Costa Rica's Defender of the Inhabitants challenges 29 lawmakers and announces she will not resign following controversial visit to CACCO

rss · Infobae 2026-11-20T03:54:02Z es
Costa Rica's Ombudswoman, Angie Cruickshank, announced that she will not resign from her position, despite a motion approved by 29 lawmakers requesting her immediate removal following the controversy generated by an inspection carried out at the Center for High Containment against Organized Crime (CACCO). During a public statement, the official rejected the legislators' questions and defended the legality of the visit conducted on November 13, 2026, asserting that her actions fall within the institution's competencies of protecting and monitoring human rights. As she explained, the Legislative Assembly notified her of a motion requesting her resignation and warning that, if she does not submit it, an investigation procedure could be opened to determine whether her removal is warranted. "It is my intention and my duty to complete the four-year term for which I was appointed," Cruickshank stated. The official also asserted that leaving the position would mean accepting a wrongdoing that, according to her position, she never committed. "I will not submit my resignation from the position of Ombudswoman," she declared. Why are lawmakers asking for her resignation? The controversy arose after Cruickshank visited the CACCO, a prison intended for persons deprived of liberty linked to criminal structures. According to the motion described by the official, the lawmakers questioned the institution's priori…
The Ombudswoman, Angie Cruickshank, announced that she will not resign from her position, despite a motion backed by 29 lawmakers requesting her removal. Costa Rica's Ombudswoman, Angie Cruickshank, announced that she will not resign from her position, despite a motion approved by 29 lawmakers requesting her immediate removal following the controversy generated by an inspection carried out at the Center for High Containment Against Organized Crime (CACCO). During a public statement, the official rejected the lawmakers' questions and defended the legality of the visit conducted on November 13, 2026, asserting that her actions fall within the institution's competencies of protecting and monitoring human rights. As she explained, the Legislative Assembly notified her of a motion requesting her resignation and warning that, if she does not submit it, an investigation procedure could be opened to determine whether her removal is warranted. "It is my intention and my duty to complete the four-year term for which I was appointed," Cruickshank stated. The official also asserted that leaving the position would mean accepting a wrongdoing that, in her view, she never committed. "I will not submit my resignation from the position of Ombudswoman," she declared. The controversy arose after Cruickshank visited the CACCO, a prison intended for persons deprived of liberty linked to criminal structures. According to the motion described by the official, the lawmakers questioned the Ombudsman's Office's institutional priorities, particularly its intervention to verify the conditions of confinement. They also attributed to her an arrogant and disrespectful behavior toward administrative and police officials during the inspection. Cruickshank rejected both accusations and maintained that oversight of prison conditions constitutes a legal responsibility. "The defense of human rights does not admit categories of people whose rights can be ignored or relativized," she stated. She added that addressing the rights of victims of crime and monitoring the conditions of persons deprived of liberty are not incompatible tasks. The controversy arose after an inspection conducted on November 13 at the Center for High Containment Against Organized Crime (CACCO). Credit: Video screenshot, Presidency of the Republic. The Ombudswoman also presented her account of the incidents that occurred during the inspection. According to her explanation, some officials under the responsibility of the Ministry of Justice and Peace allegedly engaged in disrespectful behavior and obstructed the institution's work. The official stated that the obstacles were even physical and prevented the full exercise of oversight competencies. "At no time did I behave in an arrogant, disrespectful manner or contrary to the norms of coexistence," she asserted. Cruickshank acknowledged that she responded firmly to the incidents, but maintained that her actions sought to stop the disrespectful behavior she attributed to the prison staff. Furthermore, she noted that the events were formally reported to the Minister of Justice. Cruickshank explained that the visit to the CACCO was not an improvised decision, but part of an institutional investigation initiated in May 2025, related to the project to build a maximum-security prison. According to her, the Ombudsman's Office sought to evaluate aspects of infrastructure, security, operation, and conditions of confinement. She also recalled that Article 12 of the Law of the Ombudsman's Office empowers its representatives to inspect public offices without prior notice. The official stated that the institution has carried out more than 210 inspection visits to educational centers, hospitals, shelters, public institutions, and other establishments. The Legislative Assembly warned of the possible opening of a procedure to investigate the Ombudswoman's conduct and determine whether her removal is warranted. Ombudswoman insists on completing her term. At the end of her statement, Cruickshank defended the independence of the Ombudsman's Office and called for avoiding confrontations between institutions. The official maintained that she will continue to exercise her functions, even if they generate questions from other branches of government. "Resigning from my position, as the motion proposes, would be equivalent to acknowledging a failure in my legal duties in which I never engaged," she asserted. The controversy now rests in the hands of the Legislative Assembly, which must determine whether to proceed with the announced investigation and under what conditions.

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Highlight