Asked at a Wednesday confirmation hearing whether the law allowed people to give the president a $1 million bribe in exchange for a pardon, a White House attorney up for a major intelligence job said it was a "complicated legal question."
Gary Lawkowski, who advised President Donald Trump in office and on the campaign trail, faced tough questioning from Democrats during his Wednesday hearing to serve as general counsel to the Office of Director of National Intelligence.
"You were just the lawyer. But so many times, 'I was just the lawyer' kind of becomes the default answer."
The hearing came as Senate Intelligence Committee Chair Tom Cotton, R-Ark., sought to rush Lawkowski's confirmation to the top intelligence posting before the end of the year, when Democrats take over Congress.
Although Lawkowski drew no hostile questions from Republicans, Democratic senators were concerned about Lawkowski's role in Trump's pardon spree, as well as his involvement in controversial executive orders that directed federal law enforcement to crack down on the left and designate antifa as a domestic terror organization.
"We're looking for judgment here," said Sen. Mark Warner, D-Va., vice chair of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence. "And I understand: You were just the lawyer. But so many times, 'I was just the lawyer' kind of becomes the default answer."
Lawkowski's current position is deputy assistant and deputy counsel to the president. He was little known outside the White House before Trump nominated him earlier this month to serve at the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, a Cabinet-level department where he would coordinate legal advice for the 18 different agencies making up the intelligence community.
According to a questionnaire, Lawkowski has not held jobs at intelligence agencies before. His prior national security experience involves advising Trump on classified matters over the past two years.
He also has a long-standing relationship with Trump. During Trump's time out of the White House, he helped provided legal advice to the president's reelection campaign and defended him from lawsuits brought by people harmed during the January 6 insurrection.
Questioning His Record
During the Senate hearing, Warner criticized Trump's pardons for January 6 rioters and for crypto mogul Changpeng Zhao. The crypto tycoon's company Binance was involved in a transaction that benefited one of the Trump family's crypto ventures.
Lawkowski suggested that prior reporting in the New York Times had exaggerated his role in the pardon process.
"My main focus was litigation and policy," he said. "I'm actually not our primary pardon counsel. I have worked on some pardon issues."
Sen. Angus King, an independent from Maine who caucuses with the Democrats, pressed Lawkowski on whether it would be illegal for someone to walk into the Oval Office and hand the president a $1 million bribe for a pardon.
"That's OK?" King said.
"Well, bribery itself would be a separate statutory crime. How that would interact with presidential immunity would be a complicated legal question that I think the court kind of reserved in that case," he said, referring to a 2024 Supreme Court decision that granted the president broad immunity from prosecution for official acts.
Another senator zeroed in on Lawkowski's role in crafting National Security Presidential Memorandum-7, commonly known as NSPM-7, the executive order directing federal law enforcement agencies to target "antifa" and other boogeymen of the far right.
In the written questionnaire, Lawkowski said he was involved in "communications" regarding that order and another that purported to designate antifa — the loose-knit anti-fascist movement — as a domestic terror group. He declined to explain further, citing the confidentiality of his legal conversations with the president.
"There is no basis in law to designate a domestic terrorist organization, but you have claimed the president can just do it."
"There is no basis in law to designate a domestic terrorist organization, but you have claimed the president can just do it anyways based on some magical constitutional authority," said Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore. "Once he's operating outside the law, are there any limits to how Donald Trump can persecute Americans?"
"I don't agree with the premise that the president is acting outside of the law," Lawkowski said. "Of course, the president is constrained by the limits of the Constitution."