Against Milei's request, a province raises taxes on its bank and on gas to finance education

rss · La Nacion 2026-11-18T15:26:39Z es
USHUAIA.– After a lengthy controversy and a 7-to-7 tie vote that was decided by the double vote of the body's president, the Tierra del Fuego Legislature passed the Comprehensive Financing Law for the Provincial Education System. It is an initiative of Governor Gustavo Melella that creates new funds for education through two tax levies that were the focus of the controversy: a 3.4% gross income tax rate on natural gas distribution —an activity provided in the province by Camuzzi Gas del Sur— and a 3% surcharge on all taxable activities of the Bank of Tierra del Fuego (BTF). The law was one of the promises the Executive made to the leadership of the Unified Union of Education Workers of Tierra del Fuego (SUTEF) to end a conflict that included 46 days of strike and encampment in one of the provinces with the fewest days of classes held. The Tierra del Fuego case reflects a problem affecting almost all provinces. Since the national government stopped transferring the National Teacher Incentive Fund (Fonid), several jurisdictions —including Tierra del Fuego, Neuquén, Córdoba, and Entre Ríos— created their own mechanisms to partially compensate for that salary loss, and teacher conflicts multiplied across the country. At the same time, the law runs counter to the pressure from the Casa Rosada for provinces to lower gross income taxes, the tax that the Minister of Economy, Luis Cap…
USHUAIA.– After a lengthy controversy and a 7-to-7 tied vote that was decided by the double vote of the body's president, the Tierra del Fuego Legislature passed the Comprehensive Financing Law for the Provincial Education System. It is an initiative by Governor Gustavo Melella that creates new funds for education through two taxes that were the focus of the controversy: a 3.4% gross receipts (Ingresos Brutos) rate on natural gas distribution —an activity provided in the province by Camuzzi Gas del Sur— and a 3% surcharge on all taxable activities of the Bank of Tierra del Fuego (BTF). The law was one of the promises the Executive made to the leadership of the Unified Union of Fuegian Education Workers (SUTEF) to end a conflict that included 46 days of strike and encampment in one of the provinces with the fewest days of classes held. The Fuegian case reflects a problem affecting almost all provinces. Since the national government stopped transferring the National Teacher Incentive Fund (Fonid), several jurisdictions —including Tierra del Fuego, Neuquén, Córdoba and Entre Ríos— created their own mechanisms to partially compensate for that salary loss, and teachers' conflicts multiplied across the country. Session of the Tierra del Fuego Legislature in which the tax increase was approved. At the same time, the law runs counter to the pressure from the Casa Rosada for provinces to lower gross receipts taxes, the tax that Economy Minister Luis Caputo called "the worst tax." In mid-year, the Central Bank allowed banks to open digital accounts through branches in provinces with lower tax burdens, a measure aimed at jurisdictions that tax financial activity more heavily. How the vote went With the governor traveling and Vice Governor Mónica Urquiza in charge of the Executive, the session was chaired by Justicialist legislator María Victoria Vuoto (sister of the mayor of Ushuaia, Camporista Walter Vuoto). Fourteen of the 15 legislators were present and the vote was tied, so Vuoto had to break the tie, and she did so in favor. Decisive was the change of position of Laura Colazo (Green Party), who weeks earlier had voted to strip the Executive's bill of its urgency. After the vote, she explained that she received additional information from the Ministry of Economy and a favorable assessment from the president of the Bank of Tierra del Fuego, though she admitted that "this law is not a panacea." The law creates two funds. First, the Provincial Infrastructure Fund, fed by the 3.4% gross receipts rate on the natural gas distribution activity code. Forty percent will go to school maintenance and new school infrastructure, and 60% to natural gas network works and household connections. Second, the Educational Financing Fund (FFE), permanent and with exclusive allocation, receives the 3% surcharge on the Bank of Tierra del Fuego, 40% of the infrastructure fund, and other sources: part of what is collected from rural property tax revaluations (whose valuation will be updated annually by the CPI), from the profits of state-owned companies, from Terra Ignis Energía S.A., and from future revenues from green hydrogen and the knowledge economy. Its distribution, which the law defines as "indicative" and which the Executive can modify, is 40% for teacher salaries, 40% for infrastructure, and 20% for technological equipment and pedagogical resources. Opening of legislative sessions: Gustavo Melella with his deputy, Mónica Urquiza. Press Office, Government of Tierra del Fuego. The two taxes were the focus of the discussion since the bill was introduced in September. In October, Melella himself had defended taxing the distributor, saying that "businesses pay gross receipts; SMEs pay gross receipts and every self-employed person pays gross receipts. Why shouldn't Camuzzi pay?" Yesterday, after the law was passed, he insisted: "It is not a tax grab, it is a tool to give resources and predictability to our education system." For the opposition, "the costs end up being passed on to society," as Villegas argued, questioning the burden on Camuzzi and on the bank. "You cannot pretend to solve the lack of management by passing the bill on to Fuegians," he added. Legislator Jorge Lechman (Somos Fueguinos) doubted that the prohibition on passing on the taxes would be honored: he said that under the law the new taxes cannot be passed on to customers or users, "which is not going to happen. We cannot keep generating taxes on the citizenry," he said. Radical Federico Sciurano, who voted against, had warned since October that the two taxes would end up affecting the very sectors the law aims to benefit. "I think it is important to have an education financing law," he clarified at the time, but on the tax on the provincial bank he was emphatic: "The public employee himself will end up paying that increase too." And he summarized his objection: "What I give you, I then take away through a tax, because otherwise what we are discussing makes no sense." Natalia Gracianía, chair of the La Libertad Avanza bloc, had already raised the question in October: "We have to see who will bear this 3%, whether the bank will pay it or whether it will be passed on to customers." After the vote, she called the law "an empty shell, whose only purpose is to provide an elegant way out of the 46 days of strike." Melella, for his part, acknowledged the limitations and said on social media that "this new law, although not sufficient on its own, helps to have more resources," and attributed the lack of salary increases to the national government's austerity and the elimination of programs. That reproach to the Casa Rosada was not isolated: the provincial ruling party framed the education financing debate as a dispute with Javier Milei's government. From the provincial ruling party, Greve responded to La Libertad Avanza: "Honestly, you know what would improve education in Tierra del Fuego? If La Libertad Avanza returned the 17 national programs it eliminated and turned its back on education." The confrontation, however, has nuances: when he sent the bill in September, Melella had just opened a channel of dialogue with the Casa Rosada and broadly supported the national 2027 Budget. From La Libertad Avanza, Gracianía attributed the law to a political agreement between the governor and the secretary general of SUTEF, Horacio Catena. The passage comes in a tight fiscal context: the 2027 budget bill sent by the Executive foresees tax increases and yet a deficit of some 200 billion pesos, considering that 100 billion of these would be covered by the new rate schedule. By Sol Agusti Type of work: News Original

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Highlight