The Court declared Milei's decision to allow private health insurance companies to freely set the value of their fees unconstitutional

rss · La Nacion 2026-11-19T17:41:13Z es
The Supreme Court declared two articles of Decree of Necessity and Urgency (DNU) 70, issued by Javier Milei, unconstitutional; the articles had allowed prepaid medicine companies to freely set the values of their fees. Unanimously, the highest court upheld a ruling by the Federal Chamber of La Plata and declared unconstitutional the articles of the DNU that had swept away state control over the prices of health service benefit plans. The Court resolved the case of a woman who stated that her health plan fee had increased by 110% between December 2023 and February 2024, when, had a previous resolution of the National Ministry of Health been applied, the fee increase for January 2024 would have been 6.26%. The case reached the Court through appeals filed by the prepaid medicine company and by the National State. The highest court, with the signatures of Horacio Rosatti, Carlos Rosenkrantz, and Ricardo Lorenzetti, partially upheld the ruling. It maintained the declaration of unconstitutionality of articles 267 and 269 of DNU 70/23, but reversed what the chamber had ordered insofar as it required the defendant prepaid medicine company to limit fee increases to the percentage produced by the Consumer Price Index (CPI). The effect of today's Supreme Court ruling is that the Superintendence of Health must resume its powers regarding the review of fee values and their modifications, and its duty to oversee and guarantee the reasonableness of increases, which must be based "on variations in the cost structure" and on a "reasonable actuarial calculation of risks." In its ruling, the Court recalled the limits on the legislative powers exercised by the Executive Branch, which are exceptional. It said that in this case, the recitals of the decree do not reveal even minimal justification of the reasons or exceptional circumstances that motivated the modifications to the system. They held that the mere assertion that there is a "health system crisis" requiring "increasing the competitiveness of the system," for which "price restrictions on the prepaid medicine system must be lifted," is not sufficient. According to the Court, these generic considerations do not minimally demonstrate the existence of a situation of such urgency that it must be addressed immediately within a timeframe incompatible with the normal legislative process. In the view of the highest court, it was also not proven that there was a concrete relationship between the economic and social emergency invoked by the Executive Branch and the need to eliminate the regulatory powers of the enforcement authority. Story in development Type of work: News

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Highlight