While maintaining the expectation of a call from the Government to resume dialogue, the CGT has on its agenda a proposal it will make to the libertarian officials to unblock conflicts known as "de facto leadership vacuums," as happened with Luis Barrionuevo after the Secretariat of Labor refused to extend him the certificate of authorities that would validate his victory in the elections of the Union of Tourism, Hotel and Gastronomy Workers of Argentina (UTHGRA) held last December, because the result of the vote is still trapped in a judicial labyrinth.
At the labor central, beyond wage and labor demands, they seek for the Secretariat of Labor, headed by Julio Cordero, to issue a resolution allowing the extension of a provisional certificate of authorities to whoever wins the elections in a union, even when the result of the elections is taken to court and the proclamation of the elected leadership is blocked.
It would be a way for the union's activity to maintain its internal life with normality until the conflict can be resolved through the courts: not having the certificate of authorities can cause serious problems in the management of bank accounts, the administration of the union's resources and its health insurance fund, the signing of collective bargaining negotiations, procedures before public agencies, and the legitimacy of institutional and political representation.
There lies…
AI Brief
Your highlights
Gerardo Martínez, Sandra Pettovello, Luis Barrionuevo and Julio CorderoWhile maintaining the expectation of a government call to resume dialogue, the CGT has on its agenda a proposal it will make to the libertarian officials to unblock conflicts known as "de facto leadership vacuums," as happened with Luis Barrionuevo after the Secretariat of Labor refused to extend him the certificate of authorities that would validate his victory in the elections of the Union of Tourism, Hotel and Gastronomy Workers of Argentina (UTHGRA) held last December, because the result of the vote is still trapped in a judicial labyrinth. At the labor central, beyond wage and labor demands, they seek for the Secretariat of Labor, headed by Julio Cordero, to issue a resolution allowing the extension of a provisional certificate of authorities to whoever wins elections in a union, even when the result of the elections is judicialized and the proclamation of the elected leadership is blocked. It would be a way for the union's activity to maintain its internal life with normality until the conflict can be resolved through the courts: not having the certificate of authorities can cause serious problems in the management of bank accounts, the administration of the union's resources and its health insurance fund, the signing of collective bargaining agreements, procedures before public agencies, and the legitimacy of institutional and political representation. Luis Barrionuevo at the Gastronomy Workers' march before the Ministry of Human Capital (Photo: RS Fotos)Therein lies one of Barrionuevo's central complaints: he claims that not having the certificate of authorities, even provisionally, caused Labor not to approve the sector's latest wage increase, and that is why workers in the sector have not yet received it. Some important figures at the Casa Rosada are already aware of the CGT's proposal, although it has yet to reach the Minister of Human Capital, Sandra Pettovello, who maintains a fierce confrontation with Barrionuevo because her ministry appealed a court ruling ordering it to give him the certificate of authorities and, instead of accepting it, filed an extraordinary appeal before the Supreme Court to settle the matter. The dialogue wing of the CGT, which includes, among others, Gerardo Martínez (UOCRA), also wants to resolve the Government-Barrionuevo conflict in order to try to repair its relationship with the leader of the Gastronomy Workers, which has been strained because he questions the labor central's moderate strategy since he lost spaces of power in the CGT leadership elected a year ago. Sandra Pettovello and Julio CorderoEven so, at the CGT they point out that there were other disputes similar to Barrionuevo's that could have been avoided, such as that of Mario Lavia, head of the Argentine Petroleum, Gas and Biofuels Trade Union Federation (FASiPeGyBio), whom the Government only gave the certificate of authorities after a ruling by Chamber IV of the National Labor Appeals Court. A similar situation occurred with Mariana Berbeglia, secretary general of the Sole Union of Itinerant Fair Workers of the Argentine Republic (SUTFRA). In the Government, they acknowledge that this type of case constitutes a complex problem and state that they are open to a solution agreed upon with the union leadership, while warning about the possible effects of the CGT's formula: the officials find themselves in the middle of inter-union crossfire and, if they agreed to issue provisional certificates of authorities, they would expose themselves to potential criminal complaints from rivals of the leader who claims electoral victory. From Human Capital they maintain that the political decision is to always appeal to the last judicial instance when there are rulings adverse to administrative resolutions, such as the non-recognition of Barrionuevo's electoral victory, as long as the electoral result remains mired in judicial controversy. At the CGT they suspect this is an excuse, because in other cases the Government did not seek to go to the Supreme Court to "avoid complying with judicial rulings" and, above all, because the leadership of an ultra-opposition figure like Barrionuevo is at stake, as is the fate of his ex-brother-in-law and main adversary, Dante Camaño, head of the Capital Branch. The CGT seeks a solution to Luis Barrionuevo's conflict with the GovernmentBeyond political speculation, it is true that Labor no longer has the decisive influence it once had in union elections, which explains the succession of de facto leadership vacuums. This is because Decree 342, issued by the Government in 2025, limits the State's intervention in union elections. This means that, from that rule onward, the Secretariat of Labor cannot become an arbiter of disputes between union slates, cannot automatically assume the functions of the Electoral Board, does not have the power granted to it by the previous regulations to suspend the installation of new authorities due to a challenge, and must respect union autonomy and judicial decisions. According to that decree, the Secretariat of Labor can only appoint an official for a period of 120 business days when the union lacks authorities and its bylaws do not provide for how to resolve it. And with Labor withdrawing as administrative arbiter, union conflicts over slates, membership rolls, or challenges now go directly to be resolved in the labor courts. Decree 342, in this way, stripped the Secretariat of Labor of its role of resolving conflicts related to union elections, which traditionally were often tinged with suspicions of political favoritism and even other kinds of irregularities. Thus, it is now the courts that must settle these union disputes without State intervention, in line with the conventions of the International Labour Organization (ILO). Sandra Pettovello crossed paths with CGT leaders Gerardo Martínez, Cristian Jerónimo and Jorge Sola before the Pope's speech at the UCA
Curiously, or perhaps not so curiously, this decision is now questioned by unionists who long for the exclusive role of state authorities in resolving conflicts related to union elections when, in reality, logic suggests they should trust that they have more guarantees of impartiality from judges than from officials of the government of the day. Those same instincts are what prompted some unionists with good access to the Government to operate in recent weeks to try to get the Secretariat of Labor moved out of Human Capital and placed under the Chief of Staff's Office, an arena dominated by the negotiating style of its head, Diego Santilli, who has well-oiled ties with union leaders. Barrionuevo himself made this explicit at last Monday's march of the Gastronomy Workers' Union before Human Capital, where he protested the failure to deliver the certificate of authorities: "All of us workers cannot be going to the courts to settle our problems, which are problems of the union world," he said. And he added: "At this point, the Chief of Staff's Office will have to take charge of the Secretariat of Labor. We need to solve the problems now." Be that as it may, the CGT has taken this issue as one of the central points of its agenda with the Government. All that remains is for that meeting to take place, one that was sketched out during the Pope's visit but which remains surrounded by unknowns.