I investigated my father's murder and I challenge the official version of a key episode in Peru's history

rss · BBC Mundo 2026-11-18T12:24:23Z es
The massacre of several journalists in Uchuraccay is one of the most remembered episodes of a painful past that is once again under discussion.
Image source, Octavio Infante / Courtesy of Carlos Infante Photo caption, The journalists took photographs on the way to the Andean heights where they would meet their death. Author, Author's name, BBC News World Publication date, 18 minutes Reading time: 7 min Carlos Infante was 11 years old when his father Octavio was killed in one of the most tragic and remembered episodes of the armed conflict between the Peruvian state and the Maoist guerrilla group Shining Path. Octavio Infante was one of eight journalists murdered on January 26, 1983, in the remote Andean community of Uchuraccay, at more than 4,000 meters above sea level, as they tried to reach isolated areas to confirm rumors of massacres that had reached the city of Ayacucho. Infante and his expedition companions were intercepted by the villagers of Uchuraccay, who killed them with machete blows, stones, and beatings. The group's guide and a local man accused of collaborating with Shining Path were also killed. Carlos Infante recalls that the news of his father's death arrived at the family home like "a stunning rock." The impact was felt throughout the country, which was not yet aware of the tragic magnitude of a conflict that was then only in its infancy and would leave more than 69,000 dead between 1980 and 2000. Then-President Fernando Belaúnde Terry ordered an investigation by a commission headed by writer Mario Vargas Llosa, which concluded that the villagers had lynched the journalists after mistaking them for Shining Path "terrorists," in a climate of "extremely high psychological tension." The military deployed in the area had warned them that state forces would always arrive by helicopter and that any stranger on foot should be considered a Shining Path member. For the Commission, the language barrier —Quechua-speaking villagers facing Spanish-speaking journalists— prevented dialogue. Vargas Llosa summarized it as the clash between "the official and modern country" and "the archaic and ignored country." Skip Most read and continue reading Most read End of Most read Two decades later, the final report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (CVR) questioned part of those conclusions, although the thesis of the cultural gap still enjoys wide acceptance. Uchuraccay, meanwhile, was left abandoned after years of violence between Shining Path and the Army. Now, after years investigating his father's death, Carlos Infante —today a journalist and sociologist at the National University San Cristóbal de Huamanga— challenges the official version in a newly published book: "¡Dame tu cámara, carajo! Estrategia militar, paramilitarismo y masacre en Uchuraccay" ("Give me your camera, damn it! Military strategy, paramilitarism, and massacre in Uchuraccay"). In conversation with BBC Mundo, Infante said that the dominant version "attributes [what happened] to a confusion" and "isolates it from the sociopolitical context." His book, he explained, recovers a hypothesis already raised in 1983: that the massacre was the product of a military strategy designed since March 1982 to "shift the costs of the war onto the peasant population" through the promotion of paramilitary groups. Image source, Courtesy of Carlos Infante Photo caption, Carlos Infante was a child when his father died in one of the bloodiest episodes of the Peruvian internal conflict. According to his thesis, the villagers who killed his father were part of a paramilitary group led by the leaders of Uchuraccay, instigated by the military command to stop Shining Path, whose insurgency threatened the traditional power of those local leaders. Infante's theses contrast with those of other researchers, and they arrive at a moment when the memory of the conflict is once again a matter of political dispute in Peru, coinciding with Keiko Fujimori's arrival at the presidency. What happened in Uchuraccay At the beginning of 1983, the Peruvian conflict was escalating strongly. The Shining Path columns, protected by the heights of the Rasuwilca snow peak, had intensified their attacks in the province of Huanta, which led the government to declare a state of emergency in Ayacucho and deploy the Army in the area. According to Infante, in the second half of January, Uchuraccay and neighboring communities were experiencing "the greatest state of tension in many years." "24 murders had been recorded in just two days." The most serious had occurred on January 21 in Huaychao, where the villagers rebelled against Shining Path and killed several of its militants. The echoes of those events reached Ayacucho, where local journalists and correspondents from Lima decided to undertake the journey to the heights to confirm the rumors. After hours of travel by car and on foot —guided on the last stretch by Juan Argumedo, Octavio Infante's half-brother— the group was intercepted in Uchuraccay. Image source, Willy Retto Photo caption, Photographer Willy Retto photographed the interaction between the journalists and the peasants who intercepted and killed them. The photos taken by photojournalist Willy Retto, found months later, show the moment when the villagers question the journalists about their destination and intentions. What was said in that exchange remains a matter of debate, but it ended with