Justice Among Colleagues
TO THE EDITOR:
Don Álvaro Mesa Latorre, a minister of the Temuco Court of Appeals, sued for negligent misconduct and defended by the Public Criminal Defender's Office, sought protection in the very court where he himself serves. The motion was aimed at the Valdivia Guarantee Court, but it was filed in Temuco, whose judges are all disqualified from ruling on matters concerning him.
None of that stopped that Court. It declared the action admissible, requested a report, and placed it on the docket, whereby the magistrate's fate would have been decided by those who share the bench with him, and only the recusal claimed by the plaintiff's side prevented it. Valdivia rejected the protection, and the Supreme Court confirmed that decision a few days ago, four votes to one. This brings to five the protection motions the highest court has rejected from him, amid a silence that is also shameful.
If no minister of Temuco could hear this matter, who intended to rule on it, and to whom is a Court that processes the case of one of its own accountable?
Carla Fernández Montero
Plaintiff's attorney
AI Brief
Your highlights
Court of Appeals of Temuco Comments Justice Among Colleagues
TO THE EDITOR:
Don Álvaro Mesa Latorre, an appellate minister of the Court of Appeals of Temuco, sued for negligent prevarication and defended by the Public Criminal Defender's Office, sought protection in the very court where he himself serves. The appeal was directed against the Valdivia Guarantee Court, but it was filed in Temuco, whose judges are all disqualified from ruling on matters concerning him. None of that stopped that Court. It declared the action admissible, requested a report, and placed it on the docket, whereby the magistrate's fate was to be decided among those who share the bench with him, and only the incompetence claimed by the plaintiff party prevented it. Valdivia rejected the protection, and the Supreme Court confirmed that decision a few days ago, four votes to one. This brings to five the protection appeals that the highest court has rejected for him, amid a silence that is also shameful. If no minister of Temuco could hear this matter, who intended to rule on it, and to whom is a Court that processes the case of one of its own accountable?
Carla Fernández Montero
Plaintiff attorney
More about: Minister Mesa / Temuco Court / Accountability