The new Judicial Council must begin operating but cannot be fully constituted: there are six seats in dispute

rss · La Nacion 2026-11-19T14:47:15Z es
The new Magistracy Council was to be fully constituted today, the day on which the terms of the old council members expired, but its definitive composition has become mired in a political fight in Congress, with differences between ruling-party and allied deputies; with clashes in the Senate and with disagreements among the academics that will be resolved in the courts. The difficulties, however, do not interfere with the administration of the Judicial Branch, but rather with the distribution of power, and they affect the convening of a first plenary session, which will not happen anytime soon. Judges, lawyers, the Executive Branch, and one academic already have their representatives. The eight legislators are still missing, and the fight over those council seats has turned into a power struggle between the Government, Peronism, and the governors. Eight of the new council members have already been sworn in before the president of the Supreme Court and of the Magistracy Council, Horacio Rosatti. On November 5, judges Marcelo Gallo Tagle, Gabriela Vázquez, and Paula Castro were sworn in. On the 12th, judge Juan Manuel Culotta and the four lawyers took the oath: Alberto Biglieri, Claudia Sarmiento, Itatí Demarchi Arballo, and Fernando Levene. The Executive Branch's representative —Justice Deputy Minister Santiago Viola— and the academic representative Diego Molea have already been determined. The courts will decide who will be the second academic. There is a hearing in María Servini's court next Wednesday. The voting mechanism is being disputed, by...
The new Magistrature Council was supposed to be fully constituted today, the day the terms of the old council members expired, but its definitive composition has become mired in a political fight in Congress, with differences between ruling-party and allied deputies; with clashes in the Senate and with disagreements among academics that will be resolved in the courts. The difficulties, however, do not interfere with the administration of the Judicial Branch, but rather with the distribution of power, and they affect the convening of a first plenary session, which will not happen anytime soon. Magistrature Council member Álvaro GonzálezRicardo PristuplukJudges, lawyers, the Executive Branch, and one academic already have representatives. The names of six council members remain to be defined, including five legislators and one academic. The fight over those seats has turned into a power struggle between the Government, Peronism, and the governors. Eight of the new council members have already been sworn in before the president of the Supreme Court and of the Magistrature Council, Horacio Rosatti. Horacio Rosatti, president of the Supreme Court and the Magistrature CouncilNicolás SuárezToday, the council member representing the Executive Branch, Santiago Viola, Deputy Minister of Justice, and the representative of the academics, Diego Molea, rector of the University of Lomas de Zamora, were sworn in. They took office at the Palace of Justice, before Rosatti and the other two Supreme Court justices, Carlos Rosenkrantz and Ricardo Lorenzetti. On November 5, the judges Marcelo Gallo Tagle, Gabriela Vázquez, and Paula Castro were sworn in. On the 12th, judge Juan Manuel Culotta and the four lawyers were sworn in: Alberto Biglieri, Claudia Sarmiento, Itatí Demarchi Arballo, and Fernando Levene. The courts will decide who the second academic will be. There is a hearing in Judge María Servini's court next Wednesday. The voting mechanism is being disputed, due to differences between the UBA and the National Interuniversity Council. Deputy Minister of Justice Santiago Viola was sworn in as a Magistrature Council memberconsejo de la magistraturaThe picture that emerges is that of a politicized Council with council members who arrive with political patronage: the Menems, Sergio Massa, the Radical judicial operator Daniel Angelici, the Peronist Juan Manuel Olmos, Cristian Ritondo, and now also the governors. Yesterday, in the Chamber of Deputies, when the legislators who answer to Córdoba governor Martín Llaryora and Santa Fe governor Maximiliano Pullaro entered the chamber, they remained standing and did not sit down. After the regulatory half hour, the president of the Chamber adjourned the session. The governors were claiming the third seat of the Chamber on the Magistrature Council. Provincias Unidas, the