TO THE EDITOR:
Ahead of the upcoming departure of the Chilean vessel Danstar for the Falklands/Malvinas Islands, it is worth recalling that free navigation through the Strait of Magellan is guaranteed by current international treaties, as seven former commanders-in-chief of the Navy recently warned.
Article V of the 1881 Boundary Treaty enshrined this principle, reaffirmed by Article 10 of the 1984 Treaty of Peace and Friendship, which obliges Argentina to allow, "at any time and in any circumstances," the expeditious and unobstructed passage of ships of all flags.
This guarantee is also protected by Article 35, paragraph (c), of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). Furthermore, Article 14 of the 1984 Treaty bars interpretations incompatible with its provisions.
No unilateral interpretation of maritime jurisdiction nor political declaration of support for the Argentine cause regarding the islands can alter freely undertaken legal obligations. Navigation through the Strait constitutes an inalienable right, independent of political or economic convenience.
And since some Argentine sectors seem fond of invoking legal Latinisms—such as the aforementioned casus belli—it would be well to remind them of an essential one: pacta sunt servanda. What is agreed must be honored.
The best way to safeguard bilateral relations is not to reinterpret treaties according to the convenience of the …
AI Brief
Your highlights
CommentsTO THE EDITOR:Before the upcoming departure of the Chilean vessel Danstar for the Falkland Islands/Malvinas, it is worth recalling that free navigation through the Strait of Magellan is guaranteed by existing international treaties, as seven former commanders-in-chief of the Navy recently warned. Article V of the 1881 Boundary Treaty enshrined this principle, reaffirmed by Article 10 of the 1984 Treaty of Peace and Friendship, which obliges Argentina to allow, "at any time and in any circumstances," the expeditious and unobstructed transit of ships of all flags. This guarantee is also protected by Article 35, paragraph c), of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). Furthermore, Article 14 of the 1984 Treaty precludes holding interpretations incompatible with its provisions. No unilateral interpretation regarding maritime jurisdiction, nor any political declaration of support for the Argentine cause regarding the islands, can modify freely undertaken legal obligations. Navigation through the Strait constitutes an inalienable right, independent of political or economic convenience. And since some Argentine sectors seem fond of invoking legal Latinisms — such as the aforementioned casus belli — it would be fitting to remind them of an essential one: pacta sunt servanda. What has been agreed must be honored. The best way to safeguard bilateral relations is not to reinterpret treaties according to the convenience of the moment, but to comply with them.Francisco Orrego BauzáMore about:Free navigationDanstarTreatiesStrait of Magellan