Alejandro Tullio backed the suspension of the PASO and criticized the changes to electoral campaign financing

rss · Infobae 2026-11-18T11:50:14Z es
The discussion on electoral reform once again puts under review rules that govern everything from the internal competition of parties to the way campaigns are financed and a ballot is put together. The bill the Government is preparing proposes the suspension of the PASO primaries, changes to the presidential debates, and the possibility of allowing multiple candidacies on a single ballot (colectoras), in addition to changes in the contributions regime. Within that set, there are measures that simplify the process, but also decisions that can alter the political and economic controls of an election. Alejandro Tullio, permanent electoral secretary of the province of Chubut and former national electoral director between 2001 and 2016, explained on Infobae Al Amanecer that the initiative combines advances with matters that still require discussion. "There are positive things, necessary things, and things that need to be studied a bit more," the specialist summarized. And he placed the debate within a broader question than whether or not a primary should remain in place: what tools the system needs so that voters understand the electoral offering, so that parties define their candidacies, and so that the campaign is not left tied to interests unrelated to the competition. The reform, he argued, requires reviewing each of those gears before setting new rules. The single ballot and its categories One of the points Tullio considers advisable is eliminating the direct election of the Mercosur parliamentarians. In his view, the…
Alejandro Tullio analyzed the electoral reform bill being pushed by the national government The debate over electoral reform once again puts under review the rules that govern everything from parties' internal competition to how campaigns are financed and how a ballot is put together. The bill the government is preparing proposes the suspension of the PASO primaries, changes to presidential debates, the possibility of allowing colectoras (list-stacking), as well as changes to the contribution regime. Within that package, there are measures that simplify the process, but also decisions that could alter the political and economic controls of an election. Alejandro Tullio, permanent electoral secretary of the province of Chubut and former national electoral director between 2001 and 2016, explained on Infobae Al Amanecer that the initiative combines advances with matters that still require discussion. "There are positive things, necessary things, and things that need to be studied a bit more," the specialist summarized. And he placed the debate within a broader question than whether or not a primary should remain in place: what tools the system needs so that voters understand the electoral offering, so that parties define their candidacies, and so that the campaign is not tied to interests outside the competition. The reform, he argued, requires reviewing each of those gears before setting new rules. One of the points Tullio considers advisable is eliminating the direct election of Mercosur parliamentarians. In his view, the measure would reduce categories on the single paper ballot and would prevent Argentina from maintaining a system that other countries in the region have already stopped using. Paraguay, he recalled, was the first to directly elect those representatives, but later abandoned that mechanism. The elimination of the direct election of Mercosur parliamentarians seeks to simplify the single paper ballot (Video capture) "If we remove two rows, it will be clearer for the citizen," he explained when referring to the candidacies for the Mercosur Parliament. For Tullio, the simplification has a concrete effect on the voter's experience, since in national elections one must already choose a president, deputies and, in eight provinces, senators. All 24 jurisdictions elect national deputies during a presidential election. That number of offices, added to the executive categories and the senatorial seats renewed in part of the country, shows how long a ballot can become. The electoral secretary of Chubut argued that adding two more rows overloads a tool that seeks, precisely, to make voting more transparent and understandable. The argument is not limited to a matter of design. The former national electoral director believes that the categories must correspond to effective representation and to decisions made in the regional sphere. That is why he focused on the need to review the direct election of Mercosur parliamentarians within the broader discussion on how the electoral offering is organized. Tullio backed the suspension of the Open, Simultaneous and Mandatory Primaries (PASO) in the upcoming elections and defined it as a "gesture of realism" in the face of the current political scenario. His position starts from a distinction: he maintains the idea that there should be a common mechanism for selecting candidacies, although he accepts that this time the conditions warrant an exception. "Let them pass this time," he said about the primaries, without turning that phrase into a defense of their definitive elimination. The official explained that the party structure has changed, that the provinces have their own dynamics and that local leaders have gained weight, while national parties have lost the ability to organize the competition. That transformation, according to his analysis, requires thinking about what kind of primary can work going forward. Tullio mentioned voluntary PASO or a party registration system whereby each voter decides whether to participate in an internal election. Both alternatives preserve the idea of an open