bloc of provincial governors, was asking for that seat for Córdoba's Juan Brügge. The academic Diego Molea was sworn in as a Magistrature Council memberconsejo de la magistraturaWith 18 members, it is the third-largest bloc in the Chamber. Pro, with 12, is negotiating with the ruling party to keep the seat and bring in Florencia De Sensi, a deputy who answers to Cristian Ritondo. In parallel, Álvaro González, of the Larreta wing, is seeking to renew his term on the Council, but if the other play succeeds, he would be left out. The rest is already agreed. La Libertad Avanza will have two council members (in addition to Viola): Gonzalo Roca, who already sits on the Council, and Giselle Castelnuovo. Both are aligned with the Menems. Santa Fe's Nicolás Mayoraz had been mentioned as a candidate, but he would be left out. It is not yet official. Unión por la Patria goes from two council members to one. Cristina Kirchner blessed the designation of deputy Guillermo Michel, a federal Peronist close to Sergio Massa. Rodolfo Tailhade and Vanesa Siley, two Kirchnerist lieutenants, are leaving. That is already official. The notes from the Chamber of Deputies with the names of La Libertad Avanza's Roca and Castelnuovo and Unión por la Patria's Michel have already been sent to the Council. The name of the representative of the second minority, which is the one in dispute between Provincias Unidas and the PRO, has not yet been sent. The fight in the SenateIn the upper chamber, the dispute over the four seats is deeper. The law allocates two to the largest bloc and one to each of the two that follow. But today the question is who is the first minority. At the end of October, La Rioja's Fernando Rejal returned to the Justicialista bloc led by José Mayans. With him, Peronism reached 22 senators, one more than La Libertad Avanza. The ruling party maintains that the composition as of March 1 should be taken into account and that Rejal's switch was a maneuver to grab two seats. In 2022, Kirchnerism split its bloc to keep three of the four seats, and the Supreme Court annulled the move and ordered that Luis Juez be seated. Now, the PRO would lose that seat. Patricia Bullrich and Mayans agreed that Vice President Victoria Villarruel, who signs the appointment decree, should decide. The decision has not yet come, and both sides admit the dispute could end up in the courts. The names, however, are clear. Cristina Kirchner chose Wado de Pedro; if Peronism gets the second seat, La Rioja's Florencia López would go. La Libertad Avanza proposes Nadia Márquez and Belén Montes de Oca. Radicalism is still deciding between the continuity of Eduardo Vischi and Maximiliano Abad. Politicization has reached the technical sectors. Among the lawyers, the list Unidad en Defensa de la Abogacía won two seats. Biglieri is aligned with Angelici. Claudia Sarmiento comes from Jimena de la Torre's camp and arrives with the backing of San Juan governor Marcelo Orrego. The other two seats went to Peronism, which took more than 58% of the vote. Demarchi Arballo arrived with the list promoted by Juan Manuel Olmos and La Cámpora. Levene had the support of Molea, Massa, Radical senator Abad, and Llaryora. The libertarian list of Luis Palomino was left out. In the judges' election, each of the four lists obtained one seat. La Bordó, the most traditional grouping of the Association of Magistrates, won with 203 votes but lost a seat and only placed Gallo Tagle. Culotta entered through Compromiso Judicial. La Celeste, which was split, added two council members: Vázquez, linked to Kirchnerism, and Castro, backed by outgoing judge council member Alberto Lugones. For the academic sector there is Molea, rector of the University of Lomas de Zamora and former president of the Council; the second seat is tied up in court. The Executive Branch continues to be represented by Viola, and Rosatti remains at the head of the body as president of the Supreme Court. With 20 members, the quorum is 12. Approving a shortlist or impeaching a judge requires two-thirds of the council members present: with the full membership, that is 14 votes, so seven council members are enough to block. No sector reaches that figure. "It is going to be a more fractured, more atomized Council, which will negotiate case by case," a council member anticipated. With shortlists pending and competitions underway, each judicial appointment will come to depend on that negotiation. By Hernán CappielloType of work:News Original

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Highlight