The Court of Appeals partially upheld the illegality claim filed by Asesorías e Inversiones Sartor, the parent company of Sartor AGF, against Exempt Resolution No. 8,213 of August 14, 2025 issued by the Financial Market Commission (CMF), which ordered the liquidation of the asset manager's investment funds and redeemable mutual funds, appointing Toesca AGF as their liquidator. The claimant company is owned by Pedro Pablo Larraín, who is charged with serious economic crimes and has been held at the Santiago 1 penitentiary facility since August 18. In its ruling, the appellate court struck down the measure with respect to the investment funds Sartor Táctico, Sartor Proyección, Sartor Táctico Internacional and Sartor Capital Efectivo, as well as the mutual funds Sartor Deuda Corto Plazo, Deuda Corto Plazo II, Deuda Corto Plazo III, Mixto I, Mixto II and Mixto III, also annulling the appointment of Toesca AGF to liquidate them.
"The Financial Market Commission must issue, within thirty business days counted from when this ruling becomes final, a new reasoned resolution regarding the fate of the aforementioned funds," the court noted.
"In safeguarding the interest of the participants, it is placed on record that, while the Commission has not issued the new resolution, it retains — pursuant to Article 26 letter b) of the Single Funds Law (LUF) — the status of custodian of the funds and may keep Toesca in charge of their administration and preservation, with the powers necessary for that purpose; and that what has been decided does not affect the validity of the acts carried out by the liquidator in compliance with Exempt Resolution No. 8,213 to date, nor the rights acquired by third parties by virtue of them," the ruling added.
In simple terms, the capital's appellate court ordered the CMF to make a new decision on the future of these ten funds — whether to insist on their liquidation or transfer them to another asset manager — but this time backing it with information reviewed by the regulator itself and explaining, fund by fund, why that option best protects investors.
The conflict dates back to the CMF's progressive intervention in Sartor AGF, after detecting serious violations, such as conflicts of interest from investing public fund resources in private vehicles that financed individuals linked to its directors and shareholders, along with failures in liquidity and credit risk analyses. In August 2025, the regulator ordered the liquidation of these ten funds and the appointment of Toesca as liquidator, after the asset manager's first liquidator, Ricardo Budinich, reported that valuations by PwC and Deloitte revealed impairments of between 47% and 85% in the value of its portfolios.
Reactions
In response to the ruling, the Financial Market Commission told Pulso that "the Court has not questioned the CMF's powers or the merits of the decision; therefore, it validates all of the liquidator's actions and allows the CMF to keep the current liquidator in office until the new resolution is issued."
Asked about the effects of the ruling, the claimant's lawyer, Antonio Rubilar, a partner at Grupo Evans, explained to Pulso that "this ruling confirms the illegal conduct with which the CMF has operated in the Sartor case."
"This is the second categorical pronouncement by the higher courts, and it is especially serious: the Court annuls the liquidation of ten funds and the appointment of Toesca because the regulator disposed, in an irreversible manner, of the assets of thousands of contributors without having had or examined the valuation reports, improperly hiding behind secrecy to conceal that lack of grounds. No regulator can liquidate funds blindly," he added.
For his part, Toesca AGF's lawyer, Cristián Gandarillas, a partner at GMD, explained that "the court reaffirms the fact that there are numerous victims of the crimes under investigation, for which several defendants are being held in custody, and that the CMF acted in the interest and protection of the victims by validating what has been done to date. This resolution does not relate to the substance but only to the form, and at the same time it highlights the role the CMF has played in protecting the contributors."
"The rulings are being analyzed to determine whether to appeal them in order to continue protecting the rights of the contributors in the face of this enormous harm of which they have been victims," he added.
"The court reaffirms the fact that there are numerous victims of the crimes under investigation, for which several defendants are being held in custody, and that the CMF acted in the interest and protection of the victims, validating everything done so far," he concluded.
Are you already a subscriber? Log in
This article is exclusive to subscribers. Subscribe to read it in full and access all of our journalism. View plans
NEWSLETTER
Pulso PM
Monday to Friday, 12:30 PM
The most relevant news on markets, companies and business: timely information, context and content to make better decisions. By signing up, you are accepting La Tercera's Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policies.