LUXEMBOURG — The European Commission was accused Wednesday of withholding internal messages that explain why it dropped a contentious patent proposal, amid claims of pressure from U. S. Vice President JD Vance.
At a court hearing in Luxembourg, judges were told that German center-left MEP Tiemo Wölken asked the Commission for internal notes on why the proposal was abruptly killed in early 2025. He was told there was only one relevant internal document: minutes of a private meeting between heads of cabinet, which the Commission refused to hand over.
Wölken’s lawyers said the absence of information was hard to believe given how contentious the proposal had become.
It was “unbelievable” that there were “zero emails on this highly-politicized, economically-relevant procedure,” Carsten Zatschler, Wölken’s lawyer, said at the EU’s General Court.
“All of this apparently happened without any form of electronic communication,” Zatschler said. “That’s quite simply not credible.”
In February 2025, the Commission announced it was withdrawing plans for a standard essential patents (SEPs) regulation on the licensing of patents, saying there was no “clear signal of support” from co-legislators. Negotiations between the European Parliament and EU countries were ongoing at the time. The proposal was officially killed in July that year.
The proposal had triggered a fierce lobbying battle between patent holders — including Nokia, Ericsson, Qualcomm and Huawei — and companies that license their technology, from phone makers to carmakers.
The withdrawal was announced on the same day that Vance met with Commission President Ursula von der Leyen at an AI summit in Paris, where they discussed AI, Ukraine and transatlantic ties. The timing prompted questions in the European Parliament about whether their conversation played a role in quashing the proposal.
Zatschler asked: “Why was it surprisingly withdrawn? Whether a meeting between Ursula von der Leyen and U. S. Vice President JD Vance played a role, that’s obviously not something we need to discuss here.”
“But whether it can be clarified should not be dependent on whether the European Commission categorized emails as important or not, because otherwise we would be putting the fox in charge of the hen house,” he said.
Wölken was part of the negotiating team blindsided by the decision.
“My team had met the Polish presidency [of the Council of the EU] just days before, and they were gearing up to finalize the Council position,” the lawmaker told POLITICO. “No one was informed.”
“That alone raises questions about the withdrawal, which for me turned into a real concern after hearing rumors about the meeting between Ursula von der Leyen and JD Vance,” he said.
The Commission did hand over 14 documents to the German MEP, most of which were emails and position papers from outside stakeholders sent to the Commission after the decision to kill the proposal was announced.
Lawyers for the Commission told judges that Wölken’s request didn’t specify that he was seekend internal emails predating the decision.
“These are professional lawyers,” said Tim Maxian Rusche, representing the Commission (Wölken is also a lawyer). “They work directly in Brussels. If they want internal correspondence, they’re going to have to specify that.”
He added that the Commission is “being exposed to more and more fishing expeditions” where it is asked “very general” questions in access to document requests.
“They need to make [requests] clear, because otherwise we can’t do our work,” he continued.
The Commission is also facing a lawsuit from the European Parliament over the decision to kill the proposal. Last year, lawmakers voted to sue the Commission over the decision, arguing that it had overstepped its competence.
“The Commission’s right to withdraw a proposal … cannot be used as a political instrument to short-circuit Parliament’s work or to enforce a deregulation agenda from above,” German Social Democrat René Repasi said. “This is not in line with how the democratic processes in the European Union are meant to function.”
The judges did not confirm when a decision would be made in the case.
AI Brief
Your highlights
Our readers read next
More from Mari Eccles
EU watchdog probes Commission’s AI pick over conflict of interest concerns
Jim Hagemann Snabe was named AI envoy in June, but the choice has proved controversial.
Nov 10
3 mins read
Russian strikes leave thousands without power in Ukraine, says Zelenskyy
The Ukrainian president’s remarks came as Moscow reported “significant damage” to an industrial facility in Russia’s Nizhny Novgorod region.
Nov 1
2 mins read
UK’s future lies in EU, says Rachel Reeves
The intervention by the former British chancellor comes ahead of a UK-EU summit later this month.
Nov 1
2 mins read
EU prosecutors asked to investigate advisory body
Allegations of a conflict of interest at European Economic and Social Committee have been sent to EPPO.
Oct 16
2 mins read