Why fog is abandoning an exceptional forest in Costa Rica and changing its ecosystem

rss · BBC Mundo 2026-11-19T12:00:14Z es
The Monteverde Cloud Forest, in Costa Rica, is losing its fog due to climate change, which puts numerous endemic species in danger.
Image source, Jocelyn Timperley/BBCAuthor, Jocelyn TimperleyAuthor's title, BBC Future*Publication date 20 minutesReading time: 14 minIn the misty Tilarán mountain range, above Monteverde (Costa Rica), an unusual combination of circumstances has given rise to something exceptional. A stretch of forest, permanently covered by a dense layer of clouds, is home to an enormous variety of highly specialized plants and animals. This is the only place on Earth where many of them exist. The ecological diversity of this cloud forest is astonishing. Some 400 species of birds live here, from the bellbird —known for its thunderous call— to the long-tailed manakin, famous for the males' courtship dance. Sloths, spider monkeys, jaguars, pumas and Baird's tapirs roam the terrain beneath thousands of tree species, whose branches are covered by dense mantles of vegetation. Dozens of unique amphibians thrive in this humid climate, along with a number of insect species so vast that it has not even been able to be counted. But the situation in this cloud forest —as in many other fragments of tropical cloud forests scattered around the world— is anything but encouraging. It is becoming increasingly clear that the clouds that give life to these ecosystems are beginning to dissipate. As the clouds move away, the forest world that stretches below is undergoing a profound transformation. Skip Most read and continue readingMost readEnd of Most readA refuge in the mistImage source, Getty ImagesCaption, Cloud forests are home to thousands of species that can only live in that habitat."When I first came to Costa Rica and saw the cloud forest, I thought: 'Oh my God! Look at all these plants, look at all these epiphytes!'". Ecologist Nalini Nadkarni and I are walking through the Children's Eternal Forest, an expanse of cloud forest in northwestern Costa Rica —approximately the size of Baltimore— that combines areas of virgin forest with reforested areas. When she first visited Monteverde in 1980, Nadkarni was instantly captivated by the epiphytes, a term that encompasses hundreds of plant species —from orchids and bromeliads to mosses, ferns and lichens—. Epiphytes sprout from every visible surface in the cloud forest; they never touch the ground and obtain all the water and nutrients they need from the mist. In the 1980s, she notes, little was known about their ecological function. The trees in the area creak under the weight of these plants. If one climbs up to the canopy —explains Nadkarni, who is currently a professor at the University of Utah— one finds horizontal branches covered with epiphytes, as if they were carpets. They have developed various strategies to capture water and nutrients from the constant mist that characterizes cloud forests. Orchids, in particular, constitute the most diverse family of epiphytes in Monteverde, with around 450 species. "Sometimes we are sitting on branches that literally harbor orchids worth US $10,000," says Nadkarni. "It's amazing." The vast majority of the non-woody biomass of the Monteverde cloud forest is made up of epiphytes. Moreover, their ability to absorb the nutrient-rich mist gives them a disproportionately high importance for other species. "They actually increase the amount of nutrients available and introduce them into the forest so they circulate internally," says Nadkarni. The exact number of epiphyte species that inhabit these forests is still unknown, as is what proportion of them is exclusive to this place. This is just one of the many fields of research trying to move forward, even as global warming begins to transform this ecosystem. Image source, Jocelyn Timperley/BBCCaption, Nalini Nadkarni examines a tree covered in epiphytes in the Children's Eternal Forest in MonteverdeWhat happens, then, if the clouds dissipate and these plants stop receiving the mist they feed on all year round? Their world falls apart. "These forests would be left, so to speak, off guard: they no longer have the mist or the fog," explains Nadkarni. Scientists call it the "cloud base lifting hypothesis": rising temperatures, caused by climate change, make the mist rise higher and higher, to the point of no longer reaching the mountains; this alters how often plants and animals are enveloped in clouds."And is that already happening?", I ask Nadkarni."It is already happening. We are already seeing its effects." Rising cloudsImage source, Jocelyn Timperley/BBCCaption, Epiphytes cover a tree in the Children's Eternal Forest. Researcher Alan Pounds, a scientist at the Monteverde Cloud Forest Reserve, first proposed the cloud base lifting hypothesis in the 1990s. "It has been shown that this is happening in many different areas," he tells me, "from the Andes to East Africa." Scientists like Pounds have been collecting data on humidity in the Monteverde cloud forest since the early 1970s. In 1999, he and two colleagues published a study warning that the number of dry days —defined as those in which a standard rain gauge records less than a tenth of a millimeter of precipitation, which serves as an indicator of the presence of mist and water from clouds— had increased dramatically, and also tended to cluster in consecutive periods lasting several days."If we go back to the 1970s, it was rare to record more than 25 days a year without precipitation," he says. In the 1990s, that figure rose to 59. According to his preliminary analysis —not yet published— between 2015 and 2023 an average of 119 days without rain per year was recorded. In addition, since 2002, Pounds has been collecting long-term data on mist and cloud water to try to better understand the situation. The final results are close to being published."