By Esme Yeh / Staff reporter
Add TT as Preferred Source
Activating the Fourth Nuclear Power Plant could contaminate the source of drinking water for residents in Keelung, Taipei and New Taipei City, environmental advocates said at a news conference yesterday, urging people to vote “no” in the nuclear power referendum on Saturday next week. The referendum, to be held alongside the nine-in-one elections, asks voters whether they agree to using nuclear power to boost the economy and ending the “nuclear-free homeland” policy. Fourth Nuclear Plant Dismantling Advocacy Group secretary-general Yang Mu-huo (楊木火) said that an investigation report compiled by the Control Yuan last year showed that the peak ground acceleration (PGA) rates of nuclear power plants in Taiwan are all higher than their designed seismic coefficients.
Representatives of groups including the Fourth Nuclear Plant Dismantling Advocacy Group and the Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association hold placards at a news conference outside the Legislative Yuan in Taipei yesterday.
Photo: CNA
Large nuclear reactor units or small modular reactors (SMR) would not be allowed at the second, third and fourth nuclear power plant sites if EU, US or Japanese plant construction criteria are applied, he said. The PGA of the fourth nuclear plant for a 100,000-year return period — an indicator used to evaluate safety of high-stakes facilities such as nuclear power plants or large dams — is as high as 2.3g, Yang said.
However, today’s nuclear reactor products might not be able to endure such intense ground shaking, he said, citing information he had collected from nuclear reactor manufacturers at a forum held by the Chung-Hwa Nuclear Society in December last year. For example, Westinghouse Electric Co’s reactors, including the AP1000, AP300 and eVinci Microreactor, have a seismic coefficient of 0.1g, he said, adding that a South Korean manufacturer told him that innovative SMRs’ seismic coefficient is 0.5g. Yang also raised concerns about radioactive gases that could be generated from the fourth plant’s nuclear fission process. Such exhaust gas could contain radioactive iodine, which would likely contaminate nearby water-source protected areas, such as the Gongliao Water Treatment Plant (貢寮淨水廠) and the Feitsui Reservoir (翡翠水庫), he said. Green Party Taiwan social movement division director Lee Chun-hsiang (李春祥) said that SMR refers to smaller reactors that are manufactured as modular units and then assembled on-site at nuclear plants. SMRs are easier to build, but cannot ensure nuclear safety or solve nuclear waste, he said. As SMR is not yet a mature commercial technology, power generation costs and nuclear waste disposal remain questionable, Lee said. Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association attorney Tsai Ya-ying (蔡雅瀅) said although the Taiwan Inspiration Association’s survey showed that 79 percent of people were positive about restarting the fourth nuclear power plant, it hinges on the condition that “safety criteria can be met” in the plant’s operation. However, the fourth plant has provoked concerns over its safety due to improper construction and multiple accidents — including floods and fires — since construction began in 1999, she said. Issues such as aged devices or suspended production of components must also be considered, particularly as the fourth plant has been sealed since 2014, she added.