The debate over Gross Income tax has returned to the Buenos Aires Legislature with a bill that proposes replacing it, gradually, with a tax applied only to final sales. The initiative seeks to change the way the province of Buenos Aires collects revenue without giving up resources, and focuses on the cost that the current tax adds to production, distribution and, ultimately, prices.
The author of the proposal is Oscar Liberman, a provincial deputy from La Libertad Avanza, who brought the bill to the chamber after working with a team of tax specialists. His diagnosis stems from an objection to the current mechanism: Gross Income tax is applied to invoicing at different stages of economic activity and, he argues, that cost is passed from one company to another before reaching the consumer.
The alternative Liberman is pushing for would replace Gross Income tax with a tax on final sales. That is, the levy would be charged when the product reaches the retail stage, at the point just before purchase, and not at every link in the production chain. The lawmaker stressed that the bill does not call for immediate elimination, but rather a progressive transition between the two models. "What we are presenting is a bill to substitute one for the other gradually," he explained on Infobae Al Amanecer.
The change, he explained, seeks to end a scheme that imposes taxes even when a company is going through...
AI Brief
Your highlights
Provincial deputy Oscar Liberman presented a bill in the Buenos Aires Legislature to gradually replace the Gross Receipts Tax with a levy on final sales
The debate over the Gross Receipts Tax has returned to the Buenos Aires Legislature with a bill that proposes replacing it, gradually, with a tax applied only to final sales. The initiative seeks to change how the province of Buenos Aires collects revenue without giving up resources, and focuses on the cost that the current tax adds to production, distribution and, ultimately, prices. The author of the proposal is Oscar Liberman, a provincial deputy from La Libertad Avanza, who brought the bill to the chamber after working with a team of tax specialists. His diagnosis starts with an objection to the current mechanism: the Gross Receipts Tax is applied to invoicing at different stages of economic activity and, he argues, that cost is passed from one company to another before reaching the consumer.
The alternative Liberman is pushing would replace the Gross Receipts Tax with a tax on final sales. That is, the levy would be charged when the product reaches the retail stage, just before purchase, rather than at every link in the production chain. The lawmaker stressed that the bill does not propose an immediate elimination, but a progressive transition between the two models. "What we presented is a bill to gradually substitute one for the other," he explained on Infobae Al Amanecer. The change, he explained, seeks to end a scheme that taxes companies even when they go through a period of losses. For the deputy, the central difference is that the new tax would fall at a single stage, while the current one is added to production, distribution and sales costs as the good changes hands.
The initiative seeks to eliminate the accumulation of tax burdens at each link in the production chain before products reach retail stores
Liberman took as a reference the systems that tax final consumption in the United States and Canada. Even so, he noted that the definition of the rates would be subject to eventual regulation if the bill becomes law. In his preliminary estimate, the necessary rate would have to be above 6% to preserve the province's revenue levels. The deputy described how an SME may be involved in several transactions before a product reaches a shelf or a counter. It buys inputs, outsources tasks, contracts services and sells to another player in the chain; at each of those movements, he said, the Gross Receipts Tax adds a burden that is then incorporated into the next price. "When it reaches the retailer, it doesn't carry a single Gross Receipts Tax burden, it carries an entire cascade," Liberman said on Infobae Al Amanecer while explaining the mechanism he criticizes. Under his proposal, that journey would stop accumulating the tax at each stage and would concentrate collection on the final sale transaction.
The lawmaker also criticized the withholding and advance-collection system. According to his argument, a company can make advance payments in different jurisdictions and later find it difficult to recover those balances. In that sense, the initiative seeks to modify the collection scheme without altering the revenue the province currently receives.
The discussion over prices appears as one of the central points of the bill. Faced with the possibility that the final tax would be passed on to the consumer, Liberman argued that eliminating accumulated burdens should offset that effect. In the least favorable scenario, he said, prices would remain unchanged, although producers, retailers and service companies would no longer face the distortions he attributes to the current regime.
The La Libertad Avanza initiative proposes modifying the provincial revenue-collection instrument without reducing the funds the Buenos Aires administration receives
The deputy rejected the claim that the proposal would defund the Buenos Aires administration. "You don't lose revenue with the bill," he asserted, maintaining that the goal is to substitute one revenue source for another, not to reduce the funds available to the province. Liberman separated that tax discussion from La Libertad Avanza's criticism of provincial public spending. He clarified that how resources are administered is not part of his bill's text: the initiative focuses on changing the instrument used to collect revenue and on preventing the tax from accumulating during the production process.
As a broader horizon, the lawmaker mentioned a reform that would include a reduction of the national VAT and the creation of a provincial VAT with rates defined by each district. However, he noted that this variant would require a fiscal reform, changes to the revenue-sharing law and a political agreement among governors, which is why he presented the final sales tax as a possible option ahead of that debate.
The bill must first go through committee review in the Buenos Aires Legislature before reaching the chamber floor. Liberman warned that the main obstacle is not limited to securing votes, but rather getting the initiative onto the parliamentary agenda, since many bills go unaddressed for months or until the end of the legislative year. For the deputy, support from the productive sectors could influence that process. He mentioned agriculture, industry, commerce and services among the sectors that criticize the tax and that, in his view, could push for the debate to advance within the chamber. "The Gross Receipts Tax has to go," Liberman said, summarizing a position he attributed to those sectors. The lawmaker added that officials in Axel Kicillof's administration also recognize, in his view, the need to review the tax, although so far there has been no replacement bill promoted by the ruling party.
The deputy described the Gross Receipts Tax as one of the levies that most affects companies with narrow margins: an additional burden, he argued, can turn limited profitability into a loss. Along the same lines, he placed the inflation tax among the factors that most strongly harm those with fewer resources, while he awaits the start of his initiative's proceedings in the legislative committees.
–Infobae accompanies you every day on YouTube with interviews, analysis and the most important news, in a close and dynamic format.
• From 7 to 9: Infobae al Amanecer: Nacho Giron, Luciana Rubinska and Belén Escobar.
• From 9 to 12: Infobae a las Nueve: Gonzalo Sánchez, Tatiana Schapiro, Ramón Indart and Cecilia Boufflet.
• From 12 to 15: Infobae al Mediodía: Maru Duffard, Andrei Serbin Pont, Fede Mayol and Facundo Kablan.
• From 15 to 18: Infobae a la Tarde: Manu Jove, Maia Jastreblansky and Paula Guardia Bourdin; rotating during the week: Marcos Shaw, Lara López Calvo and Tomás Trapé.
• From 18 to 21: Infobae al Regreso: Gonzalo Aziz, Diego Iglesias, Malena de los Ríos and Matías Barbería; rotating during the week: Gustavo Lazzari, Martín Tetaz and Mica Mendelevich
Follow us on our YouTube channel @infobae.