Senator Juan Luis Castro (PS) and the signatures case: "I reiterated what Paulina Vodanovic had requested, that the processing of the procedure be initiated"
As a "difficult and tense" week with "consequences I never would have expected." That is how the head of the Democratic Socialism parliamentary committee, Senator Juan Luis Castro (PS), describes the fallout from his decision to withdraw the constitutional leaves of absence, in the context of the Budget Law debate, from senators Fidel Espinoza (PS) and Ximena Órdenes (IND.-PPD), who were accompanying President José Antonio Kast on his Asian tour and claimed they had not given their authorization.
The incident triggered a deepening of the crisis between the PS and the PPD, harsh criticism from the governing coalition, an ex officio investigation by the Public Prosecutor's Office, and a criminal lawsuit against him over possible signature forgery.
But Castro says he has no fear of the Public Prosecutor's Office inquiry, and while he acknowledges an "internal communications" error, he rules out any wrongdoing.
In this interview, he reconstructs the step-by-step account of the events, responsibilities, and political consequences.
When and how did you decide to withdraw the senators' constitutional leaves of absence?
It should be noted that constitutional leaves of absence are a provision that applies when a member of parliament travels abroad for more than 30 days, for the purposes of congressional quorums (...). In the committee meeting, the order of the voting items was established, which was the traditional one. At the moment the floor session began, on Tuesday, a change in the order of voting occurred.
AI Brief
Your highlights
Like a "difficult and tense" week with "consequences I never would have expected." That is how the head of the Democratic Socialism parliamentary committee, Senator Juan Luis Castro (PS), describes the fallout from his decision to withdraw the constitutional permissions of senators Fidel Espinoza (PS) and Ximena Órdenes (IND.-PPD), who were accompanying President José Antonio Kast on his Asian tour and claimed they had not given their authorization, in the context of the Budget Law discussions. The incident triggered a deepening of the crisis between the PS and the PPD, harsh criticism from the governing coalition, an ex officio investigation by the Public Prosecutor's Office, and a criminal complaint against him for possible forgery of signatures. But Castro says he has no fear of the Public Ministry's inquiry, and while he acknowledges an "internal communications" error, he rules out any wrongdoing. In this interview, he reconstructs the step-by-step account of events, responsibilities, and political consequences.
When and how did you decide to withdraw the senators' constitutional permissions?
Let me clarify that constitutional permissions are a mechanism that applies when a member of parliament travels abroad for more than 30 days, for the purposes of congressional quorums (...). In the committee meeting, the order of the budget items was established, which was the traditional one. At the moment the chamber session began, on Tuesday, a change in the order of voting occurred.
What happened then?
I arrive at my seat, and next to me was Paulina Vodanovic (president of the PS), who tells me that they had just altered the order of voting and would start from the last item. That the fiscal debt measure had to be voted on and that there were quorum problems, who knows. So (Paulina) told me she had spoken with the administrative coordinator of the caucus, Javier Sánchez, so that he could look into this, and that we would have to revoke the permissions of those who were abroad. I was a bit surprised by the situation that was unfolding, that is, the presiding table was moving forward with the voting. And I go to the socialist committee and ask the coordinator whether it was true that Paulina Vodanovic had told him this. He said yes, that he was reviewing it. I tell him, well, then proceed to process it, under the rules of the game, which are obviously the respective consultation with the interested parties themselves.
Did you speak with the senators afterward?
That night I contact Ximena Órdenes via messaging, I explain this to her, and I got the impression that she understood. She told me it 'could be something more than a misunderstanding,' sent greetings, put a heart in the message. We were left at ease, because this is an administrative matter.
What happened after that?
The next day I arrive at the chamber. That is when the revocation becomes known. By the way, it is the chamber that accepts or rejects the permissions—I want to be emphatic about this—it is not the committee head who decides. And at no point in the chamber did anyone, whether from the PPD committee or the governing coalition, say that objections should be raised. The items were dispatched with the agreement of the entire chamber. But a letter arrives at the presiding table, a complaint from Ximena Órdenes, saying that she had not authorized it and wanted it to be placed on record.
