Given the importance of the case, retired judge Martha Eugenia Magaña López requested that the Judicial Disciplinary Tribunal (TDJ) discuss and resolve the administrative process against her for granting an injunction (amparo) against the judicial reform of former Mexican president Andrés Manuel López Obrador in a public hearing. Through a letter sent to the Tribunal's Disciplinary Commission, chaired by Rufino León Tovar, the judge requested a session with in-person access or live broadcast through institutional channels, safeguarding only confidential information of third parties or personal data unrelated to the central issue, in order to review the decisions she made in the context of the judicial reform. She asserted that Article 111 of the Internal Regulations of the Judicial Disciplinary Tribunal, which provides for private sessions, is a norm hierarchically inferior to the Political Constitution of the United Mexican States, which enshrines the fundamental right to be judged in a public hearing. "Mexican society demands a transparent exercise of justice with open doors. The debate on the exercise of jurisdiction and the defense of judicial independence must take place face to face with the citizenry," she stated. She considered that the Mexican people have the right to know directly the arguments of her defense, the reasons put forward by the members of the Judicial Disciplinary Commission, and the outcome of the vote. She detailed that her request is based on Articles 1, 6, and 17 of the Constitution; Article 14.1 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights; Principle 17 of the United Nations on judicial independence; as well as guiding criteria of the European Court of Human Rights (such as the cases Olujić v. Croatia and Ramos Nunes de Carvalho e Sá v. Portugal), which support the importance of publicity in disciplinary proceedings when the person being judged expressly requests it. For these reasons, she formally requested that the full bench of the Judicial Disciplinary Tribunal act with complete transparency, setting aside the opacity with which, she asserts, it habitually acts. You may be interested in: Jufed backs the observations of the UN Committee on Economic Rights; denounces persecution against judges and suspension of injunctions. Judicial Disciplinary Tribunal: another nail in the coffin of judicial independence. Companies must retain users' telephone records for two years, the Court approves; Justice Ríos calls for respect after criticism. Join our channel! EL UNIVERSAL is now on WhatsApp! From your mobile device, find out the day's most relevant news, opinion articles, entertainment, trends, and more. dft