By declaring two articles of mega-decree 70/2023, signed by Javier Milei at the start of his term, unconstitutional, the Supreme Court added a new case to the short list of rulings that invalidated, totally or partially, decrees issued by the Executive Branch. From the 1994 constitutional reform until the end of 2025, more than 970 necessity-and-urgency decrees were signed, and on only 18 occasions did the Supreme Court declare their content unconstitutional, according to a survey compiled by Gustavo Arballo, a doctor of law and constitutionalist, published in August and updated following the new ruling. For the expert, this, combined with other factors, such as the oversight system established by law, creates a scenario that ends up functioning as an "incentive" for presidents to resort to DNUs. "The system not only normalizes, but actually encourages a route that should be highly restrictive," notes the author of the study. Alberto Fernández signed 179 necessity-and-urgency decrees, Mauricio Macri 71, and Cristina Kirchner 81. Other data from the research help put the Court's decision in context. Until this Thursday, Milei could boast, along with Cristina Kirchner, that all of his decrees remained in force. Now, that distinction—for the moment—belongs solely to the former president, who spent the most time in the Executive Branch. Time had been working in Milei's favor: recent history shows that the Court generally takes several years to declare a DNU unconstitutional. According to Arballo's survey, the median time elapsed between the signing of the decrees and the rulings that invalidated them was 48 months, the equivalent of a full presidential term. That delay is another of the factors that, according to Arballo, contribute to the system ultimately encouraging the use of DNUs. Arballo is a professor at the National University of La Pampa. In the case of Milei's mega-decree, signed in December 2023, almost three years passed. During that time, the rule remained in force, even though the Senate had rejected it in March 2024. With the high court's ruling, Milei joined the group of five presidents who received that judicial setback while still in power. The other four are Carlos Menem, Fernando de la Rúa, Eduardo Duhalde, and Alberto Fernández. The decree that most quickly received a setback from the Court was one by Alberto Fernández. In May 2021, just 19 days after the then president used that route to suspend in-person classes during the pandemic, the highest tribunal declared that the decision had violated the autonomy of the city of Buenos Aires. At the other end of this record is a decree by Menem on pension contributions of the Gendarmerie, which was invalidated in October 2021, 24 years after it was signed. "If one looks at the Court's overall performance regarding DNUs, one notices a strange combination: a rhetoric of strong oversight combined with a practice in which the judicial reaction leaves a great deal of leeway to the Executive Branch: the Court has issued few invalidations and, with exceptions, has done so taking its time, making it statistically rare for a decree to be declared unconstitutional within the very presidential term in which it was issued," Arballo assesses. The ruling The Court's recent ruling targets only two articles of DNU 70/2023, one of the main tools used by Milei to push forward economic reform programs. These are the provisions that eliminated the State's powers to control increases in the fees of private health insurance companies. However, the reasoning used by the Court, Arballo and other specialists point out, could extend to other aspects of the mega-decree, although the tribunal clarified that it was not ruling on the validity of the rest of its provisions. "In 'Bobbio' the Court reaffirms the guidelines set in 'Cencosud' and adds important criteria, especially regarding an anomalous and omnibus DNU such as DNU 70/23," the author maintains. As he explains, the high court considered that invoking a crisis in the health system and the need to improve the competitiveness of private insurers was a generic assertion, insufficient to justify the use of an exceptional legislative tool," highlights constitutionalist Lorena González Tocci. The so-called "omnibus" decrees, she notes, constitute "a form of abuse of the law" because they bring together a large number of reforms on matters that are unrelated to one another and modify or repeal numerous laws. "That is just one fact, easily verifiable, that shows there was neither necessity nor urgency in issuing them, given that it presupposes they were preceded by an in-depth study of that legislation, and therefore that task could well have been carried out by Congress, the natural repository of the legislative function," she warns. Hence the importance she attributes to the Supreme Court's ruling: "Generic invocations of crisis or emergency are not enough; there must be a concrete connection between the alleged urgency and each measure adopted," she emphasizes regarding the Court's decision. By Federico González del Solar