[A mist forest or cloud forest] is a mountain immersed in clouds," he explains. "Or at least, that's how it should be; that's part of the problem: much of this is changing." There are other concerns about the climatic changes affecting this cloud forest. During the dry season, humid days seem to be becoming more humid, while dry days are becoming drier. "So far we have not observed a decrease in total precipitation," says Pounds, "but an ever greater contrast." Pounds also points out that the extent of the cloud layer may be decreasing, although he clarifies that this has not yet been confirmed. Warning bellImage source, AlamyCaption, The extinction of the Monteverde golden toad was one of the first, anywhere, to be linked to global warming. Because they appear near mountain tops, generally above 1,500 m, cloud forests tend to be much smaller than lowland forests —such as the seasonal rainforest that makes up most of the Amazon— which lack these permanent low clouds. In Monteverde, it takes just five minutes of driving to find yourself in a completely different microclimate. Their location on mountain tops also means that species are often isolated and therefore endemic; that is, native only to a specific area (which, in this case, is usually very small). This makes them especially vulnerable to extinction. Monteverde has, in fact, been the scene of the best-known impact of climate change on cloud forests: the disappearance of the famous golden toad in the late 1980s. This species, which inhabited a tiny area of cloud forest, remained buried underground for most of the year and emerged every spring to mate."You could see bright orange male toads hopping around everywhere looking for females," says Nadkarni. In 1987, more than 1,000 adult golden toads were observed mating. By 1989, only one male was sighted. The following year, none. The golden toad is now considered extinct. The probable cause: a lethal combination of climate change, an invasive fungus and a year marked by an intense "El Niño" phenomenon —a weather event that raises global temperatures—, which caused an exceptionally dry season. Since then, research by Pounds and other experts has documented a massive loss of frogs and toads, linked to both climate change and the fungus "Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis". Image source, Getty ImagesCaption, The Hercules beetle is one of the largest, and lives in the Monteverde reserve. The loss of species like the golden toad is a sign that the habitat is in the process of changing. One way to understand the impact of climate change on the cloud forest, says Pounds, is that "it is transforming into a seasonal rainforest... more like that of the lowlands." The result, he says, is that lowland species are arriving in the area. NewcomersImage source, Getty ImagesCaption, The resplendent quetzal, the long-tailed manakin and the three-wattled bellbird are among the most iconic species of the Monteverde cloud forest. Not all species feel at home in cloud forests, notes Pounds; however, "there are advantages... if one is able to adapt to the conditions," such as, for example, escaping the competition and predation from the great variety of species that inhabit lowland tropical forests. However, as the clouds in Monteverde dissipate, temperatures rise and the forest dries out, these lowland species are being seen more frequently. Keel-billed toucans —opportunistic predators that feed on the eggs and young of other birds— are nesting increasingly close to resplendent quetzals, an iconic species of Central American cloud forests that is already threatened due to deforestation. Venomous snakes, such as the fer-de-lance, are arriving in Monteverde. Likewise, lowland bat species seem to be moving to higher altitudes; among them, the enormous spectral vampire, which preys on quetzals. As the climate changes and these new species arrive, they may displace the current inhabitants and alter their environment, causing chaos in the complex and delicately balanced microecosystems of the cloud forest. Every species in this place has "its own space, its own rhythms and its own companions," explains Daniela Quesada Cruz, coordinator of community programs at the Monteverde Institute, a non-profit organization. For example, the 75 species of wild avocado present in Monteverde produce fruit at different times of the year; any alteration could cause the fruit to rot, with no birds to eat it and disperse its seeds. The effects of climate change essentially imply "the loss" of the most specialized flora and fauna of the higher altitude zones, says Pounds. "Everything is happening very quickly and, in reality, we have not had the resources necessary to carry out systematic sampling of everything we should have analyzed. It is an overwhelming situation." Image source, Getty ImagesCaption, Environmental changes are having effects on Monteverde's delicate ecosystem. The Monteverde cloud forest is not the only one in danger. Throughout Mesoamerica, climate change and deforestation are causing cloud forest plant species to move to higher altitudes, at an average rate of 1.8 to 2.7 meters per year. Globally, between 2001 and 2018, 2.4% of cloud forest area was lost. Early warningImage source, Getty ImagesCaption, Costa Rica's cloud forest ecosystem could be lost if the path stays the same. After the disappearance of the golden toad and the decline of other amphibian species in Monteverde, researchers began to observe other signs of the effects of climate on the cloud forest, says Nadkarni; effects that also affect trees and plants. Epiphytes —plants that depend on environmental humidity— constitute, in particular, a kind of early warning ("canary in the mine") of climate impacts, says Sybil Gotsch, a forest ecologist at the University of Kentucky. "It is the first plant community that will be affected, since their roots do not reach the ground. As the atmosphere dries out, we will lose these epiphytes." In cloud forests, ecosystems of immense complexity, it is difficult to quantify the extent of the losses already occurring. However, various studies —which have involved moving epiphytes to trees at lower altitudes or to greenhouses— have revealed that these plants are extremely vulnerable to the reduction of mist; likewise, mass extinctions are expected in the future if climate change continues unchecked. Climate change has advanced rapidly and, given the enormous diversity of species that inhabit these places, for most there are no long-term studies to