Centrist and leftwing MEPs boycott rightwing NGO funding probe, which found no wrongdoing

rss · EUobserver 2026-11-18T17:02:36Z en
Centre and left-wing MEPs boycotted another meeting of the European Parliament’s Scrutiny Working Group (SWG) on NGO funding on Wednesday (18 November), at which rightwing MEPs presented a 71-page report on their year-long probe that found no wrongdoing. In a joint press statement, MEPs from the S&D, Renew Europe, The Greens/EFA, and The Left accused the SWG, which was set up by the European People’s Party (EPP) and the European Conservatives and Reformists (ECR), of becoming “a political instrument” to undermine civil society. MEPs also accused the group of breaching parliament’s internal rules on confidentiality and democratic participation, They referred to the working group being set up without the backing of the Committee on Budgetary Control, and to the fact that no amendments were allowed to the report. “Having found nothing, the scrutiny working group has shown its real intent with its final document: attack civil society organisations and the democratic space they represent,” the statement of the cross-party group of MEPs said. Wednesday’s boycott follows a walkout at the group’s first meeting in November 2025, after which centre and left-wing groups refused to take part in its work. In the final report, authors Dirk Gotink, a Dutch centre-right MEP, and Carlo Fidanza, an Italian conservative, admitted they found no proof of wrongdoing or financial misconduct by NGOs or the commission. Nor did they find evidence that EU authorities had required NGOs getting EU funds to carry out advocacy, or whether they had any impact on policy outcomes at all. But the report still includes 23 recommendations to the commission, such as imposing five-year funding bans on organisations that lobby EU and national institutions, phasing out core operating support, and introducing administrative ring-fencing requirements. Presenting the report to rightwing MEPs on Wednesday, Gotink said some of these recommendations should apply only to a limited number of NGOs that "behave very much like the consultants". “We want civil society to engage” but “they do not need to be here with amendments in their pockets and trying to influence our legislative outcomes,” he said. Still the gap in lobbying firepower between industry and NGOs remains huge. The EU’s biggest industry lobbyists, including Meta, Amazon, Apple, Shell and Bayer, spend at least €381.75m a year lobbying EU institutions, according to Corporate Europe Observatory and LobbyControl. By contrast, environmental NGOs receive roughly €15.6m a year in operating grants from the EU’s LIFE programme, according to media reports. Contracts under the LIFE programme between NGOs and the commission were the subject of the probe launched by the scrutiny group. 'Not a single euro' One of the problems, Gotink said, was that EU money was going to NGOs that lobby MEPs and take legal action to enforce EU law. Pointing to what the report calls a “persistent perception” of closeness between the Commission and the NGOs it funds, he argued that the Commission does not need a “network of external actors to emphasise even more their proposals or make sure that they survive the legislative process.” Yet back in February, Gotink had said that “the problem that we’re pursuing here is not to establish whether things are illegal, it is to establish whether politically it is undesirable.” His co-author, Fidanza also said the next long-term EU budget must have “all the tools possible to ensure that not a single euro of European public money is spent in a way that doesn’t bring benefits to European citizens,” calling for “reciprocal transparency between the institutions and civil society.” What about the consultants? Centre and left-wing MEPs said in their statement that if transparency were the real concern, “the same scrutiny would apply to all beneficiaries.” On Wednesday, Gotink admitted the group could have done “much more” on the Commission’s consultancy contracts, warning that “if the big four stop working for the commission today, the commission simply stops working.” The centre and left-wing MEPs also accused the working group of “effectively seeking to penalise the defence of EU fundamental values,” arguing that “it would shut civil society out of the debate on EU and national legislation.” The report by Gotink and Fidanza comes after the European Commission unveiled in November 2025 its strategy for civil society, in a bid to “ensure an open, safe and enabling civic space” and support organisations “with adequate, sustainable and transparent funding”. The UN special envoy on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association Gina Romero raised concerns ahead of the committee meeting on Wednesday, arguing that “restricting operating grants risks starving civil society and undermining agendas crucial for the EU”. “Weaponising budgetary scrutiny to sideline critical voices weakens democratic checks and balances at the exact moment Europe needs them most,” she also said.

Knowledge Graph

Entities
Highlight