For months they delayed the examinations and traditional treatments. By the time the boy was hospitalized, it was too late for him.
AI Brief
Your highlights
They have been sentenced for their son's death—the boy, who had cancer, was treated using the Hamer method, delaying diagnostic tests and conventional treatments—and for this they must serve two years for manslaughter. This was the decision of the court in Vicenza, convicting Luigi Gianello and Martina Binotto, parents of Francesco, who died in January 2024 from an osteosarcoma.
When the fourteen-year-old was diagnosed, his parents delayed the biopsy and the start of chemotherapy for months, preferring to rely on the Hamer method—already rejected by the National Institute of Health, the medical association, and scientific societies—and other therapies of dubious scientific validity.
Following the advice of Matteo Penzo, a doctor who at the time was still registered with the medical association and is now suspended, and despite the contrary opinion of several specialists, the boy's parents decided to follow the Hamer method, which attributes every illness to a biological conflict triggered by a trauma.
For months the boy was housed in a community in Tuscany and treated with clay poultices, natural anti-inflammatories, and massages. Only when his condition had become desperate was he taken to the hospital in Perugia. But by then it was too late for him. The tumor had spread rapidly, and the chemotherapy, started too late, failed to save his life. According to the specialists heard in court, he could have been saved with conventional treatments.
For this reason, the prosecutors in Vicenza had requested 14 years each for the parents. "We know that the primary cause of Francesco's death was the tumor," the prosecutor had said in court, "however, there is criminal responsibility tied to having omitted an action that could have prevented it. It is clear that the parents did not want the boy's death, but while aware of the danger, they continued with the alternative treatments in a negligent and reckless manner."
The judges of the Assize Court, however, embraced the defense's argument, which for both defendants had requested the reclassification of the charge to manslaughter and the sentence reduction provided for by the expedited trial procedure.