Children whose innocence and childhood were erased. Forever. Women who lived through a hell they will never be able to forget. Mutilated men who barely survived the barbarity and the extermination. Systematic. Inhumane. Each of the hundreds of thousands of refugees —1.2 million, most of them in Bangladesh, according to UNHCR— hoped for some measure of justice, which finally came from a distant court in The Hague.
The International Court of Justice (ICJ) —the United Nations' highest court— concluded that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya Muslim minority, that group of human beings who have survived displaced for nearly a decade.
It is the first time in its 80-year history that the ICJ has declared a State responsible for such a crime. The ruling obliges the Asian country —under the de facto government of General Min Aung Hlaing, following the February 2021 coup d'état— to allow the safe return of the refugees, to investigate and punish the suspects, and to pay the corresponding compensation in each individual case. Historic.
In Latin America, a prosecutor's office devoted hours of investigation to those crimes, which finally reached a conclusion this Thursday at the ICJ, headquartered in The Hague. Argentine federal prosecutor Guillermo Marijuan was the first to advance the investigation against those he considered the perpetrators of "genocide" against the Rohingya minority. And on June 28, 2024, he had already requested the issuance of red notices for the c…
AI Brief
Your highlights
Rohingya refugee children look through a metal mesh as they gather to watch the live broadcast of the announcement of the verdict by the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in a case accusing Myanmar of committing genocide against that minority (Reuters)Children whose innocence and childhood were erased. Forever. Women who lived through a hell they will never be able to forget. Mutilated men who barely survived the barbarity and the extermination. Systematic. Inhumane. Each of the hundreds of thousands of refugees —1.2 million, most of them in Bangladesh, according to UNHCR— was waiting for some measure of justice that finally came from a distant court, in The Hague. The International Court of Justice (ICJ) —the United Nations' highest court— concluded that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya Muslim minority, that human group that has survived displaced for nearly a decade. It is the first time in its 80-year history that the ICJ has declared a State responsible for such a crime. The ruling obliges the Asian country —under the de facto government of General Min Aung Hlaing, following the February 2021 coup d'état— to allow the safe return of the refugees, to investigate and punish the suspects, and to pay the corresponding compensation for each case. Historic. In Latin America, a prosecutor's office devoted hours of investigation to those crimes, which finally reached a conclusion this Thursday at the ICJ, headquartered in The Hague. Argentine federal prosecutor Guillermo Marijuan was the first to advance the investigation against those he considered the "genocidaires" of the Rohingya minority. And on June 28, 2024, he had already requested the issuance of red notices for the international capture of the Burmese defendants. He had reached the conclusion that the authorities of that country had committed a genocide. Although these are different cases, where on the one hand a state is tried and on the other individual responsibilities are assigned, for prosecutor Marijuan, however, "they are distinct tracks that converge today." "The application of the principle of universal justice carried out by the Public Prosecutor's Office of the Argentine Republic, in this case through the work performed by the staff of my office, was transcendental," Marijuan said in conversation with Infobae. And he emphasized: "A jurisdictional response must be given to those people who cannot reach the courts, who cannot make their claims heard and be able to denounce conduct as grave as what took place in Myanmar, in order to bring those responsible before a tribunal." Judge Yuji Iwasawa, president of the International Court of Justice, presides over the session to deliver its ruling in the case brought by Gambia, which accuses Myanmar of genocide against the Rohingya Muslim minority, in The Hague, Netherlands (Reuters)The Argentine federal prosecutor gave an interview in which he highlighted the most salient points of his investigation and celebrated what was done in The Hague.- What was the most compelling evidence you found, and what was the hardest thing to prove in order to establish that this was not simply war crimes or crimes against humanity, but a genocidal plan?- First of all, I want to clarify that the International Court of Justice judged the responsibility of the State of Myanmar, whereas our case, opened under universal jurisdiction, investigates individual criminal responsibility. They are distinct tracks that converge today. In our investigation, the most compelling thing was the corroboration between independent sources. The survivors who testified before the prosecutor's office, in Buenos Aires and by videoconference from Bangladesh, recounted the same thing that emerges from the satellite images and from the material provided to us by the United Nations Independent Investigative Mechanism for Myanmar. On top of that, there was a former soldier who defected and described from the inside how the army thought and operated. The hardest part was proving the intent to destroy the group, which is what separates genocide from crimes against humanity, and reconstructing the chain of command from thousands of kilometers away, without access to the territory or the cooperation of the State. What convinced us was realizing that 2017 was not an isolated explosion, but the culmination of decades of policies directed against the Rohingya. ARCHIVE: Federal prosecutor Guillermo Marijuan in his office in Buenos Aires. His investigation determined the criminal responsibility of those responsible for Myanmar's genocide against the Rohingya minority (Infobae)- In genocide proceedings, one of the greatest challenges is proving the specific intent to destroy, totally or partially, a human group. How can that intent be proven when those who design and carry out the operations rarely leave written documents spelling out their objectives? What elements allowed that will to be reconstructed?