peronism came together and in which Massa took center stage, was a watershed in the electoral landscape through which the opposition is moving. On one side were the Frente Renovador, the PJ Federal, the League of Mayors, the Cristina Kirchner wing, and some unaffiliated figures. On the other side were Axel Kicillof and the MDF, along with the support of Juan Grabois.
Within that enormous group of leaders, there are some who are not irreversibly tied to either of the two structures. Especially among those who went to San Fernando. They operate under the roof of an identity with which they feel better represented, but they are not absolute members of a new political scheme. They understand that the gathering served to show Peronism in motion and that this adds greater dynamism to the opposition's debate.
There are leaders who left the Teatro Otamendi very pleased with what happened, and others who did not, who without...
AI Brief
Your highlights
The end of the week left Peronism with two determining keys for understanding how it will face next year's electoral process. The first is that, although it has not yet been confirmed by Congress, in the PJ they take it for granted that the PASO primaries will be suspended. This will force them to organize an internal party election or reach a unity agreement. The second is that the Cristina Kirchner–Sergio Massa alliance is stronger than ever and that this tandem will begin to build an alternative in parallel to Axel Kicillof. The event in San Fernando, where different currents of Peronism came together and in which Massa was at the center of the scene, was a watershed in the electoral landscape the opposition is navigating. On one side were the Frente Renovador, PJ Federal, La Liga de Intendentes, Cristinism, and some loose actors. On the other side were Axel Kicillof and the MDF, plus the support of Juan Grabois. Within that enormous group of leaders, there are some who are not irreversibly tied to either of the two structures. Above all among those who went to San Fernando. They move under the roof of an identity with which they feel more represented, but they are not absolute parts of a new political scheme. They understand that the gathering served to show Peronism in motion and that this brings greater dynamism to the opposition's discussion.
The San Fernando photo generated noise within Peronism and contributed to the discussion about the national construction of the opposition
There are leaders who left very pleased with what happened at the Otamendi Theater, and others who did not, who felt that such a politically powerful photo was not the most convenient thing and only widened the rift within Buenos Aires Peronism. That is what the governor of La Rioja, Ricardo Quintela, foresaw in advance, and what motivated him to decline the invitation. There are many stories within the story that began to be told in San Fernando. In practice, it served to show the convergence of sectors that have an important and influential volume of votes, and for that display to bear the stamp of diversity and federalism. But it was also a gathering of leaders, of politics, of those who often speak in internal code. What became most visible at that gathering was the strength of the CFK–Massa agreement, which left Kicillof on the margins of that conglomerate. Beyond the back-and-forth about whether he was invited or not, through two heavyweights of the MDF like Gabriel Katopodis and Mariano Cascallares, at last Tuesday's event it became clear that the implicit intention was to send a message to the Buenos Aires governor. They told him, without saying it, that he is not alone on the path to the presidential candidacy. The promotion of Guillermo Michel to the Council of the Magistracy and the backing of the San Fernando event made visible that the political agreement between the former president and the former minister has no cracks. In Cristinism they maintain that this agreement is the same one founded in 2018, when the Frente de Todos began to be woven together, and that the only difference is that Kicillof decided to break away and build his own space. "Everything else remains in the same place. Even with some new actors. The one who left is him," they specified.
The agreement between Sergio Massa and Cristina Kirchner is solid and will be decisive in the electoral year
The other message the event left is that within that fusion of leaders there are, at least, three presidential pre-candidates. Massa said publicly that they are Sergio Uñac, Gerardo Zamora, and Natalia de la Sota. To that list, and inevitably in first place, he himself is added. "Axel doesn't do politics. He doesn't contain anyone. He doesn't even contain his own people. He holds events with the most stale figures of the conurbano and constantly plays the victim," was the verdict of one of the national deputies who was in San Fernando. That has a correlation among the leadership that organized last Tuesday's Peronist gathering. Whatever Kicillof fails to contain will, sooner or later, be embraced by the fusion between Massa, Kirchnerism, and PJ Federal. The division, based in the province of Buenos Aires, was clearly marked. For Peronism there is one more problem added to that fragmentation, which is the very possible suspension of the PASO primaries. This time, and after several months, the Government seems to have secured the votes to do away with an electoral tool that for the PJ is key, because it could have allowed them to settle their differences through votes.
Axel Kicillof maintains his plan of action and his electoral roadmap (REUTERS/Pedro Lazaro Fernandez)
Without PASO, the option that begins to gain strength is unity by consensus. There is no generalized conviction in Justicialism regarding the possibility of organizing an internal party election. Whether by region, as Sergio Uñac proposed, or in the traditional format. Very few see viability in organizing a party dispute. The barriers they encounter have to do with financing, organization, agreements on the rules of the electoral game, the voter rolls of the political parties that make up the coalition, the impact that low voter turnout could have on the path forward, the legitimacy and transparency of the elections, the oversight, and the multiplication of the dialectical battle between the different tribes. But above all, what many leaders see is that people are not interested in being part of an electoral process. "Are we going to tell citizens that they have to go choose the best opposition candidate? The PASO or the internal election is a problem of politics, not of the people," reflected an important voice within La Cámpora.
The San Fernando event resonated in the Buenos Aires landscape and in the national discussion of Peronism
The only option being evaluated in terms of an internal election is organizing an open party primary, with the national voter roll, and financially sustained with funds that must be gathered from contributors. That idea was championed by Agustín Rossi and Victoria Tolosa Paz in the public debate, and it is an option circulating in the Buenos Aires governor's office. This Friday, in an interview with Letra P, Kicillof's Chief of Staff, Carlos Bianco, stated: "If Peronism is not capable of organizing an internal election, let's dedicate ourselves to something else." For Peronism, it was important to legitimize its next candidate through votes because the fragmentation of the space is very large. And after the last elections, in which Cristina Kirchner played a leading role, what looms in 2027 is an election where the decision-making table has more actors, because the former president's influence over the whole is no longer what it was. Among those actors there is one who is preponderant: Axel Kicillof. Certain that they will not have PASO, in several sectors of Justicialism they believe it is necessary to begin discussing, as soon as possible, how the space will be organized. On the horizon appears the possibility of a new Peronist summit, like those at the Hotel Emperador and the Casa de La Pampa, before the end of the year, to define an alternative path for determining the tool with which candidates will be selected. At the end of this week, Kicillof finished confirming what he had long been chewing over. He will have to walk alone with the MDF until the negotiation prior to next year's elections. The San Fernando conglomerate is targeting him for not containing and for not leading. They do not see him as a presidential candidate. The end of the story is impossible to know at this point in the year. There is an endless row of ellipses ahead.