Florida has scheduled the execution of Thomas Mitchell Overton for this Thursday, November 19. He was convicted of the murders of Michael MacIvor and Susan Michelle MacIvor, who was eight months pregnant, at a home in Tavernier, in the Florida Keys. The case dates back to August 1991 and resulted in a death sentence after an investigation that incorporated genetic evidence.
The procedure is scheduled for 6:00 p.m. at Florida State Prison in Raiford, by order of Governor Ron DeSantis. The sentence comes after more than three decades of legal proceedings and successive attempts by the defense to overturn the convictions.
The Florida Supreme Court rejected the latest state appeals on November 13. Overton also turned to the United States Supreme Court in an attempt to halt the procedure and obtain a review of the case. If the execution is carried out, Florida will reach 20 executions in 2026, a new record since the reinstatement of capital punishment in 1976.
Execution scheduled for 6:00 p.m. at Raiford State Prison
The execution of Thomas Mitchell Overton is scheduled for 6:00 p.m. this Thursday, November 19, at Florida State Prison, located in Raiford, in the northern part of the state.
The date was set in an execution order signed by Governor Ron DeSantis on October 21. The Florida Supreme Court confirmed that schedule in the ruling issued on the 13th…
AI Brief
Your highlights
Governor Ron DeSantis signed the order to execute Thomas Mitchell Overton by lethal injection at Florida State Prison. (Illustrative image Infobae)Florida has scheduled the execution of Thomas Mitchell Overton for this Thursday, November 19. Overton was convicted of the murders of Michael MacIvor and Susan Michelle MacIvor, who was eight months pregnant, at a home in Tavernier, in the Florida Keys. The case dates back to August 1991 and resulted in a death sentence after an investigation that incorporated genetic evidence. The procedure is scheduled for 6:00 p.m. at Florida State Prison in Raiford, by order of Governor Ron DeSantis. The sentence comes after more than three decades of legal proceedings and successive attempts by the defense to overturn the convictions. The Florida Supreme Court rejected the final state appeals on November 13. Overton also turned to the United States Supreme Court to try to stop the procedure and obtain a review of the case. If the execution is carried out, Florida will reach 20 executions in 2026, a new record since the reinstatement of capital punishment in 1976. The execution of Thomas Mitchell Overton is scheduled for 6:00 p.m. this Thursday, November 19 at Florida State Prison, located in Raiford, in the northern part of the state. The date was set in an execution order signed by Governor Ron DeSantis on October 21. The Florida Supreme Court confirmed that schedule in the ruling issued on November 13, in which it also detailed the final appeals filed by the defense. The procedure will be carried out by lethal injection, according to the information included in the official case documents. Raiford prison is one of the Florida Department of Corrections facilities designated for carrying out capital sentences. The order set the time after the main state review stages had concluded. The scheduling, however, does not amount to a confirmation that the procedure has already been carried out: its implementation depends on there being no last-minute judicial stay. The judge imposed two capital sentences on Overton in 1999 following the jury's recommendation at trial. (Florida Department of Corrections)Overton was found guilty of the murders of Michael MacIvor and Susan MacIvor, which occurred in August 1991 at the couple's home in Tavernier. Susan was eight months pregnant when she was attacked, and the child she was expecting died after his mother. The court record shows that the charges included two counts of first-degree murder, the death of an unborn child, burglary, and sexual assault. Overton pleaded innocent throughout the process, but the jury found him guilty of the charges. In the sentencing phase, the jurors recommended the death penalty by a vote of nine to three for Susan's murder and eight to four for Michael's. The judge accepted both recommendations and handed down two death sentences in 1999. The Florida Supreme Court subsequently affirmed the convictions and sentences. Since then, Overton filed various appeals to challenge the process and seek the annulment of the sentences, but none succeeded in changing the judicial outcome. Susan and Michael MacIvor returned home on the night of August 21, 1991, after attending a childbirth preparation class. They were never seen alive again. Their bodies were found the next day inside the family home in Tavernier. According to the reconstruction of events included in the Florida Supreme Court ruling, Michael was attacked inside the house and received several blows before dying from strangulation. His body was found in the living room, with his head covered with adhesive tape and a sock over his eyes. Susan was found in the bedroom, bound hand and foot, with signs of sexual assault. The forensic examination determined that she died from strangulation. The autopsy established that the baby, a boy, survived approximately 30 minutes after his mother's death. This fact was incorporated into the medical records presented during the judicial process. The investigation also determined that the attacker had entered the property during the night and that the home's telephone lines had been cut. The evidence collected at the scene, including biological samples obtained from the bedding, later became central elements in solving the case. The defense filed a stay application and a petition for certiorari with the United States Supreme Court. (Curt Anderson/AP)The investigation was initially unable to identify the perpetrator through the genetic samples collected at the home. In 1993, the first DNA tests performed on fragments of the bedding produced no matches with the available profiles. The case advanced three years later. In 1996, Overton was arrested during a burglary attempt while under police surveillance. After his arrest, authorities obtained a sample of his DNA and compared it with the genetic profile recovered from the MacIvor home. The Florida Supreme Court indicated that both samples matched. In 1998, a second laboratory, Bode Technology Group, performed another test using a different genetic technique and confirmed the result. The prosecution presented the genetic evidence at trial along with testimony from two people who had shared a prison cell with Overton. One of them testified that the defendant had described details of the attack on the couple and had spoken of his intention to sexually assault Susan. The DNA match and the testimonies were part of the evidence used by the prosecution to obtain the conviction. During subsequent appeals, the defense challenged the investigation and argued that investigators had planted or manipulated the genetic evidence. However, the courts rejected their arguments and upheld the convictions. After the Florida Supreme Court rejected his final appeals on November 13, Overton's defense turned to the highest federal judicial body to try to stop the execution. The lawyers filed an application for a stay of the death sentence and a petition for review of the case record, known as certiorari. The latter seeks to have the United States Supreme Court examine a lower court's decision when it believes there are legal questions that justify its intervention. Among the arguments raised were challenges to Florida's clemency procedure and to the restrictions on accessing certain public records related to the case. The defense argued that these conditions affected Overton's ability to present new arguments to obtain relief from his sentence. Federal case number 26-6154 records the filing of the petition on November 14. The state of Florida's response and the defense's replies were incorporated on November 17. At the time of this report, the public docket of the United States Supreme Court showed those filings without a final ruling on the stay application. The Florida Supreme Court's decision did stand at the state level: the court rejected Overton's arguments, denied his petition for habeas corpus, and determined that there were no grounds to stay the execution. The state of Florida will reach twenty executions in 2026 if it carries out the death sentence against Overton. (Illustrative image Infobae)Florida had recorded 19 executions in 2026 before the procedure scheduled for Overton. If the sentence is carried out this Thursday, the state will reach 20 executions in a single year, surpassing the maximum it had set in 2025. The Florida Department of Corrections record makes it possible to track executions carried out since the reinstatement of the death penalty in 1976. The figure reached during 2025 was 19 procedures, which represented the state's annual maximum up to that point. Overton's scheduling is part of a year of intense capital punishment activity in Florida. The calendar also contemplates other procedures planned for December. However, each one corresponds to an independent conviction and case file, and therefore does not modify Overton's particular judicial situation.