- No one signs an order that says 'destroy this people.' Intent is reconstructed from conduct, from the pattern. In this case there were decades of measures pointing in the same direction, such as the denial of citizenship, restrictions on moving around, studying, receiving care at a hospital or practicing their religion, and marriage permits tied to the commitment not to have more than two or three children. Added to that are the scale and simultaneity of the 2017 operations, in which some 392 villages were totally or partially destroyed, nearly 40 percent of the settlements in northern Rakhine, most of them burned in the first three weeks, with combat troops deployed months earlier. Language also weighs in, because the army banned the word Rohingya and referred to them as invading foreigners. And there are the reports of the United Nations Mechanism on the hate speech campaign on social media linked to military structures. When all these elements are read together, the only reasonable explanation is the will to eliminate the group as such.- I understand you worked with Rohingya groups for your investigation, which led to requests for international captures. But behind every document, satellite image, testimony or record there are people who suffered persecution, sexual violence, displacement and murder. How do you work with survivors to transform their testimonies into solid judicial evidence without revictimizing them? What story or testimony marked you most during the investigation?- That was the most delicate aspect of the entire investigation. The victims testified before the prosecutor's office, some in person in Buenos Aires and others by videoconference from the refugee camps, always with interpreters of their language and, in most cases, with identity protected for security reasons. The provisions of the Law on Rights and Guarantees of Persons Victims of Crimes and the protocols in force were applied, and we requested the intervention of the Assistance Program for Victims of Repression and Torture of the Committee for the Defense of Ethics, Health and Human Rights, so that it could provide psychological assistance and emotional support to the witnesses. When women victims of sexual violence recounted the abuses they had suffered, only women remained in the room. And when the pain of their account prevented them from continuing, the hearing was interrupted and resumed only when the person was able to go on. No one was forced to tell more than they could. Personally, I was marked by the testimony of a doctor from one of the razed villages, who, together with his daughter, attended victims of sexual violence after the operations, among them children. That is not forgotten.- What did you feel when you learned that the Court had finally recognized the genocide, after so many years of investigative work? Was there any moment when you thought the evidence gathered would not be sufficient to achieve this outcome?- I have been a federal prosecutor for more than 30 years now, and perhaps with the passage of time one might think that nothing moves us anymore or that we have seen it all before. However, the fact that our work proving a genocide, along with the request for the international capture of an entire country's governing leadership, was received and recognized by the International Court of Justice, upholding the application of the Principle of International Justice, fills me with pride and is for me a very important professional achievement. But the survivors of the massacres who receive a just response are, without any doubt, the ones who should feel the true achievement of their claims.- Now that there is a historic ruling, who should be sitting in the dock, and what real possibilities are there that they will answer criminally for these crimes?- In our case there are twenty-five defendants with international capture ordered by the Argentine justice system in February 2025. Those who should answer are those who led the operations and those who allowed them, that is, the commander-in-chief of the Defense Services and his deputy, the chief of the General Staff, the commander of the Air Force, the commander of the Western Regional Command, the heads of the divisions and battalions that acted on the ground, the Minister of the Interior, the head of the border police and the highest civilian authorities of that time. As for the real possibilities, it must be said frankly that Interpol did not load the red notices for their captures. It invoked immunity and the political and military nature of the matter, and Myanmar formally objected. Without that tool, the orders can only be carried out if they enter our country. That is why I hope that, with this ruling, the request made by this prosecutor's office becomes a reality, because it is no longer only the Argentine justice system but the International Court of Justice itself that affirms there was a genocide and orders it to be investigated and punished. We will continue working with the United Nations Mechanism so that it is so. X: @TotiPI