In a nearly unanimous decision, four votes to one, the Second Chamber of the Supreme Court upheld the ruling that had declared the amparo petition filed by the Office for the Defense of Children inadmissible.
The action brought by the institution led by defender Anuar Quesille sought to annul the 56 decrees signed by the Ministry of Justice to reduce the sentences of sex offenders whose victims were minors.
The ruling by the highest court received the favorable votes of justices Manuel Valderrama, María Cristina Gajardo, and Dinko Franulic, as well as of the ad hoc member Pía Tavolari.
However, it received the dissenting vote of Justice Jorge Zepeda. The justice considered that "at an initial admissibility stage, there is not sufficient background information to dismiss the action in limine litis, especially given its urgent nature."
The ruling by the highest court confirmed what the Santiago Court of Appeals had already previously decided.
That ruling was unanimous and also included a separate opinion by ad hoc member Catalina Infante, who joined the inadmissibility decision taking into account that in the acts of Justice Minister Fernando Rabat alleged by Quesille in his amparo petition "there are no facts supporting the claimed illegality."
AI Brief
Your highlights
NationalThe ruling confirming the inadmissibility of the constitutional action was issued by the Second Chamber of the highest court, and the decision was reached by four votes to one. Andres Perez CommentsIn a nearly unanimous decision, by four votes to one, the Second Chamber of the Supreme Court upheld the ruling that had declared the amparo petition filed by the Childhood Defense Office inadmissible. The action by the institution led by defender Anuar Quesille sought to annul the 56 decrees signed by the Ministry of Justice to reduce the sentences of sexual offenders whose victims were minors. The ruling by the highest court received the favorable votes of justices Manuel Valderrama, María Cristina Gajardo and Dinko Franulic, as well as that of appointed lawyer Pía Tavolari. However, it was opposed by the vote of Justice Jorge Zepeda. The justice considered that "at an initial admissibility stage, there is not sufficient background information to dismiss the action in limine litis, especially given its urgent nature." The ruling by the highest court confirmed what the Santiago Court of Appeals had already previously decided. That ruling was unanimous and also included a dissent-in-part from appointed lawyer Catalina Infante, who joined the inadmissibility decision taking into account that in the acts of Justice Minister Fernando Rabat alleged by Quesille in his petition "there are no facts supporting the claimed illegality." More about:Supreme CourtChildhood Defense OfficeFernando Rabat