In Praise of Tolerance

rss · La Tercera 2026-11-19T12:30:00Z es
Tolerance is perhaps the only value that can save the twenty-first century. I do not say this rhetorically. Those of us born immediately after the Second World War wanted to believe that the cost of the wars caused by intolerance had been so great that humanity had learned the lesson. We were wrong. Today the fanaticisms of identity—religious, ideological, nationalist, racial, of gender or of class—have resurfaced from the bowels of history. And as at its origin in the seventeenth century, tolerance, that fragile flag of modernity, is being put to the test. Tolerance must be defended. And for that, it is worth returning to that origin. Impressed by the political and religious hatreds that characterized Dutch life (and European life in general) in his century, the philosopher Baruch Spinoza published in 1670 his Theological-Political Treatise, in which he criticizes any attempt by any church or state to govern people's conscience: No one can abdicate his freedom of judgment and feeling; and since every man is, by inalienable natural right, master of his own thoughts, it follows that men who think in diverse and contradictory ways cannot, without disastrous results, be forced to speak only according to the dictates of the supreme power […] nothing can be imposed on men's conscience—it is not viable, it is not lawful; and from that freedom of conscience there naturally follows the possibility for man to hold beliefs and manifest them, and to conceive and elaborate opinions in which he believes, and to be able to publish them. To understand the tension that led him to write his treatise—in addition to the excommunication he suffered in his own community for defending his freedom of thought—it is enough to recall the outcome of those wars in the city of The Hague. It is an atrocious episode of which Spinoza was a witness. The victims were the De Witt brothers, friends of Spinoza. One of them, Jan, a mathematician with liberal ideas, was the Grand Pensionary (civil ruler) of Holland. His rival was William of Orange, heir to the royal house. In the context of a confrontation with the France of Louis XIV, the people of The Hague supported William, blamed the war on De Witt and his brother Cornelius, and in 1672 the mob not only lynched them both, but physically devoured them. A painting of the time that revives the scene. The De Witts hanging by their feet, flayed. How did the even-tempered philosopher of reason react? Beside himself for once, he wrote a manifesto titled Ultimi barbarorum and hung it on the door of the house in whose attic he lived. And it is moving what, according to a biographer, he said to his landlord: Do not fear for me [...] As soon as the mob makes the slightest noise at your door, I will go out and face them, even if they do to me what they did to the unfortunate De Witts. I am a good republican, and nothing has moved me except the honor and welfare of the state. Astonishingly, the twenty-first century is reenacting the scenes of the seventeenth century. What to do in the face of such extreme barbarity? "War is absurd—Spinoza wrote—but these problems do not make me laugh or cry. On the contrary, they encourage me to better understand human nature." That honest disposition to investigate in all their complexity the causes of today's wars in all their varieties—virtual and real, media and cybernetic—is the first duty of any intellectual endeavor, whether in universities or the media, whether by one who writes books or one who has a public voice. That scientific ethic, together with the daring to think freely and defend the freedom to think, is the task that Spinoza left for all generations. But in the face of the "ultimate barbarity" of our time, we must do more and be more. We must imitate the personal courage of that philosopher. Tolerance cannot degrade into indifference. Tolerance does not aspire to force the convergence of ideas and opinions, but rather the free discussion of them. Its only banner is the shared civility of one who listens and is listened to. That is why the greatest paradox of tolerance is the need to draw limits: when intolerance incites violence, it must be fought. To what extreme? To the extreme of Spinoza. With a sense of responsibility, each of us must wage that battle. And wage it with that same resolve. That, in our time as well, is to be a good republican. By Enrique Krauze, Mexican historian. Excerpt from the acceptance speech for the XXXII Prize of the Association for Tolerance, Madrid. NEWSLETTEROpinionSaturday, AMIdeas in tension, opposing viewpoints, and clear analysis: elements to unravel the issues that divide opinions and will set the agenda. By signing up you are accepting the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policies of La Tercera.

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Highlight