A nation of coffee lovers is losing its cafés

rss · La Repubblica 2026-11-21T05:00:00Z
Every day, 16 million people in Italy visit these “secular churches”, a cornerstone of neighbourhood life. Yet rising costs, changing consumer habits, the transformation of historic city centres and the expansion of international chains are threatening their survival
ROME – For more than two and a half centuries, people have been stepping into the Antico Caffè Greco on Rome’s Via dei Condotti, just a stone’s throw from the Spanish Steps, as if entering a museum where they could order a coffee. Opened in 1760 and frequented by Goethe, Byron, Stendhal and Baudelaire, it is Rome’s oldest café and a must-see for tourists. In October 2025, after an eight-year legal battle over the rent between the management and the property owners, the locks were changed. It has been closed ever since, and its future remains uncertain. Caffè Greco is the most high-profile case, but not the only one. In Florence, Harry’s Bar, a symbol of the city’s Dolce Vita frequented by stars such as Elizabeth Taylor and Paul Newman, was forced to leave its historic premises on Lungarno Vespucci in 2023 following an eviction, after 60 years at the same address. It remained closed for two years, reopening only in late 2025 in premises rented from a major hotel, bringing its original furnishings with it. The closed doors of Rome’s historic Antico Caffè Greco in a photograph taken in 2025 More than a place for coffee Behind these famous names, however, lies a much broader crisis affecting the everyday Italian café: the place where people have breakfast standing at the counter, order a cappuccino and a cornetto, buy cigarettes and catch up with their neighbours. Every day, 16 million people visit cafés in Italy, a country of 59 million inhabitants. And yet cafés are closing. According to an analysis by Fipe-Confcommercio, the federation representing cafés, bars and restaurants, the number of businesses operating in the sector has fallen to 124,917, down 1.5% in a year, compared with more than 148,000 in 2019. Since 2015, 21,741 establishments have either closed or been converted into other businesses. “Cafés are secular churches, places that foster social interaction and provide a sense of security,” explains Lino Enrico Stoppani, president of Fipe. “But they are very often the poor relation of the hospitality industry. Restaurants have received UNESCO recognition for Italian cuisine and are featured in gastronomic guides. Cafés have not.” Italians’ attachment to their cafés remains strong, and stands out even by European standards. A study commissioned by Heineken, covering nine European countries and involving around 9,000 respondents, ranks Italy first for the social value people attach to cafés. A young woman at the counter of Rome’s historic Antico Caffè Greco on Via dei Condotti in August 1958 The economics of an espresso The problem is the economics. The average spend per visit is €4.20, and more than 60% of customers come in for breakfast or a mid-morning break, the times when people spend the least. Every increase in the price of coffee, however, becomes a national controversy, industry insiders complain. “We spent the summer justifying price increases of just a few cents,” says Stoppani. “The cost of raw materials, rent and energy has increased. But when the price of coffee goes up, even though it is among the cheapest in Europe, it is treated almost as an act of lèse-majesté.” There are also structural reasons behind the crisis. In 2006, an Italian liberalisation reform known as the Bersani decree abolished the requirement for minimum distances between one establishment and another. The result, according to Stoppani, is an overcrowded market. “The more competition there is, the more there is to manage,” he says. “And if you manage it on price alone, there is no future.” Then there is competition from convenience stores and grocery shops selling coffee, sandwiches and alcoholic drinks without being subject to the same requirements as cafés. “A café must have toilet facilities proportionate to the services it offers, and in expensive cities like ours, that space comes at a cost,” he explains. “If you consider us important to society and to the country’s identity, at least give us the same rules as everyone else.” When tourists replace regulars The historic Sant’Eustachio Caffè in the heart of Rome is a favourite among tourists The crisis is also affecting, and perhaps above all, Italy’s historic cities of art. According to an analysis by Confesercenti, another business association, Rome lost 2,827 cafés and bars between 2019 and 2025, a decline of more than 30%. The trend has continued despite record tourist numbers. In historic city centres, neighbourhood cafés increasingly find themselves alongside establishments designed for people passing through, with prices, opening hours and menus tailored to visitors, while residents lose their familiar gathering places. Stoppani also emphasises the role cafés play for tourists. “Foreign visitors choose Italy for its beauty, but also for the quality of the services offered by its cafés, bars and restaurants, and cafés are part of that.” The question is what remains of that traditional café when those seeking it out are predominantly tourists, and who should be responsible for protecting it. The rise of international chains Meanwhile, the chains have arrived. For years, it was widely believed that they would never take root in Italy: why pay for a long coffee in a paper cup in the country of espresso served at the counter? It was Milan’s cafés, after all, that inspired Howard Schultz, the man who transformed Starbucks into a global giant in the 1980s. Yet the Seattle-based chain waited until 2018 to open in Italy, with a large roastery in central Milan, and did not arrive in Rome until 2023. Since then, its expansion has been rapid: in November 2024, Starbucks opened its first European flagship store in the Italian capital, an 800-square-metre space featuring a counter serving coffee-based cocktails. Today, it has more than 50 outlets across the country, from railway stations to outlet shopping centres. The market share of chains in Italy remains low: according to Bain & Company, they account for a tenth of the foodservice market, compared with just over a quarter in Europe and as much as 50% in the United Kingdom. But the gap is narrowing. According to Deloitte, between 2019 and 2025, chains in Italy grew by 7.2%, compared with just 0.6% for independent operators, the widest gap among all the regions of the world analysed. A new generation, new habits It is the younger generation that is changing the rules. For 32% of Italians, the traditional way of experiencing cafés has faded or disappeared, although 56% still recognise it. Young people are less inclined to visit cafés simply to be around others, and for Generation Z, international chains also count as cafés. Stoppani acknowledges that the sector has “so far failed to respond to” their changing tastes, from alcohol-free drinks to vegetarian options. In an effort to revitalise the sector, Fipe presented a “New Code of Etiquette for the Italian Café” at its Forum: six words intended to define its identity – quality, relationships, refreshment, furnishings, decorum and feeling. This article was reviewed by an external translation partner
Highlight