Trump gave his participation in the Shenzhen summit more than a 10, but most analysts failed him

rss · La Nacion 2026-11-19T17:28:19Z es
WASHINGTON — Donald Trump did not arrive at the unprecedented tripartite summit in Shenzhen as he would have liked, badly wounded by an electoral beating that will condition the final stage of his time in the White House. And, surely, he did not leave the Chinese city as he would have imagined either, with Presidents Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin having much more to celebrate at a meeting laden with symbolism, though without significant advances for a world in permanent upheaval. After their warm greetings, at the very moment when Trump, Putin and Xi sat down alone around a large round wooden table, illuminated by crystal chandeliers in an imposing hall of the Kylin Villa, the host of the summit and the Russian leader sealed their opportunity to empower their position on the global geopolitical stage. Trump asserted that "history" was being made at the first summit held with the leaders of China and Russia. But at the meeting, which lasted 90 minutes, there was barely any sign of the main issues that the US president himself had raised before departing on his Asian tour — the wars in Iran and Ukraine — and a modest "peace declaration" centered on oil, nuclear risks, UN reform and the International Criminal Court (ICC). "Under the old approach, which consisted of refusing to address problems, nothing was ever resolved," Trump justified himself. "Peace was never forged by rejecting opportunities for dialogue…
WASHINGTON — Donald Trump did not arrive at the unprecedented tripartite summit in Shenzhen as he would have liked, badly wounded by an electoral thrashing that will condition the final stage of his time in the White House. And, surely, he did not leave the Chinese city as he would have imagined either, with Presidents Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin having much more to celebrate at an encounter laden with symbolism, though without significant advances for a world in permanent upheaval. After their warm greetings, at the very moment when Trump, Putin and Xi sat alone around a large round wooden table, illuminated by crystal chandeliers in an imposing hall of the Kylin Villa, the host of the summit and the Russian leader sealed their opportunity to empower their position on the global geopolitical stage. Presidents Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping and Donald Trump at the meeting in Shenzhen. SERGEI BOBYLYOV - POOL Trump claimed that "history" was being made at the first summit held with the leaders of China and Russia. But at the meeting, which lasted 90 minutes, there was hardly any sign of the main issues that the US president himself had raised before departing on his Asian tour — the wars in Iran and Ukraine — and a modest "peace declaration" centered on oil, nuclear risks, UN reform and the International Criminal Court (ICC). "Under the old approach, which consisted of refusing to address problems, nothing was ever resolved," Trump justified. "Peace was never forged by rejecting opportunities for dialogue and communication. Together, we are taking a different course," added the president, who faced questioning from his critics over the role he played at the summit. President Donald Trump at the summit in Shenzhen. Vyacheslav Prokofyev - Pool Sputnik Kremlin True to his grandiloquent style, Trump gave his trip a grade. "On a scale of zero to 10, I think it was a 12. It went wonderfully. Fantastic relationships were forged," he told NBC, already on the return flight to Washington. "Peace through strength" was the slogan the White House chose to "sell" the tour as a success. However, many international analysts agree that Trump's participation — weakened internally after the Republican debacle in the midterm elections — at that three-way table in China elevated the profile of Xi's regime as a global interlocutor and the main competitor of the United States. The Chinese leader joined Trump in affirming that the summit had "transcendental importance," added that "the world is at peace when the great powers live in harmony," and urged the three countries to "abandon the Cold War mentality, not seek decoupling or the breaking of chains." "The summit made clear that both the American president and the Russian one are trying to win Xi's favor," said Ali Wyne, researcher for US-China relations at the International Crisis Group. "From that point of view, the image was quite striking," he added. At the same time, for Putin — the great beneficiary — the scene served to continue leaving behind the status of international pariah derived from the 2022 invasion of Ukraine, further aided by a warm greeting from Trump that did not go unnoticed. "He is my friend," the magnate assured, laughing, as soon as he saw him (he also described Xi that way). "The president treats Russia like a friend and Canada like an enemy. The United States just elected a Congress that knows it is exactly the opposite," needled Democratic Congressman Hakeem Jeffries (New York), nominated to preside over the House of Representatives starting January 3. "Shameful, despicable and, frankly, pathetic," was how Democratic Senator Chuck Schumer (New York) described it; he is seeking to become majority leader in the upper chamber. The former Secretary of State and former Democratic candidate in the 2016 elections, Hillary Clinton, also lambasted Trump's role at the summit. "A strong American president with strategic vision should have demanded that the Russian army stop bombing Ukraine. He should have warned Xi that China will pay a price for supporting Russia's war machine [...] No one expected Trump to do any of this," she wrote in The New York Times. The Polish prime minister and former president of the European Council, Donald Tusk, was not far behind either. "It is not my role to comment on Trump's diplomatic language, but let us be clear: if he considers Putin his friend, the rule that your friend's friend is your friend certainly does not apply here. Putin is not our friend and never will be," he warned. Trump had arrived at the summit with a double weakness before Xi and Putin. The election results turned him into what in American politics is known as a "lame duck," a president in the final stretch of his term with diminished political power, and at 80 years old facing the final stretch of his stay in the White House and, surely, of his entire political career. While he remains at the head of the leading global power — and American foreign policy is still under his baton — analysts warn that his capacity for influence will be increasingly limited, before two leaders like Putin and Xi who already envision an American future without Trump starting in January 2029, when he must hand over the keys to the White House. Both autocratic leaders will be able to remain in power beyond that date. Presidents Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping and Donald Trump at the summit in Shenzhen. VYACHESLAV PROKOFYEV - POOL "In that triangle, the closest and most cordial relationship is the one between Xi and Putin, who have met on more than 40 occasions since 2013 and share the desire to erode American leadership on the world stage," noted American analyst Ryan Hass, director of the John L. Thornton China Center at the Brookings Institution in Washington. In that sense, the summit gave no indication that that long-standing anti-American stance shared by the Chinese and Russian leaders is going to change. "Nor will Trump be able to forge with either of them the same kind of relationship that the two maintain with each other," The New York Times analyzed. The greeting between Presidents Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen, China. Vyacheslav Prokofyev/Kremlin Pool - Planet Pix via ZUMA Press Wire Added to this is the implicit message Trump left for the allies of the United States in the Western world, who had already viewed the holding of the summit in Shenzhen with suspicion because of its possible implications for security and the future of the war in Ukraine. "The message is forceful. The trilateral meeting reinforces the European concern that their security is something negotiable. In Asia, partners such as Japan and Taiwan wonder whether the security commitments the United States maintains with them are also subject to negotiation. The result could be that many opt to cover their backs, drawing closer to Beijing, seeking greater strategic autonomy, or both," analyzed political scientist Scott Moore, executive director of Global Initiatives, Research and Strategy at the University of Pennsylvania. The summit symbolizes an alignment — previously unthinkable — between the United States and the world's main authoritarian powers, and could accelerate the fracturing of Western alliances, an objective that Moscow and Beijing have long pursued, he added.

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Highlight