The case that originated with the municipality returned to the local court, which had ordered the restitution of the property. The community's defense filed multiple appeals, but exhausted the judicial avenues to prevent it. The judge could order the voluntary withdrawal of the occupants and, if that does not happen, proceed with the eviction.
After a lengthy judicial journey, the case ordering the restitution to the Municipality of Villa La Angostura of a campground located on the shore of Lake Correntoso returned to the local court. The Paicil Antriao Mapuche community failed to overturn the ruling that obliges them to return the property, after their arguments were rejected at the various judicial levels, including the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation.
The case file is once again in the hands of Judge Francisco Astoul Bonorino, who must proceed with the enforcement of the ruling in favor of the municipality. The judge could order the occupants to voluntarily remove their belongings and return the property. If they fail to comply, he may order the necessary measures to carry out the eviction, even with the assistance of public security forces.
The municipality filed charges against members of the community for remaining at the campground after the concession period ended, which expired in 2011. Since then, the dispute has spanned more than 15 years of litigation and has become one of the longest-running territorial conflicts in Villa La Angostura.
The courts recognized…
AI Brief
Your highlights
The campground on the shore of Lake Correntoso must be returned to the Municipality of Villa La Angostura
The case initiated by the municipality returned to the local court, which had ordered the restitution of the property. The community's defense filed multiple appeals but exhausted all judicial avenues to prevent it. The judge may order the voluntary withdrawal of the occupants and, if that does not happen, proceed with the eviction.
After a long judicial journey, the case ordering the return to the Municipality of Villa La Angostura of a campground located on the shore of Lake Correntoso has gone back to the local court. The Paicil Antriao Mapuche community failed to overturn the ruling requiring the return of the property, after its arguments were rejected at the various judicial levels, including the National Supreme Court of Justice.
The case file is once again in the hands of Judge Francisco Astoul Bonorino, who must proceed with the enforcement of the ruling in favor of the municipality. The judge could order the occupants to voluntarily remove their belongings and return the property. If they fail to comply, he may order the necessary measures to carry out the eviction, even with the assistance of public security forces.
The municipality filed a complaint against members of the community for remaining at the campground after the concession period ended, which expired in 2011. Since then, the dispute has spanned more than 15 years of litigation and has become one of the longest-running territorial conflicts in Villa La Angostura.
The Paicil Antriao Mapuche community maintained that the site is part of its ancestral territory, an argument that was not accepted by the courts.
The courts recognized the municipality's right to recover the establishment, although the various appeals filed by the Guild of Lawyers of the Argentine Republic, which represents the community, delayed the enforcement of the ruling.
This is the same community that settled on the route of the bypass road being built in Villa La Angostura, whose members will be relocated by the Neuquén government to allow the works to continue. The members of Paicil Antriao also maintain other unresolved territorial conflicts, both with public agencies and with private parties.
The campground is located on the shore of Lake Correntoso, approximately eight kilometers from the town center. It is a property that belonged to the municipal administration and was operated under a concession. Hugo Montes and Sofía Antriao, members of the Mapuche community, had been the concessionaires of the establishment. When the contract ended, they were supposed to return the administration of the campground to the municipality, but at the end of 2011 they did not return the property.
The members of the Paicil Antriao Mapuche community have occupied the campground since the concession expired in 2011
At that time, they raised a territorial claim based on the prior presence of their relatives and ancestors on those lands. The community maintained that the site was part of its ancestral territory. One of the historical records incorporated into the litigation was the donation of land made in April 1951 by José Victoriano Antriao to what was then the Development Commission of Villa La Angostura. That document was analyzed during the proceedings, but the courts concluded that it did not prove the ancestral possession claimed by the community over the campground area.
During the course of the conflict, Mayor Javier Murer even proposed a new concession of the establishment to the community to guarantee the provision of services during the summer season. However, social resistance to the initiative forced the mayor to abandon the project.
Faced with the failure to return the property, the Municipality initiated a reivindicatory action to recover ownership. The lawsuit was filed between 2012 and 2013 and was initially handled by Judge Jorge Videla, who recused himself from the case after a recusal motion was raised. The case file then went to Civil and Commercial Court No. 2 of Junín de los Andes, where Judge Andrés Luchino presided.
On December 11, 2019, Luchino issued a ruling in favor of the municipality and ordered the occupants to return the campground. The ruling rejected the community's arguments and found that the claimed ancestral possession of the property had not been demonstrated. It also analyzed the application of Law 26.160 on indigenous territorial surveying and concluded that the necessary conditions had not been established to recognize a traditional and current occupation of the property.
The property, located about eight kilometers from the center of Villa La Angostura, was the subject of more than 15 years of litigation
The community appealed the decision and managed to have the Civil and Commercial Court of Appeals of the interior of Neuquén overturn the ruling. However, the controversy did not end there. On April 11, 2024, the Superior Court of Justice of Neuquén overturned the Appeals Court's decision and reinstated the first-instance ruling. In this way, the provincial highest court ratified the Paicil Antriao community's obligation to return the campground to the Municipality of Villa La Angostura.
The ruling was a turning point in a lawsuit that had lasted more than a decade. The court considered that the claimed ancestral possession had not been sufficiently proven, nor was there evidence of traditional community use of the property. It also reviewed the documentary records regarding the 1951 land donation and concluded that they were insufficient to support the rights claimed by the occupants.
After the Superior Court of Justice ruling, the community attempted to take the case to the National Supreme Court of Justice. It filed a federal extraordinary appeal, which was rejected by the Neuquén highest court, and subsequently filed a complaint with the Supreme Court. On August 6, 2026, the Supreme Court rejected that argument. In this way, the ruling ordering the return of the campground to the municipality became final. The national highest court did not issue a new ruling on the merits of the dispute, but rather declined the possibility of reviewing the provincial ruling through the appeal filed.
The Supreme Court rejected the federal appeal filed by the Mapuche community
In parallel, another procedural dispute developed over which court should handle the enforcement of the ruling. On December 27, 2024, Judge Santiago Montorfano, of Civil and Commercial Court No. 2 of Junín de los Andes, had ordered the case files sent to Villa La Angostura so that the local judge could proceed with the restitution of the property. The community challenged that decision through various appeals. However, on February 3, 2026, the Superior Court of Justice rejected the arguments and confirmed the transfer of the case file. Subsequently, on October 5, it also dismissed a federal extraordinary appeal filed against that decision.
While the final judicial stages were unfolding, the municipality and the community attempted to find a negotiated solution to the conflict. In June 2025, both parties agreed to open a conciliation process, which was approved by the courts. The negotiation was not limited to the campground: it also covered another adjoining plot of land, occupied by members of the community and claimed by the Municipality. The intention was to reach an understanding that would allow both disputes to be resolved without the need to proceed with judicial enforcement measures.
However, approximately a year passed without the parties reaching an agreement. On June 22, 2026, the judge ended the conciliation process and ordered the proceedings to continue.
With the ruling final and the judicial appeals exhausted, the case file returned to the local court. Now, the Municipality is in a position to proceed with the recovery of the campground, although the judge still has to order the concrete measures to carry out the restitution.