The former Pensions Superintendent, Solange Berstein, reflected on the causes that generated the sharp drop in Funds D and E, which sparked a major controversy a few weeks ago with harsh criticism of the AFPs and the system in general.
Within the framework of a seminar, the woman who also chaired the CMF and is currently a professor of finance and regulation at the UAI pointed to the need to define what the population's expectations really are for the pension system in relation to risk.
As an anecdote, the economist recounted her experience in a class at a union school, about pensions and the risks in the system. At that, one of the attendees told her: "We are workers, we don't want risks, why don't you invent something that has no risk and that is pensions?"
In that sense, she pointed out that the question should be: "How do we meet people's expectations? That is very difficult; unfortunately we don't have the solution. Sure, we can give zero risk, but it means the pensions will be miserable, so there is no way to meet people's expectations at a reasonable cost."
On the other hand, she commented: "The objective of the pension system is to deliver pensions, and therefore, I have to have something that, in my judgment, we still don't have. What is the objective of the system? What are we seeking to protect or safeguard? What is the expected pension of this system? Is it..."
AI Brief
Your highlights
The former Superintendant of Pensions, Solange Berstein, reflected on the causes that generated the sharp drop in Funds D and E, which sparked great controversy a few weeks ago with harsh criticism of the AFPs and the system in general. Within the framework of a seminar, the woman who also chaired the CMF and is currently a professor of finance and regulation at the UAI pointed to the need to define what the population's expectations really are for the pension system in relation to risk. As an anecdote, the economist recounted her experience in a class at a union school, about pensions and the risks in the system. When this happened, one of the attendees told her: "We are workers, we don't want risks, why don't you invent something that has no risk, and that is pensions?" In that sense, she pointed out that the question should be: "How do we satisfy people's expectations? That is very difficult; unfortunately we don't have the solution. Sure, we can give zero risk, but it means the pensions will be pauper-level, so there is no way to satisfy people's expectations at a reasonable cost." On the other hand, she commented: "The objective of the pension system is to deliver pensions, and therefore, I have to have something that, in my judgment, we still don't have. What is the objective of the system? What are we seeking to protect or safeguard? What is the expected pension of this system? Are we making it explicit to people? What is the tolerable risk with respect to that expected pension? That was never made explicit, people have never been told." Then, she said that "there is an issue in terms of what was communicated to people. That is what generates the problem we are in today: at the end of the day, the explanations today are not so easy." On the other hand, she posed: "When we talk about pension risk, how is volatility measured?" She said that various calculations have been made to see whether or not the swaps contributed to reducing pension risk. On this last point, she acknowledged: "My impression (...) I'm not so clear that they contributed to reducing pension risk, to tell the truth; if that was indeed the objective." However, she noted that a lesson can be drawn from this whole episode, and "it is that it has put the focus where it needs to be, which is: What do we expect from the pension system? That it deliver pensions, that we avoid volatility, that we make those pension projections, and that we regulate in such a way that the incentives move in that direction." The academic presented her views at the seminar organized by the Faculty of Economics and Business (FEN) of the University of Chile and CFA Society, Berstein, which also featured the presence of UC financial economics professor Jaime Casassus; former president of CFA Society Hugo Aravena; FEN associate professor Erwin Hansen; and the president of the AFP Association, León Fernández de Castro. NEWSLETTER Pulso PM Monday to Friday, 12:30 PM The most relevant news on markets, companies and business: timely information, context and content to make better decisions. By subscribing you are accepting the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policies of La Tercera.