A new ruling by the Supreme Court adds to the controversy facing Justice Minister Fernando Rabat over the sentence reductions granted to people convicted of sexual offenses against minors and crimes against humanity.
The Second Chamber of the highest court upheld a ruling by the Valparaíso Court of Appeals that obliges the ministry to "grant or reject" the sentence reduction request of Víctor Manuel Alarcón Torres, 54, who is serving a sentence of five years and one day in prison for the rape of a 14-year-old girl.
The decision, adopted on Tuesday, November 17, comes after the government announced, on November 9, the suspension of all sentence reduction decrees, without exception, while a bill to repeal the regulation that allows access to this benefit advances in Congress.
The ruling also comes amid the constitutional accusation filed by the opposition against Rabat. In the first of its three chapters, the accusers argue that the minister "suspended the processing of applications, against the legal obligation incumbent upon him to decide." Likewise, the accusers argue that the minister "resolved with general effect a controversy that it was for the Courts of Justice to decide case by case," invoking, according to the brief, the desirability of avoiding litigation.
Alarcón is serving his sentence at the Centro de D…
AI Brief
Your highlights
A new Supreme Court ruling adds to the controversy facing Justice Minister Fernando Rabat over sentence reductions granted to individuals convicted of sexual offenses against minors and crimes against humanity. The Second Chamber of the highest court upheld a ruling by the Valparaíso Court of Appeals that orders the ministry to "grant or reject" the sentence reduction request of Víctor Manuel Alarcón Torres, 54, who is serving a sentence of five years and one day in prison for the rape of a 14-year-old girl. The decision, adopted on Tuesday, November 17, comes after the government announced, on November 9, the suspension of all sentence reduction decrees, without exception, while a bill to repeal the regulation that allows access to this benefit advances in Congress. The ruling also comes amid the constitutional impeachment filed by the opposition against Rabat. In the first of its three chapters, the accusers argue that the minister "suspended the processing of applications, against the legal obligation upon him to decide." Likewise, the accusers argue that the minister "resolved with general effect a controversy that it was for the Courts of Justice to decide case by case," invoking, according to the filing, the desirability of avoiding litigation. Alarcón is serving his sentence at the Limache Preventive Detention Center. The controversy began when the Valparaíso Sentence Reduction Commission excluded him from the evaluation process due to the crime for which he was sentenced. After a first writ of protection, the Valparaíso Court of Appeals ordered him reinstated to the procedure and to have his behavior evaluated without applying the exclusion ground set forth in Article 17, letter e), of Law 19.856. Subsequently, the commission rated him with "outstanding conduct." According to his defense, the accumulated reductions would have allowed his release from prison to be moved up to October 26 of this year. Faced with the Ministry of Justice's lack of response, his lawyer filed a second writ of protection, alleging illegal deprivation of liberty due to the delay in issuing the corresponding decree. On November 5, the Court of Appeals granted that action and ordered the ministry to resolve the request within 24 hours. The CDE's arguments and the judicial decision The State Defense Council (CDE), which took over the representation of the Ministry of Justice, appealed to the highest court, arguing that the ministry must conduct its "own examination and not a merely formal analysis" of the conduct rating made by the respective commission. In its filing, the agency argued that such an examination must be carried out "exhaustively," and that neither Law 19.856 nor its regulations establish a deadline for the ministerial ruling. It also argued that the sentence reduction only takes effect once the decree recognizing the benefit has been issued. In its ruling, the Supreme Court acknowledged that "Law No. 19,856 and its Regulations do not set a deadline for the respondent agency to issue the decree ruling, negatively or affirmatively, on the request for recognition of the sentence reduction." However, it upheld the appealed ruling, establishing that "the Ministry of Justice and Human Rights must, as soon as possible, grant or reject the request for recognition of the benefit of sentence reduction of the protected person in accordance with the provisions of Law No. 19,856 and its regulations." In this way, the highest court maintained the obligation to resolve the petition, although it eliminated the 24-hour deadline set at first instance.