selection, though with different participation rules. Tullio backed the suspension of the PASO elections as an exceptional measure for the next electoral cycle EFE/ Nina Osorio The suspension, then, appears as a way out for this election and not as the end of the discussion. The permanent electoral secretary noted that, once the process is over, it will be necessary to return to the way political forces choose their candidates and to the role the State should assume at that stage. Tullio's sharpest objection concerns the possible withdrawal of the State from campaign financing. He accepted reducing official electoral advertising in the media, but questioned the reform's complete elimination of that support. For the specialist, that decision deserves a "yellow light" because it would modify the relationship between the parties, resources, and those who contribute money. "Private financiers are the ones who will control the extent to which political proposals reach the people," he warned. His concern is that the dissemination of candidacies would be determined by each political space's fundraising capacity and that contributions would condition which messages can circulate during the campaign. Tullio also called for establishing clear limits to prevent third parties outside the parties from campaigning without controls. That route, he said indirectly, could allow influences over the electoral competition without the groups having to answer for the origin of the funds or the expenses made on their behalf. At that point he included the risk of intervention by transnational organized crime. The former official noted that such groups can finance candidates and then claim political benefits. That is why he proposed that contributions go into the parties, that each group be responsible for its expenses, and that control mechanisms be maintained over the money that sustains electoral activity. The possible authorization of colectoras is another aspect Tullio views with caution. The mechanism would allow the same presidential candidate to appear more than once on the ballot, associated in each case with different legislative lists. One column could contain the candidate's own contenders and another, candidates from an allied district force. "It is not natural for a president, a candidate for president, to have various groups of legislators supporting him," he argued. The objection refers to the relationship between the presidential election and the composition of Congress, a link that, in his judgment, is decisive for governability. The electoral secretary accepted that colectoras could serve exceptionally if the PASO are suspended and alliances need to resolve a territorial competition. However, he considered that they should not become an established rule. The single ballot seeks to organize the electoral offering and, under that criterion, it should not present as part of the same presidential candidacy sectors that later face off in Parliament. The former electoral director warned about the risk of penetration of transnational organized crime into political campaigns EFE/ Demian Alday Estevez Tullio argued that agreements must be settled before the election. If different forces decide to back a presidential candidate, they should define in advance the conditions of that alliance and the relationship with their legislative lists. Otherwise, he said, the vote for the Executive can become disconnected from the representatives who will need to deal with the future government's initiatives. The bill also contemplates changes to presidential debates. According to the latest draft mentioned during the interview, the mandatory first-round debate would no longer be required, although one could be held in the event of a runoff. Tullio lamented that change, but estimated that the encounters will continue to take place. "Whoever does not participate will pay a cost for not doing so," he said. For the former national electoral director, candidates have political incentives to attend because debates allow them to present their proposals to voters under conditions similar to those of their rivals. He also stressed that these spaces make it possible to hear all the contenders on the same topics and reduce the technological mediation typical of a campaign. Although he defended their usefulness, he considered that the public interest they generate should be enough to sustain them, without the need to impose them by law. The reform thus leaves open several fronts that Tullio asked to be discussed before Congress sets the rules for the next election: the future of the PASO, the scope of the colectoras, controls over financing, and the regulation of debates. From Chubut, the official argued that the challenge is not only to speed up or simplify the process, but to preserve clear conditions for competition and the citizens' vote. –Infobae accompanies you every day on YouTube with interviews, analysis and the most important news, in a close and dynamic format. • From 7 to 9: Infobae al Amanecer: Nacho Giron, Luciana Rubinska and Belén Escobar. • From 9 to 12: Infobae a las Nueve: Gonzalo Sánchez, Tatiana Schapiro, Ramón Indart and Cecilia Boufflet. • From 12 to 15: Infobae al Mediodía: Maru Duffard, Andrei Serbin Pont, Fede Mayol and Facundo Kablan. • From 15 to 18: Infobae a la Tarde: Manu Jove, Maia Jastreblansky and Paula Guardia Bourdin; rotating during the week: Marcos Shaw, Lara López Calvo and Tomás Trapé. • From 18 to 21: Infobae al Regreso: Gonzalo Aziz, Diego Iglesias, Malena de los Ríos and Matías Barbería; rotating during the week: Gustavo Lazzari, Martín Tetaz and Mica Mendelevich Follow us on our YouTube channel @infobae.

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Knowledge Graph

Entities
Highlight