Guatemala selects its new rapporteurs against torture, the process enters its final stretch in Congress

rss · Infobae 2026-11-19T16:48:47Z es
The Human Rights Commission of the Congress of Guatemala on Monday, November 16 rejected the objections against eight of the 31 applicants to be rapporteurs of the National Office for the Prevention of Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, so all the eligible candidates advanced to the evaluation stage to choose six positions for the next five years. Only those who score above 70 points in the evaluation of their backgrounds will be able to move on to an interview and present a work plan before the lawmakers. The commission began that review on Wednesday, November 18, and analyzed 15 files during the first day. The 70-point threshold before interviews and work plans The selection process began with 55 files, but 24 applicants were excluded for not meeting the requirements established in the Law of the National Mechanism for the Prevention of Torture, Decree 40-2010, and the Law of Nominating Commissions. The list of the 31 candidates who passed that filter was published on October 29 in the Diario de Centro América. The call then opened a period to receive objections and for those who had been excluded to submit clarifications. The extraordinary session to resolve the challenges did not include a public reading of the arguments. The lawmakers only identified each file, the questioned applicant, and the person who had raised the objection before voting. Several legisla…
Several deputies of the Congress of the Republic of Guatemala raise their hands to cast their vote during a working session. (Congress of the Republic of Guatemala) The Human Rights Commission of the Congress of Guatemala rejected on Monday, November 16, the objections against eight of the 31 candidates for rapporteur positions at the National Office for the Prevention of Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, so all the eligible candidates advanced to the evaluation stage to fill six positions for the next five years. Only those who score above 70 points in the evaluation of their backgrounds will be able to move on to an interview and present a work plan before the deputies. The commission began that review on Wednesday, November 18, and analyzed 15 files during the first session. The selection process began with 55 files, but 24 applicants were excluded for not meeting the requirements established in the Law of the National Mechanism for the Prevention of Torture, Decree 40-2010, and the Law of Postulation Commissions. The list of the 31 candidates who passed that filter was published on October 29 in the Diario de Centro América. The call then opened a period to receive objections and for those who had been excluded to submit clarifications. The extraordinary session to resolve the objections did not include a public reading of the arguments. The deputies only identified each file, the questioned applicant, and the person who had raised the objection before voting. Several legislators from the Winaq, National Unity of Hope, and Nosotros caucuses described some objections as "spurious." Among them were challenges against rapporteurs seeking reelection for having already held the position, even though the regulations do not prohibit a new candidacy. Former judge and sitting rapporteur Lesther Castellanos Rodas received four objections, the same number as Jennifer Alejandra Aldana García, also a sitting member of the body. Both remained in the contest after the deputies dismissed the allegations by majority. Several deputies of the Congress of the Republic of Guatemala raise their hands to cast their vote during a working session. (Congress of the Republic of Guatemala) The organization Alianza por las Reformas objected to Castellanos's candidacy, arguing that he had been inefficient during his tenure and that he participated in criminalization processes against justice operators. Freddy Noé Orellana Orellana accumulated two objections. Rita Magnolia Sandoval Rodríguez, Brian Iván Cruz Gómez, Luis Fernando de León Laparra, Hilda Margarita Franco Hernández, and Silvia Violeta de León Santos de Miranda each received one objection. Among the candidates still in the running are also Juan Carlos Humberto García Rosales, Cecilia Araceli Méndez Chicas de Galiardo, Christian Giovanni Orellana Castillo, Karen Yanira Palma Recinos, Dennis Waldemar Cisneros Torres, Xiomara Argentina Barillas Peláez, Pablo Adolfo Leal Olive, Eva Rocío Herrera Ramírez, José Fernando Roca Guinea, and Marlon Javier Juárez Mejicano. The applicants come from various disciplines related to human rights. The commission's chairwoman, Carolina Cerna, indicated that a review mechanism for the files already evaluated was not planned for the moment. The remaining evaluations were to be confirmed in later sessions. The commission seeks to form three shortlists with nine applicants. From that list, the full Congress must choose three principal rapporteurs and three alternates for a five-year term. Analysts consulted by eP Investiga warned that the voting scheme by caucus may favor candidates close to the deputies. The National Office for the Prevention of Torture had already faced criticism for its performance. Cerna expects the final list to be complete during the first weeks of December, when it will be sent to the Board of Directors and the Legislative Directorate of Congress for a vote in the full chamber.

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Highlight