Bernardo Martorell: "The government should be more prudent when interpreting and drawing positive conclusions from the oncology alert"

rss · La Tercera 2026-11-19T19:00:00Z es
Despite the implementation of the oncological alert established by Health Minister May Chomali, the latest results of the GES report leave doubts about its impact. Between September 2025 and the same month of 2026, compliance with oncological guarantees dropped from 97.62% to 97.40%, while delayed guarantees barely decreased by 2.5%. The figures raised questions about the effects of one of the authority's main bets to tackle delays in cancer care. In that context, Bernardo Martorell, Undersecretary of Healthcare Networks during Gabriel Boric's government, who had among his main challenges reducing waiting lists, states that this decision only had transitory effects and that measures must be more focused on solving structural problems. What do you think of the recently released figures? The most relevant figure is that overall GES compliance improves by 0.5 points, from 97.3% to 97.8%, while oncological GES compliance decreases by 0.2 points. Both changes are slight; they don't move the needle. The paradoxical thing is that the government decreed an oncological health alert, and not seeing a change in those parameters, which are the most important in our healthcare management, is worrying. One could interpret that the alert is not the appropriate instrument to tackle a problem like cancer. The government must be more prudent when interpreting and drawing positive conclusi…
Despite the implementation of the oncological alert established by the Ministry of Health under May Chomali, the latest results of the GES report leave doubts about its impact. Between September 2025 and the same month of 2026, compliance with oncological guarantees dropped from 97.62% to 97.40%, while delayed guarantees barely decreased by 2.5%. The figures raised questions about the effects of one of the authority's main bets to address delays in cancer care. In this context, Bernardo Martorell, Undersecretary of Healthcare Networks during Gabriel Boric's government, who had among his main challenges reducing waiting lists, states that this decision only had transitory effects and that measures must be more focused on solving structural problems. What do you think of the recently released figures? The most relevant figure is that overall GES compliance improves by 0.5 points, from 97.3% to 97.8%, while oncological GES compliance decreases by 0.2 points. Both changes are slight, they don't move the needle. The paradoxical thing is that the government decreed an oncological health alert and not seeing a change in those parameters, which are the most important ones in our care management, is concerning. One could interpret that the alert is not the appropriate instrument to tackle a problem like cancer. The government should be more prudent when interpreting and drawing positive conclusions from that oncological alert. Are there differences between what was done and what was promised? The report shows that 99% of the patients who were with delayed GES when the alert started were treated. What happens is that if you only take the stock of patients, you forget that new ones are coming in. In the end, the reduction of delays is marginal. The alert did not generate any different mechanism to reduce the inflow or the outflow speed. Why didn't this measure show more significant changes? Health alerts are designed for acute emergencies, disasters, catastrophes, epidemics or risks of that nature. It is not an instrument designed to solve continuous-flow diseases. We have had a lot of cancer for years, it's not that there is a peak now. This measure is not pertinent for a situation like cancer. It seems there is a communicational use. You say there was much talk of a success with this alert? It didn't move the needle and that is clear from the figures. It is not the appropriate instrument for the problem, which requires more structural changes, medium to long term, strengthening of the network and a more strengthened public-private integration. The government's reading should be more prudent. You were Undersecretary of Healthcare Networks. Did you consider using an alert? We always knew that alerts are instruments for emergencies, acute problems. At the time we were called to implement a health alert from different sectors and, in our view, it was not the appropriate instrument for this type of situation. Were the measures you took better than a health alert? The correct measures are those that seek to strengthen the network's capacity to respond to the population's cancer needs. And the alert does not seem to be the appropriate instrument. Maybe it solves some cases in the short term, it flexibilizes certain use of resources, which is the contribution a health alert makes, it doesn't do much more than that. What is your opinion of the communication made by the Ministry of Health about the success of the alert? I don't think it's about assigning responsibilities, rather it's about doing long-term work. In all political cycles governments are tempted to communicate partial results, small successes. That is natural. I heard the minister say when the alert ended that one of the lessons learned was that structural changes were necessary. And I think that is precisely the direction in which we must continue working as a state policy. Is this administration working in that direction? This administration has maintained and given continuity to many investment and management projects that came from the previous one. So there is a positive note there in terms of understanding health policy as a state policy. But there is a basic issue that this government has not looked at, which is the financing needs resulting from the population's growing health needs. All the countries of the world are increasing their health spending and we cannot imagine that health spending should be cut. When the government starts with a cut, it is clear to me that the population's health needs are not being understood. While in oncological matters and the GES the needle doesn't move, we do see another needle that is starting to change slipping away from management. Since the beginning of the pandemic we had not seen such a significant increase in GES waiting times in surgical matters. Did concentrating efforts on the oncological alert and on resolving the guarantees and benefits associated with cancer was to the detriment of the other waiting lists? Directly to their detriment. There is an effect of the signals one sends. The Ministry of Health does not directly manage the hospitals, but it sends signals that are a very important language to manage. When one focuses on certain points, hospitals align with that and naturally will stop looking at and worrying about what the authority is saying is not the priority. It puts on the table that the other waiting lists worsened. Exactly, there is an increase like never before in surgical waiting time and that is very concerning. Certain figures in our administration generated more alarm and concern among the different actors related to the health system and also in the media than in the current process.

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Highlight