The final sign that the relationship was definitively broken came via WhatsApp. As soon as Carolina Rossi said goodbye to her colleagues at the Ministry of Science after the government accepted her resignation, Ximena Lincolao removed her from the coordination group. It was the epilogue of a partnership that had begun with an invitation to join the Executive branch and ended with two irreconcilable visions of the country's science policy.
But the rupture did not happen overnight. The second undersecretary to resign in eight months, after Rafael Araos, traces the first differences back to when she began to notice that the minister's technology bet did not necessarily align with the needs of academia and the scientific community. After the dismissal of one of her closest advisors, Rossi began to consider leaving.
How did you meet the minister?
We saw each other at an event in the U.S. and we had each other on LinkedIn, but I didn't know her until I arrived at the ministry. We had never worked together until she contacted me to join the Division of Emerging Technologies. That was in April.
When did you begin to consider resigning, and what was the reason?
On October 23, when Nicolás Fuenzalida, my direct advisor and a great source of support, was let go. Operationally, it made things considerably more difficult.
But did the crisis come before that?
I don't like to talk about a crisis, since my differences with the minister have to do with c…
AI Brief
Your highlights
The last sign that the relationship was definitively broken came via WhatsApp. As soon as Carolina Rossi said goodbye to her colleagues at the Ministry of Science after the government accepted her resignation, Ximena Lincolao removed her from the coordination group. It was the epilogue of a working relationship that had begun with an invitation to join the Executive and ended with two irreconcilable visions of the country's science policy. But the rupture did not happen overnight. The second undersecretary to resign in eight months, after Rafael Araos, traces the first differences back to when she began to notice that the minister's technological bet did not necessarily align with the needs of academia and the scientific community. After the dismissal of one of her closest advisors, Rossi began to consider her departure. How did you meet the minister? We saw each other at an event in the U.S. and we had each other on LinkedIn, but I didn't know her until I arrived at the ministry. We had never worked together until she contacted me to join the Emerging Technologies Division. That was in April. When did you begin to consider resigning, and what was the reason? On October 23, when Nicolás Fuenzalida, my direct advisor and a great source of support, was let go. Operationally, it made things considerably harder. Carolina Rossi, former Undersecretary of Science. But did the crisis come from earlier? I don't like to talk about a crisis, since the differences I have with the minister have to do with how we understand public policy in the area we are operating in, which has to do with the connection with the science academia, and with building this long-term strategy. This had been becoming more visible since mid-August, when I began to see that we have different visions. And did you discuss this with La Moneda before resigning? At some point I approached La Moneda to raise this concern and I received support to see how it could be resolved. And I believe that materialized with the arrival of Carolina Calvo. I had no prior information or access regarding the signing of the agreement (with OpenAI). It may be an agreement that is fundamentally correct, but I did not like not having known this information in detail before it came out in the press. Did you have the opportunity to talk about this with the president? I never spoke with him directly. Nor did it seem appropriate, because I am someone who follows the proper channels. Beyond that, I am deeply grateful for the president's support and also for his having appointed me. Did La Moneda do enough to resolve this situation? It is not for me to say that, but I did feel supported. I do consider it important to emphasize that my resignation was voluntary and due to technical differences with the minister. How would you describe the minister's leadership style, and what differences are there with yours? I respect the minister's leadership style; I have a different one and, for that reason, I realized I had to step aside. They are different approaches to how to execute a public policy so that it materializes. The biggest difference is that I do not agree with her vision of the world of technology. There are many points on which we also agreed, but on the central ones we have different visions. What is the minister's vision of technology? The ministry should have forged certain lines that align more with academia and the scientific community, which perhaps I would have strengthened a bit more. Her predecessor also resigned over differences with the minister. Is there a pattern in the relationship with undersecretaries? My main reason for leaving is the difference in vision. I was not aware of those dismissals; I found out that same day, just as they were happening. There were also dismissals of people close to you. Those are not matters for me to answer; what matters is that I am leaving calmly, happy to have been in an atomic ministry, with very good people. What are those fundamental differences with the minister? There are two types of innovation: incremental and disruptive. The first is very well embodied in the European ecosystem. It is slower and more gradual than the U.S. or China, but it has a very strong connection with academia, which links with researchers who then connect it to industry. And the disruptive kind is the one we have seen very present in recent years, which uses technology as an enabler. I support technology, but there was a lack of space for deep conversation with academia and scientists; because if that is not done, at some point the link will break. Is there any initiative that has been postponed or compromised by the differences in visions? I am anxious to know what will happen with the National Quantum Action Plan and the National Biotechnology Action Plan, which were to be launched in the coming days. I care that the ministry continues to function properly and I trust that it will. Carolina Rossi and Ximena Lincolao Did you agree with the arrangement with OpenAI? I had no prior information or access regarding the signing of the agreement. It may be an agreement that is fundamentally correct, but I did not like not having known this information in detail before it came out in the press. Were you aware of the dismissals of officials, as the minister publicly stated? I was not aware of those dismissals; I found out that same day, just as they were happening. What are your future plans? I have received some options from Europe regarding the harmonization of public policies in these areas, and I will most likely return to academia. I have already received an option to join a council. I would like to remain connected to strengthening our natural laboratories and how, from the regions, we can link these spaces where there is high-level talent. I would love to stay in Chile and try to increase this link between the global south and Europe.