A veteran’s ten-year plan for cross-strait integration revives familiar ideas — and exposes the distance between the party’s political imagination and Taiwan’s preferences
A veteran’s ten-year plan for cross-strait integration revives familiar ideas — and exposes the distance between the party’s political imagination and Taiwan’s preferences
By Michael Turton / Contributing Reporter
Add TT as Preferred Source
Last week, senior figures in the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) met at National Taiwan University Hospital’s International Conference Center, apparently to forward proposals on Taiwan’s submission to the People’s Republic of China (PRC). Present were former Examination Yuan head John Kuan (關中), former legislative speaker and wily head of the Taiwanese faction in the KMT, Wang Jin-pyng (王金平), former secretary-general of the National Security Council, Su Chi (蘇起), former foreign minister Lin Yung-lo (林永樂) and repeatedly unsuccessful mayoral aspirant and the KMT’s losing 2018 Taipei candidate Ting Shou-chung (丁守中), among others. According to Ting, the conference had been months in planning. Fount Media reported that Xiamen TV, a PRC state-run media outlet, sent reporters to cover the event. At the conference, former Straits Exchange Foundation vice chairman and secretary-general Chiu Chin-yi (邱進益) proposed a “Ten-year plan for a cross-strait peaceful integration initiative” calling for the integration of Taiwan with the PRC over the next 10 years. He called for the Legislative Yuan to propose a referendum to authorize the government to negotiate with the PRC to establish a cross-strait common market. The referendum should be held concurrent with the 2028 presidential election.
Former Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) legislator Ting Shou-chung, third right, and former Examination Yuan head John Kuan, center, on Nov. 12 hosted the “Commemoration of the Father of the Nation’s Birthday and Cross-Strait Peace Initiative Conference”. Second from the left is former Straits Exchange Foundation vice chairman and secretary-general Chiu Chin-yi.
Photo: Tien Yu-hua, Taipei Times
Once the referendum passes, the new government — presumably KMT — could begin talking to Beijing. First, representative offices would be established on each side. They would replace the current Straits Exchange Foundation (SEF) and Association for Relations Across the Taiwan Straits (ARATS). Then, under the “1992 consensus”, the two sides would move forward to expand the exchanges of people, goods and capital via the formation of a common market. By 2032 the currencies would unified. After that, they could hold talks on what sort of political structure would govern the two, with everything wrapped up by 2036. The “1992 consensus” refers to a tacit understanding between the KMT and CCP that both sides of the Strait acknowledge there is “one China,” with each side having its own interpretation of what “China” means. Su in 2006 admitted that he made up the term to break a cross-strait deadlock and alleviate tension.
FOOLING NOBODYThis remarkable fantasy illuminates many things about the KMT. The first is that it never has new ideas. For example, during a visit to China in 2001 — 25 years ago — KMT heavyweight Vincent Siew (蕭萬長) gave a speech in Beijing calling for the development of a cross-strait common market founded on the “1992 consensus”. Lien Chan called for similar institutions to be developed during his 2005 visit to the PRC. The gray haired politicians at that conference last week are thus little more than metaphors for their political ideas. The KMT continues to promote these ideas despite the public’s rejection of them, and the PRC’s refusal to treat Taiwan with any equality. The KMT treats the ROC as if it were an imperial state ruling a great nation, instead of the administrative apparatus of a wealthy middle power. This revealing conference also shows how tone deaf the KMT is. A hard fought local election is nearing its climax, and KMT figures are publicly discussing frameworks for the fringe idea of integrating Taiwan with the PRC. Moreover, attendees applauded speakers’ assertions that the ROC is China, and that Taiwanese are Chinese, despite their unpopularity in Taiwan. Sharp-eyed netizens spotted flower baskets from Chiang Wan-an (蔣萬安) the KMT incumbent mayor running for re-election, and Chiang Chi-chen (江啟臣), the KMT candidate for mayor of Taichung. Recognizing the dangerous implications of this discourse so late in an election, Ting and a couple of other attendees were quick to distance themselves and the KMT, saying that the cross-strait integration proposal was Chiu’s opinion and not official policy. That could be believable, if only these ideas hadn’t been repeatedly proposed by ranking KMT members over the years. Chiu explicitly envisaged negotiations under a KMT government taking office in 2028. Although the organizers deny that his timetable represents their shared position, its appearance at this gathering invites scrutiny of the party’s wider cross-strait agenda. No one else laid out fantasies as detailed as Chiu’s, but heavyweights such as Wang Jin-pyng proposed using shared “Chinese culture” and mutual kinship as a bridge. Ting laid out a similar idea, saying that negotiations could be carried on by the private sector. It could also be argued that the politicians were simply attempting to appeal to their deep blue base, but they were literally thinking out loud to each other. Most of the politicians present were past their prime and no longer very active. Current KMT Chair Cheng Li-wun (鄭麗文) and several powerful local faction politicians were among those absent. But Cheng has called for relations to be based on the “1992 consensus”, and has also asserted that Taiwanese are Chinese. Fu Kun-chi (傅?萁), the legislator from Hualien and a major player in the KMT who frequently visits the PRC, has similarly called for relations between the PRC and Taiwan based on the “1992 consensus” and shared opposition to Taiwan independence. Former Chairman Eric Chu (朱立倫), under whose leadership the KMT slowly recovered from its 2014 and 2016 elections, was not there, but he too supports the “1992 consensus”. Ironically, in 2022, when Chu forwarded this KMT version of the non-existent “consensus” on a visit to the US, the PRC Taiwan Affairs Office rebuked him, saying “the 1992 consensus is not permitted to be arbitrarily distorted, [Chu] must maintain a clear head and keep to the correct direction.”IDEOLOGY TRUMPING REALITYEveryone at the conference knows that the PRC has never accepted the KMT’s version. That shows how for the KMT, public incantation of unreality signals membership in the belief system, a problem for every group in which ideology trumps reality. Surely a savvy local politician like Wang Jin-pyng, a Taiwanese from Kaohsiung, understands how unpopular these KMT ideas are, yet he still repeats them. Fount Media quoted Ting as saying that the initial planning meeting was on May 18 of this year, and that a follow-up working group would come next. It will be interesting to see how its concrete policy proposals differ from Chiu’s program of submission to the PRC. We have been watching the KMT struggle with PRC policy and Taiwanese preference for so long that we have almost forgotten how the KMT itself evolved. Originally it was going to Return to China. As that Return to Zion possibility faded into history, it has inverted that ideology to propose bringing Zion over. This possibility is so intensely theological that the KMT simply never talks about what would happen afterwards — note how none of the speeches at the conference appear to consider the effects of cross-strait integration on Taiwan itself. The KMT’s purpose has gradually become “immanentizing the eschaton”, with the apocalypse of Taiwan annexation as its avowed end, a thing good in itself. What would post-apocalypse Taiwan look like? For the KMT, that appears to be unimportant. Notes from Central Taiwan is a column written by long-term resident Michael Turton, who provides incisive commentary informed by three decades of living in and writing about his adoptive country. The views expressed here are his own.