the eight journalists, their guide, and a villager linked to Shining Path lynched with machete blows, beatings, and stones, and buried in pits on the mountainside. Carlos Infante's investigations While the tragedy dominated the news and Vargas Llosa arrived with his commission, the boy Carlos Infante was struggling with his father's death. "For eight years I refused to begin the mourning," he says in his book. It was the exhumation of Octavio's remains, he says, that allowed him to begin to heal by investigating the episode. In his book, Infante rejects the idea that communication was impossible due to the language barrier: "My father spoke Quechua, and he was not the only one in the group who spoke it, so it cannot be argued that the villagers did not understand them when they identified themselves as journalists." On the contrary, he maintains that it was precisely because they knew they were journalists —and that they were going to investigate the Huaychao massacre— that the leaders of Uchuraccay decided to kill them, to hide their participation in that massacre and in the paramilitary campaign promoted by the military high command. "It was not an impossible dialogue despite the social distances and from Quechua to Spanish. They revealed their mission to the perpetrators of that crime and of others that had occurred a week earlier," says Infante, who concludes: "It was not the irrational explosion of 430 villagers, but a relatively calculated action of 35 men in exchange for restoring their absolute hegemony in the community." Image source, Óscar Medrano / Courtesy of Carlos Infante Photo caption, Infante believes that paramilitary groups were formed in the Andean communities, but other authors maintain that the communities were prey to fear and the climate of violence. The explanations for Uchuraccay Suspicions of official involvement and paramilitarism are not new. They have been repeated since the massacre became known, along with criticism of Vargas Llosa for exonerating the State by relying on stereotypes about the indigenous peasantry. Statements from that time feed that reading. After the first killings of Shining Path members, Belaúnde celebrated the "gallantry" of the people of Ayacucho against the "subversion," and General Clemente Noel, the highest military authority in the Ayacucho emergency zone, applauded the "spontaneous" rebellion. The press also highlighted that some of the villagers involved appeared in photos wearing military fatigues under their ponchos. Other researchers, however, reject Infante's thesis. The Japanese historian Hiromi Hosoya maintains that the discourse of "confusion" ignores the distance —racial, ethnic, and cultural— between the villagers and those who later judged what happened, including Vargas Llosa. According to Hosoya, the villagers perhaps did not understand why high state authorities applauded the deaths of Shining Path members while Vargas Llosa —according to the writer's own account— explained to them that the government could not arm them because justice had to be applied by a judge and follow a procedure. "Violence was treated differently depending on the context: sometimes it was considered a criminal act, and other times a heroic deed," Hosoya wrote. For her, "the voice of the villagers was not heard." Image source, Courtesy of Carlos Infante Photo caption, The villagers declared that the military told them that anyone who did not arrive in Uchuraccay by helicopter should be considered an enemy. The legacy of Uchuraccay The final report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission concluded that the massacre was the work of the villagers, in a climate of fear of reprisals after confronting Shining Path, and that they mistook the journalists for Shining Path members because of the military warnings about anyone arriving on foot. The Commission also pointed out the State's lack of protection for the peasant population, but it did not go so far as to affirm the existence of a strategy to promote paramilitarism or to classify the villagers as a paramilitary group. Infante's book arrives at a moment when the memory of the two decades of violence that ravaged Peru at the end of the last century is once again a matter of dispute. Since Keiko Fujimori's arrival at the presidency this year, sectors of her party have proposed revising the exhibition at the Place of Memory and school textbooks about the conflict, which they accuse of "ideological bias" and of instilling the narrative of the "internal armed conflict" instead of the "victory of the State over terrorism." Academic and left-wing sectors have denounced this as a "coordinated offensive against memory," in the words of filmmaker Joel Calero, and an attempt to dilute the State's responsibility for the human rights violations that occurred. With his research, which he himself describes as "controversial and provocative, but necessary," Infante joins a debate about the country's past that is in fact also about its present. Download the new BBC World Service app. Choose BBC News Mundo and receive news alerts, documentaries, and analysis, all in one place. Important: the new app is not available in the United Kingdom or the United States. You can also follow us on YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, X, Facebook, and on our WhatsApp channel. And don't forget to subscribe here to our newsletter to receive a special selection of our best content every Friday.

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Knowledge Graph

Entities
Highlight