The leader of the Socialist Party (PS) deputies' caucus, Raúl Leiva, stated that the recent Supreme Court ruling on a request for sentence reduction undermines one of the main arguments of Justice Minister Fernando Rabat, amid the impeachment proceedings being pushed against him by the opposition.
The ruling, issued on Tuesday, November 17, ordered the Ministry of Justice to "accept or reject," as soon as possible, the sentence reduction request filed by Víctor Manuel Alarcón Torres, who was convicted of raping a minor.
The decision by the highest court comes after the government announced a general suspension of sentence reduction decrees and while the impeachment proceedings against Rabat move forward, the first chapter of which questions both the benefits granted to those convicted of sexual crimes against minors and the halting of the requests.
In Leiva's view, the Supreme Court's pronouncement demonstrates that the Secretary of State has the authority to decide on these benefits and is not limited to formalizing the determinations of the sentence reduction commissions.
"In other words, the Supreme Court has today told Minister Rabat, undermining his main argument, that he has the legal authority to accept or reject a sentence reduction," the lawmaker asserted.
The deputy contrasted that interpretation with the explanations given by the head of the J…
AI Brief
Your highlights
The leader of the Socialist Party (PS) deputies' bloc, Raúl Leiva, stated that the recent Supreme Court ruling on a request for sentence reduction undermines one of the main arguments of Justice Minister Fernando Rabat amid the impeachment motion driven by the opposition against him. The ruling, issued on Tuesday, November 17, ordered the Ministry of Justice to "accept or reject," as soon as possible, the sentence reduction request filed by Víctor Manuel Alarcón Torres, convicted of the rape of a minor. The decision by the highest court comes after the government announced a general suspension of sentence reduction decrees and as the impeachment motion against Rabat advances, whose first chapter questions both the benefits granted to those convicted of sexual crimes against minors and the paralysis of the requests. In Leiva's view, the Supreme Court's pronouncement demonstrates that the Secretary of State has the authority to decide on these benefits and is not limited to formalizing the determinations of the sentence reduction commissions. "In other words, the Supreme Court has today told Minister Rabat, undermining his main argument, that he has the legal authority to accept or reject the sentence reduction," the parliamentarian asserted. The deputy contrasted that interpretation with the explanations given by the head of the Justice Ministry before the Chamber of Deputies, where, he recalled, he had stated that his role was limited to ratifying the commissions' decisions. "Unlike what Minister Rabat has argued and stated in this special session, in this Chamber — that he could only formalize or ratify the sentence reduction — here the Supreme Court itself has established that he has the possibility, as we maintain in the impeachment brief, of accepting or rejecting what is proposed by the Sentence Reduction Commission," he said. Leiva asserted that the ruling constitutes "an input that obviously, I insist, undermines the allegations made by the Minister in the venue of this body in the special session and that obviously obliged him to make a decision."