And what did you tell the President of the Senate?
I told her to see what was appropriate. She tells me this has been sorted out, but a moment later Senator (Pedro) Araya enters the chamber, asks for the floor, and announces that he is going to read a letter, which was from Ximena Órdenes. On that basis, Senator (Rodolfo) Carter intervenes, saying that this could constitute a crime.
But did your committee and Senator Vodanovic know about your action?
Vodanovic and I knew. And I was the one who instructed the coordinator, reiterating what Paulina (Vodanovic) had already asked him, to begin processing the procedure. The processing requires, since it is done through the administrative channel, communication with the interested parties, to validate the entire procedure. A situation that in this case was delayed, and I was informed later that it had not been completed during the course of the afternoon. And therefore, I immediately revoked what had initially been started.
Senator Órdenes nevertheless decided to send her letter—do you know why?
No, because apart from the text messaging I have not had a direct dialogue with her (...). So that this is clearly understood, it is not that they are always putting their signature down. Each senator has a pool of digital signatures that are placed at the disposal of the committee leadership for all pertinent contingencies. That is the modus operandi.
So, a common practice?
The committees have the powers, the authority to represent their members of parliament before the presiding table in the relevant agreements. That is why senators make an act of direct trust.
So this has been used before?
Many times. There has been talk here of forgery of signatures. There has never been any manipulation or forgery of a signature here. The procedure establishes a availability of digitized signatures, which each senator gives to their committee. I categorically rule out that there was, on my part or anyone's, any manipulation or impersonation of signatures, because that does not exist in the Senate. What happened here, as the coordinating head informed me, was an inability to contact the senators who were in Asia due to the time difference. And, in that circumstance, having been informed that this consent had not been possible, I withdrew everything.
From the governing coalition they accused a lack of fair play, and even the Vice President, Claudio Alvarado, spoke of a situation of "maximum gravity."
Things are being blown out of proportion when an internal and administrative procedure is called into question. There can be disagreements within a committee, but to take this to the level of an illegal act is absolutely detached from reality.
Would you describe the situation as a mistake? Would you do it again?
A situation arose, internally and administratively, that could have been handled better (...). But there was never any manipulation of any signature, because that is not my style, it is not my way. I have ethical commitments to the principles that guide parliamentary action. My history, moreover, is unblemished in that regard. I have nothing to hide and nothing to be ashamed of. Here, unfortunately, a misunderstanding occurred, but around it there was a political skirmish that, frankly, I do not know what it responds to. Senator Araya has probably had wounds that reflect, in some way, an antagonistic attitude.
Are you saying that, after what happened with his departure from the Constitution Committee?
I would not want to imagine that this could be a payback or a settling of scores.
What do you think about the fact that, as a result of this situation, an ex officio investigation was opened at the Public Prosecutor's Office?
There was also a criminal complaint. It is truly regrettable. When the justice system enters into a matter of political definitions or agreements, moreover within the same caucus, what is being judicialized is something that belongs purely to the internal coexistence of the parties, which is not something that establishes crimes or illegalities. Accusations have been made here that I see as absolutely irresponsible and reckless. Therefore, I have no fear; on the contrary, I am rather willing to do whatever is pertinent to help ensure that the facts are investigated, facts that will be far from constituting any crime.
Would you have liked greater support from your committee?
Look, there have been very telling opinions, like that of Senator Espinoza himself, who is on the trip, and he has been very explicit in pointing out the nature of a misunderstanding.
There has nonetheless been a reputational cost for you—do you not intend to resign from the committee leadership?
I am not clinging to any position. I will meet with them next week, with the entire committee, including the senators who were abroad. If there is support, I continue; if there is no support, I step aside. But I have no prior will of my own. I prefer, first, to talk.