Malvinas Law: the Government modified the bill again, but differences persist over penalties for external interference

rss · La Nacion 2026-11-18T11:02:52Z es
The Government will seek to obtain preliminary approval today in the Chamber of Deputies for its National Sovereignty Defense bill, known as the Malvinas law. The ruling party has the votes to approve it in general terms, but has not yet reached an agreement on the penalties for foreign interference. To bring positions closer together, the Legal and Technical Secretariat introduced new modifications after a meeting with representatives of allied blocs last week. The initiative, driven by presidential advisor Santiago Caputo, heads the agenda of the session scheduled for 12 noon. Although it emerged with the aim of penalizing companies that exploit natural resources in the Malvinas Islands without Argentine authorization, its scope was expanded to the defense of territory, critical infrastructure, and electoral and institutional processes. Santiago Caputo at the Fundación Faro year-end dinnerThe main differences are concentrated in Title VII, which amends the political parties law and the Criminal Code to penalize foreign interference campaigns and acts of violence against the State. The allies consider that some definitions remain too broad and could affect constitutional rights. Furthermore, because it introduces changes regarding electoral matters, that section requires an absolute majority of 129 affirmative votes, a number the ruling party still does not have guaranteed. If it fails to reach new agreements, it could be left out of the bill during the item-by-item vote. Silvana Giudici, parliamentary secretary of LLA, one of those in charge of gathering endorsements for the bill in DeputiesSoledad AznarezAmong the changes incorporated is the new name of the National Security Council, which will be renamed the Council of Strategic Affairs. The Ministry of Security, currently headed by Alejandra Monteoliva, will no longer be a permanent member and will only be convened when necessary. "Given the new name of the Council, it is clear that it has to do with defense, not security. The ministry will be convened when the security forces are required," a libertarian figure explained to LA NACION. In the original wording, the Security Ministry was not part of the Council, but it ended up being included at the request of the allies. In the latest draft, the Government returned to its original intention. The definition of aerospace was also expanded to expressly include airspace and outer space. But the most sensitive adjustments are concentrated in Article 129 of the bill —part of Title VII—, which incorporates new criminal offenses related to foreign interference. The Government removed the word "sabotage" as well as the reference to actions intended to "affect the free formation of the political will of the population." In addition, it established that, for the crime to be constituted, the perpetrator must know the nature of the campaign and act with that specific purpose. It also excluded from the penalties those who share or adhere to content or opinions, for example on social media, without receiving financing or instructions from foreign agents. The clarifications, however, did not satisfy all the allies. A legislator participating in the negotiations warned that the definition of the crime could still reach legitimate activities of unions, social organizations, or business chambers. "Defined by negation, everything is included, and it is the citizen who has to prove that they fall under an exception," he questioned. That same deputy also objected that the restrictions on foreign financing extend to the organization and direction of electoral campaigns, which could affect the hiring of foreign consultants. The differences with PeronismUnión por la Patria (UP), which presented a minority opinion, shares the central objective of the bill: to penalize companies that participate, without Argentine authorization, in the exploitation of natural resources in the Malvinas and the continental shelf. In that section, the ruling party had already limited the prohibitions on suppliers and shareholders of offending companies. The new wording requires that the goods or services supplied be indispensable for the illegal activity and that the supplier know, or cannot reasonably be unaware of, their destination. However, Peronism questions the Withdrawal and Regularization regime, which allows companies to abandon the objected activities and avoid certain penalties. From the bloc, they consider that the mechanism could facilitate evading the fines provided for by the law itself. They also object to Article 111, which subjects certain investments by foreign states or companies controlled by them to review by the Council of Strategic Affairs. The provision covers sectors such as defense, telecommunications, energy, hydrocarbons, and mining, in addition to critical infrastructure of national interest. Germán Martínez alongside Silvana Giudici, Gabriel Bornoroni and Nicolás MayorazHernán ZentenoFrom UP they warn that it could interfere with provincial decisions. "If a province wants to tender a service provided by, for example, Huawei or Cofco, with participation of the Chinese government, or even Petrobras, it has to ask the Council for permission," said a figure from the space. The text excludes, however, ordinary commercial relations that do not imply control, determining influence, or access to sensitive technological information. The ruling party will thus arrive at the chamber with general approval on track, but with negotiations still open on one of the most controversial sections of the bill. The session also includes the reform of the Central Bank Charter, the trade agreement between Mercosur and the European Free Trade Association (EFTA), an amendment to the Montevideo Protocol on Trade in Services, the transfer of criminal and juvenile judicial competencies to the city of Buenos Aires, and modifications to the regulatory framework for SMEs. By Delfina Celichini

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Knowledge Graph

Entities
Highlight