serve as a reference for tracking changes. In 2016, Gotsch launched a ten-year study to monitor epiphytes, but the initiative was interrupted by Covid-19 (in 2027 she will publish a paper covering the first four years of the research). On a windy January day, I accompany Gotsch and Nadkarni to a farm located in the cloud forest ecosystem. There, through an experiment that consists of removing epiphytes from trees, they are trying to understand what could happen to other species if the cloud forest lost these plants. "We don't want to wait 50 years [to find out]," says Nadkarni. For example, without the epiphytes covering them, trees could experience greater growth, explains Gotsch; however, this is not as positive as it seems, since the trees could end up consuming even more water. Image source, Jocelyn Timperley/BBCCaption, Sybil Gotsch and Costa Rican scientist Elenter Cubero Campos examine a strangler fig from which the epiphyte plants were removed in 2022. They show me two pairs of large strangler figs; in each case, one has had its dense covering of epiphytes removed, while the other has been left as a control. They have eight other pairs of similar trees scattered around Monteverde. They are now measuring everything that, in their judgment, could vary in a tree stripped of epiphytes: from ambient temperature, humidity and wind speed, to sap flow, the appearance of leaves and their use by wildlife. Unknown lossesCountless more changes may be happening here, out of our sight. Pounds tells me of a "painfully evident" decline in the number of insects, judging simply by how many appear around lights at night. (Ecologists in the nearby region of Guanacaste have similarly observed a drastic drop in insect populations —even in their cloud forest—, which they attribute to climate change). Debra Hamilton, co-director of the Costa Rica Conservation Foundation (CRCF) and researcher in ecological restoration at the University of Vermont, expresses a similar concern based on her observations of the decline of insectivorous birds. "I think that's like the canary in the coal mine," she says. Hamilton, Pounds and other researchers are carrying out insect sampling and bird censuses in Monteverde to compare current figures with data from earlier times. A current concern is the ongoing "super El Niño" phenomenon. "Next year is forecast to be very dry," says Nadkarni. "The forest canopy is likely to suffer a severe impact." Hamilton points out that, this year, October —which is usually the rainiest month— has turned out to be surprisingly dry. "It's the first time I've heard of a drought weather alert during a month in which we normally receive a huge amount of rain," she says.What will be the ultimate fate of the cloud forest's ecology in the face of persistent climate change? One possible outcome is the emergence of an unprecedented ecosystem: new combinations of native and non-native species —self-organizing under human influence—, a phenomenon increasingly common around the world. Even so, it is far from clear which species —if any— will manage to endure among those specialized in the cloud forest, says Pounds. It is impossible to predict, he adds, what this ecosystem will end up becoming.Connecting habitatsMonteverde is, in a way, a pioneer in environmental matters. The area is protected by a mosaic of national parks and private reserves, established during the conservation boom of the 1970s and 1980s; moreover, the inhabitants of Monteverde are, for the most part, well informed about sustainability and their natural environment. Image source, Jocelyn Timperley/BBCCaption, More than half of the world's tree fern species live exclusively in cloud forests. Decades of ecotourism in Monteverde have supported conservation, says Quesada Cruz, encouraging locals to stop raising cattle and offer night walks, zip lines and canopy tours, keeping the trees on their lands in the process. But she believes tourism may be reaching a limit of sustainability. In some places that had been reforested, she says, developers have now cut down the forest and built new hotels. Long-term efforts are creating corridors to connect the cloud forest with areas outside the reserves, many of them private lands, helping to create space for species to move and migrate. The Monteverde Institute delivers about 10,000 native trees per year to locals, creating corridors for animals and windbreaks for farmers in the area's windy terrain. There is a push to plant native species in gardens. Ensuring connected habitats, along with broader restoration and protecting forests from development, fires and livestock, remains essential to protecting the cloud forest, says Katy VanDusen, coordinator of the local non-profit climate organization CorClima. What gives hope in Monteverde, she adds, is the local community. "What makes this place truly unique is how the community has collaborated, in creative ways and for decades, to solve problems, always with a firm commitment to conservation." I ask Hamilton —a scientist specializing in reforestation who has spent decades restoring habitats in Monteverde— whether conservationists might eventually be forced to intervene in these native forests, moving tree species to help both the trees themselves and the fauna they support adapt to the changes."That's a great question," she replies. She explains that longer-established scientists were trained under the strict premise of never introducing trees into new areas. "The way I see it, it's playing God. But, on the other hand, perhaps it's necessary to do it... because climate change is a reality. This is an adaptation into Spanish of a BBC Future story. If you want to read the original version, click here. Download the new BBC World Service app. Choose BBC News Mundo and receive news alerts, documentaries and analysis, all in one place. Important: the new app is not available in the UK or the United States. You can also follow us on YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, X and our WhatsApp channel. And don't forget to subscribe here to our newsletter to receive a special selection of our best content every Friday.

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Knowledge Graph

Entities
Highlight