No EU institution did more than the European Parliament to bring about the Union’s first common Ethics Body. Decades of scandals, from the resignation of the Santer Commission in 1999 to Qatargate in 2022, had exposed conflicts of interest, revolving doors, and the influence of private interests.
In response, the parliament championed an unprecedented attempt to reform the fragmented and largely self-policed ethics systems of the EU institutions. It pushed for the body, negotiated its creation, approved the agreement and signed it, but today, it is the same institution quietly killing it.
Two and a half years after the agreement was signed, the Interinstitutional Body for Ethical Standards has yet to hold its first meeting. It was presented as a landmark step towards restoring public trust in the EU.
The political families that make up parliament’s right-wing majority are now deliberately preventing it from starting work: the European People’s Party (EPP), together with the European Conservatives and Reformists (ECR), Patriots for Europe (PfE), and Europe of Sovereign Nations (ESN) groups.
The story began long before Qatargate, arguably the most damaging corruption scandal in the history of European integration. After the Santer commission collapsed, commission vice-president Neil Kinnock proposed an advisory group on standards in public life. The initiative was later quietly shelved.
Academia and civil society subsequently revived the idea. In 2019, Daniel Freund, a former Transparency International EU campaigner newly elected as a German Green MEP, helped secure commission president Ursula von der Leyen’s commitment to a common independent ethics body in her political programme.
In 2020, the Greens in the European Parliament asked me to develop a legal blueprint for such a body, drawing on France’s High Authority for Transparency in Public Life. Parliament adopted that blueprint in September 2021. It called for an independent body with investigative powers and the power to recommend sanctions.
Yet it took Qatargate, which erupted in December 2022, to turn this long-standing proposal into an institutional priority. The scandal exposed the vulnerability of a system in which EU institutions largely policed their own members.
More critically, it unveiled how in the EU Parliament, seven in 10 MEPs have outside activities , and roughly a quarter are paid for them, under limited scrutiny.
The pressure to show that the EU was serious about cleaning up its act became irresistible: Within a week, Parliament voted by 541 to two to demand the ethics body.
When the EU Commission presented its proposal in June 2023, parliament called it “unsatisfactory” and pushed for a stronger role for independent experts and closer scrutiny of declarations of interest.
Negotiations among eight EU institutions and bodies eventually produced a compromise. It fell far short of parliament's original vision, but was still a significant achievement.
The body would develop common minimum standards on financial and non-financial interests, outside activities, gifts, hospitality, travel, and contacts with lobbyists. Five independent experts would advise the participating institutions. Each institution would assess its own rules against the common standards and explain publicly how it intended to close the gaps.
On 25 April 2024, MEPs approved the deal by 301 votes to 216. Three weeks later, it was signed in parliament’s name.
EU parliament president Roberta Metsola called it “a starting point”. The text is not just a declaration of good intentions, but - as it states plainly - it is binding.
How the EPP stalled it
For its part, the EPP never liked it. Most of its MEPs had voted against the deal, and, after the 2024 EU elections, the party found the allies it needed to stall it: the three groups to its right.
In February 2025, parliament told its partners it could not move until it had updated its internal rules. In May, the EPP and its allies voted down the very report that would have made those amendments.
Now even the appointment of the body's five independent experts has become a battleground.
The Irish EU Council presidency has formally asked the EU Parliament to endorse the nominees and attend a first meeting in December.
They are Věra Jourová, Erkki Liikanen, Leo Brincat, Dagmar Roth-Behrendt, and Élisabeth Morin-Chartier. Every other participating institution has approved them, including the EU Commission.
Yet the EPP has blocked a fast-track endorsement in parliament. Lóránt Vincze, the EPP's lead MEP on the file, now says the Ethics Body “cannot be revived”.
But it has never met only because his own party blocked it.
Parliament is still legally bound
Slow-walking the Ethics Body, however, runs into one obstacle: EU law. Parliament formed the body by a plenary vote, and only another plenary vote can undo it.
No political group, committee or Conference of Presidents can do so by stalling. The agreement is legally binding, and its text says so explicitly. Parliament remains bound by it unless it lawfully withdraws, and must cooperate in good faith with the other institutions that signed it.
By refusing to take the steps necessary to make the agreement operational, the EU Parliament risks exposing itself to legal action for failure to act.
Under Article 265 of TFEU [EU treaty], another EU institution, or a member state can formally call on parliament to act and, if it fails to define its position within two months, bring the matter before the EU Court of Justice in Luxembourg.
The EU's only directly elected institution could thus find itself condemned by its own court for failing to honour a commitment it voluntarily undertook.
And where, in all this, is the parliament's president? Metsola signed the agreement. She chairs the Conference of Presidents and, under parliament's rules of procedure, is the institution's legal representative. She cannot treat the agreement as a political project her own party is free to abandon. Her responsibility is to ensure that parliament honours its commitments.
If the EPP wants out, it must make its case to the plenary, where it can be debated and voted on openly.
How can the president allow a group of MEPs to walk away from parliament’s legal obligation without even putting it to a vote? That this group happens to be her own political family makes her silence all the harder to explain.
MEPs are entitled to oppose the Ethics Body. They are not entitled to kill it through manufactured procedural delays that evade public scrutiny and accountability.
Paradoxically, MEPs have remarkably little to fear from this agreement. Even the EPP, the group with the highest share of MEPs declaring paid outside activities, should not be afraid.
The body has no power to investigate or sanction MEPs. It does not replace parliament's own rules. It sets common standards and brings independent expertise into a system that has long relied on self-regulation.
If even this modest step towards accountability is unacceptable, the real question is whether parliament is willing to accept even the most basic common standards of probity.
Those who want to kill the Ethics Body should say so openly, put the EU Parliament's withdrawal to a plenary vote, and defend that decision before European voters. Their refusal to do so tells us everything.
They know what voters would think of MEPs who voted down an ethics watchdog, so they prefer to work in the dark. It is now up to Metsola, and the rest of us, to drag the situation into the light.