A team of researchers from the University of Manchester and the University of Toronto concluded that the flapping birds perform just before landing serves not only to reduce speed, but also to stop within the available space.
The study, published in the journal Proceedings of the Royal Society A and authored by Tom Rottier, Philippe Lavoie, and Ben Parslew, did not use real birds: the scientists built a mathematical model based on physical equations to simulate the gliding flight that occurs without moving the wings.
According to the article published on Earth.com, the calculations focused on a specific case: a 400-gram pigeon wanting to land without flapping its wings. The results revealed that this would be possible in theory, but under conditions that no urban pigeon could meet in practice.
A bird would need to fly at more than 120 km/h to land without flapping
For the model pigeon to glide until coming to a complete stop, it would have to begin the maneuver at approximately 128 km/h, a speed more than double its usual pace. In addition, it would have to climb about 20 meters, the equivalent of a six-story building, while covering about 60 meters horizontally.
That type of landing would also not be possible in many environments: City pigeons fly among buildings, where that space simply does not exist. For larger birds, the required distance would be even greater.
The key behind…
AI Brief
Your highlights
Theoretical calculations showed that a pigeon would need to fly at 128 kilometers per hour to slow down solely by gliding (Illustrative Image Infobae)
A team of researchers from the University of Manchester and the University of Toronto concluded that the flapping birds perform just before landing serves not only to reduce speed, but also to stop within the available space. The study, published in the journal Proceedings of the Royal Society A and signed by Tom Rottier, Philippe Lavoie and Ben Parslew, did not use real birds: the scientists built a mathematical model based on physical equations to simulate the gliding flight that occurs without moving the wings.
According to the article published on Earth.com, the calculations focused on a specific case: a 400-gram pigeon that wanted to land without flapping its wings. The results revealed that this would be possible in theory, but under conditions that no urban pigeon could meet in practice.
The physical equations revealed that a direct descent onto flat ground always retains residual speed (Illustrative Image Infobae)
For the model pigeon to be able to glide until coming to a complete stop, it would have to begin the maneuver at approximately 128 km/h, a speed more than double its usual pace. In addition, it would have to climb about 20 meters, the equivalent of a six-story building, while traveling about 60 meters horizontally. That type of landing would also not be possible in many environments: city pigeons fly among buildings, where that space simply does not exist. For larger birds, the required distance would be even greater.
The key behind this phenomenon has to do with the physics of flight. The forces acting on a wing depend on the speed at which it moves through the air: the lower the speed, the less lift and, therefore, less control over the trajectory. There is also a minimum operating speed called the stall speed, below which the wing no longer generates enough lift to support the bird's weight.
The impact of a landing with residual speed poses a risk of bone and muscle injuries to birds' legs (Illustrative Image Infobae)
"Landing is not as simple as slowing down," said Parslew, a lecturer in aerospace engineering at Manchester. Touching down with residual speed — that is, without having come to a complete stop — means the legs must absorb the impact; a blow that is too hard can injure muscles and bones, or even kill the bird.
The researchers propose that flapping solves this problem by allowing the bird to brake within the space it has available. Gliding can reduce speed, but flapping achieves the same over a much shorter distance.
They also found a peculiarity regarding the ground: unlike a branch, the ground cannot be approached from below. When the mathematical model was forbidden from ascending at any point in the trajectory, no combination of variables allowed reaching zero speed at landing. The slowest descent the equations permitted reached the ground at an angle of approximately 34 degrees below the horizontal level, which implies that there is always residual speed upon touching the ground.
The scientists analyzed the maneuvers of the Harris's hawk, a species that combines a dive with an ascent to land (Illustrative Image Infobae)
The study also examines why ducks, geese and swans land differently on water than on solid ground. Water absorbs more of the impact's energy than solid ground, so these animals can arrive at a higher speed without risk of injury.
In the case of some birds of prey, the pattern is different. A 2022 study observed how Harris's hawks flew between two perches using a particular maneuver: they first dove downward and then climbed in a glide until landing. Rottier's team reproduced that behavior in their model, allowing the bird to flap during the descent. When the scheme was programmed only to minimize the time during which the wings lost their ability to fly (the moment when they no longer generate enough force to stay aloft), the bird reached the surface at a speed so high that it would have injured a real bird. When the only goal was to land as slowly as possible, the preceding dive was too abrupt. The best result was obtained by combining both goals.
The physical equations revealed that a direct descent onto flat ground always retains residual speed (Illustrative Image Infobae)
The calculation tool built by the team is, by design, a working basis. It does not include wind, the bird's body, tail, or flapping in its core form. However, when the researchers doubled the maximum lift value (the aerodynamic force that allows staying in the air) to assess its impact, the starting speed required for a slow landing dropped by 44%, the horizontal distance fell by 65%, and the required climb by 55%. This suggests that real birds might be capable of gliding to a stop in less space than the pigeon's figures indicate, although the model does not allow determining how much less.
The equations were designed to incorporate wind in future studies and to be adapted to the analysis of specific species. The authors point out that the same physics could be applied to animals that never flap, such as flying squirrels and flying snakes, as well as to drones designed to land on perches.