European governments reacted with skepticism and concern to the meeting held this Thursday in Shenzhen by the presidents of the United States, Donald Trump, China, Xi Jinping, and Russia, Vladimir Putin, a gathering in which Europe did not participate and which ended with a declaration on peace that makes no mention of the war in Ukraine. Before and after the meeting, several leaders and officials from the continent expressed doubts about its outcomes and demanded a seat at the table in any negotiation about Ukraine's future.
The clearest warning came from Berlin. There, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said after the meeting of the so-called "coalition of the willing" that "a Yalta-style format will not bring peace."
"If there are peace negotiations, we will be involved. Negotiations can only succeed if Ukraine and Europe are part of the process together," he stated. Yalta is the 1945 conference at which the United States, the United Kingdom, and the Soviet Union agreed on the future of Europe at the end of World War II, and which the continent associates with the division into spheres of influence.
The coalition of the willing is the group of countries—more than 40 as of this Thursday, according to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky—that coordinate military and financial support for Ukraine and future security guarantees for Kyiv. The meeting, convened by Merz together with French President Emmanuel Macron and the British prime minister…
AI Brief
Your highlights
Zelensky, Merz and Macron during the plenary session of the "coalition of the willing" at the Berlin Chancellery, this November 19. (REUTERS/Lisi Niesner/Pool)European governments reacted with skepticism and concern to the meeting held this Thursday in Shenzhen by the presidents of the United States, Donald Trump, of China, Xi Jinping, and of Russia, Vladimir Putin, a gathering in which Europe did not participate and which ended with a declaration on peace that does not mention the war in Ukraine. Before and after the meeting, several leaders and officials from the continent expressed doubts about its results and demanded a place in any negotiation about Ukraine's future. The clearest warning came from Berlin. There, the German chancellor, Friedrich Merz, said after the meeting of the so-called "coalition of the willing" that "a Yalta-style format will not bring peace."
"If there are peace negotiations, we will be involved. Negotiations can only succeed if Ukraine and Europe are part of the process together," he said. Yalta is the 1945 conference at which the United States, the United Kingdom and the Soviet Union agreed on the future of Europe at the end of World War II, and which the continent associates with the division into zones of influence. The coalition of the willing is the group of countries—more than 40 this Thursday, according to the Ukrainian president, Volodymyr Zelensky—that coordinate military and financial support for Ukraine and future security guarantees for Kyiv. The meeting, convened by Merz together with the French president, Emmanuel Macron, and the British prime minister, Andy Burnham, was attended by Trump's envoys, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, who reported on the talks in China. Merz gave each guest a piece of the Berlin Wall as an example of "what the Yalta agreement meant for Berlin" and addressed Putin: "End the war in Ukraine and let us work together to find diplomatic solutions." Burnham, Zelensky, Merz, Macron, Kushner and Witkoff at the press conference of the "coalition of the willing" in Berlin, this November 19. (REUTERS/Annegret Hilse)Several European governments had expressed their skepticism before the three leaders met. The French foreign minister, Jean-Noël Barrot, told RTL radio that "these three leaders do not agree on anything and, therefore, nothing will come out of that meeting." About the photo of the three before the meeting, he said that "it is not exactly the photo of the three greatest world powers," which in his view are the United States, China and the European Union. He added that the three countries meet because "they have something in common: they all border the Pacific." The Swedish prime minister, Ulf Kristersson, said his expectations of concrete results were "low," although "there is concern that this becomes a new 'Yalta,' with the world divided into spheres of influence." The Polish prime minister, Donald Tusk, wrote on the social network X, after Trump called Putin a "friend" in their bilateral meeting: "God, protect us from such friends." His foreign minister, Radosław Sikorski, said that "the optics of embracing Putin and calling him a friend cause us some concern." Trump's curious greeting to Putin before their bilateral meeting in ChinaThe text that the three presidents released at the end, published by Chinese state media, does not mention Ukraine or Europe. The closest sentence says that the leaders "exchanged in-depth views on the international situation" and committed to "maintaining strategic stability and international security." In Brussels, the European Commission's foreign policy spokesman, Christian Wigand, said they had seen the statement and that he would not go "into any detail." Asked about the "friend" treatment Trump gave Putin, the chief spokeswoman, Paula Pinho, responded that "in general, we do not comment on friendships." Several European affairs ministers, arriving in Brussels, acknowledged that they did not know the details of the meeting, but reiterated their governments' positions. Sweden's Jessica Rosencrantz said that "there must be no conversations about European security without Europe, nor about Ukraine without Ukraine." Ireland's Thomas Byrne said that "nothing will be decided about Europe without Europe." Poland's Ignacy Niemczycki rejected the comparison with Yalta: "Europe remains very strong" and, "even if some decisions were made, their implementation would be simply impossible without Europe's participation." The Danish prime minister, Mette Frederiksen, said in a statement before the Berlin meeting that Putin's demands "are about much more than Ukraine" and that it is about "European security on Russia's terms." "We must never accept that," she said. Putin said at his press conference that Russia had proposed through "diplomatic channels" that the Europeans travel to Moscow "to define their positions," and called it "strange" to discuss Europe's security without Europe, according to the Russian agency TASS. He also stated that "Ukraine and Europe are not yet ready to make compromises." Trump's envoys, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, informed Merz in Berlin about the talks in China. Kushner described the meeting as "very productive." Witkoff, Kushner and Günter Sautter, Merz's adviser, at the "coalition of the willing" summit in Berlin, this November 19. (Kay Nietfeld/Pool via REUTERS)Bloomberg reported that Trump told the Europeans that his conversation with Putin had gone well.