The Supreme Court upheld the removal of former federal judge Walter Bento

rss · La Nacion 2026-11-19T19:12:32Z es
The Supreme Court upheld the removal of Walter Bento as federal judge of Mendoza, confirming the validity of the impeachment trial that found him responsible for misconduct. Bento is also convicted in criminal court to 18 years in prison and a fine of more than 540 million pesos as the head of an illicit association dedicated to collecting bribes and laundering money. The Magistrates' Jury of Impeachment had removed him in November 2023. Almost three years later, he was convicted by an oral court. Now the Supreme Court of Justice reviewed his removal. The highest court dismissed the appeal for review that Bento filed against that ruling. The Court held that Bento failed to demonstrate "patent violations of the rules of due process and the guarantee of the right to defense," which is the only circumstance in which the highest court can review an impeachment trial. Justices of the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation: Carlos Fernando Rosenkrantz, Horacio Rosatti, Ricardo Lorenzetti. Supreme Court. The decision was signed by justices Carlos Rosenkrantz and Ricardo Lorenzetti, along with substitute judges Leopoldo Bruglia, Carolina Robiglio, and Juan Fernando Perozziello Vizier. The head of the Court, Horacio Rosatti, who also presides over the Council of Magistracy that investigated Bento, recused himself from the case, and the highest court accepted his withdrawal. The same day, the Court resolved another appeal by Bento, case CSJ 2380/2023, against the rejection of the recusals he had raised during the impeachment trial. Bento had been a federal judge in Mendoza with electoral jurisdiction since 2005. That is, he oversaw national elections in that jurisdiction. He was removed on November 8, 2023, by six votes to one: the then president of the Jury, Javier de la Fuente, voted in dissent. That same day, Bento was detained. Last February, Oral Federal Court No. 2 of Mendoza sentenced him to 18 years in prison as the head of an illicit association that collected bribes in exchange for favorable judicial rulings. The Jury of Impeachment removed him for maneuvering to obstruct the investigation against him, having sold a property without declaring his status as a politically exposed person, having obtained a mortgage loan for a single home despite owning several properties, having omitted information in his sworn statements, and having registered for a competition for the Federal Criminal Cassation Chamber despite not meeting the requirements. The main argument of the defense, led by Mariano Fragueiro Frías, was the unconstitutionality of law 26.080, which reformed the Council of Magistracy and left only one lawyers' representative on the Jury. Article 115 of the Constitution states that the impeachment jury is composed of "legislators, magistrates, and lawyers of the federal bar." According to Bento, that plural requires at least two members from each group. "Its reasoning is weak," the Court responded. To rebut it, it concluded that the Constitution uses a "generic plural." That is, the article indicates which sectors must make up the Jury, not how many representatives each one has. Bento also questioned the impartiality of two legislators from Juntos por el Cambio who were part of the jury. The former judge had argued that his presumption of innocence was violated, because he had been removed for crimes that did not yet carry a conviction. The Court responded that the argument was "ostensibly unfounded" and recalled that the jury had set aside the criminal accusations when removing him, focusing instead on his conduct "improper for a federal judge." In its ruling, the Court listed those actions by Bento. For example, it noted that the removed judge requested reports from the National Directorate of Migration and the Real Estate Registry to find out whether there were any restrictions on him or his assets; or he asked the telephone company to change the chip of a cell phone that the courts had requested days earlier. And he left a handwritten note in his safe deposit box, addressed to the judge investigating him, which was found during the raid: "Puigdengolas reads!!! Please," it said, alluding to Judge Eduardo Puigdéngolas, who had charged him as the leader of an illicit association that demanded money in exchange for judicial benefits. The Court noted that Bento did not deny these facts during the impeachment trial and even admitted some of them. He said the note in the safe had been a "plea for clemency" in the face of "the helplessness he suffered from the violation of his rights as a defendant." By Hernán Cappiello. Type of work: Original News

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Highlight