An international Financial Times investigation reveals deficiencies in the German bank's internal controls, casting a shadow over the restructuring led by CEO Sewing. German minister Klingbeil: "Provide clarity."
AI Brief
Your highlights
MILAN – Deutsche Bank's stock closed with a 6% decline on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange due to the effects of the international investigation published by the Financial Times, based on over 15 million confidential internal documents, which exposed alleged deficiencies in the institution's internal control systems, the management of relationships with wealthy Russian clients, and relations with financier Jeffrey Epstein. The institution responded by emphasizing that in some cases the incidents date back 20 years, claiming the transformation process initiated in the control systems under the guidance of CEO Christian Sewing.
The journalistic investigation also prompted a reaction from the German Minister of Finance. "Deutsche Bank now has the responsibility to clarify with full transparency how it has corrected its shortcomings and the gaps in internal controls and how it intends to effectively prevent them from recurring in the future," stated Vice Chancellor Klingbeil. He also urged independent supervisory authorities to carefully examine the matter and adopt the necessary measures. "I am certain that the supervisory authorities and, where profiles of criminal relevance emerge, also the investigative ones, will carefully analyze the elements that emerged from the leak," he said.
Deutsche Bank, conversely, maintains that the published news does not contain "new elements." The Chairman of the Supervisory Board, Alexander Wynaendts, recalled that the reported facts date back many years and that since then the institution has invested billions of euros to strengthen internal controls and correct past critical issues. The journalistic investigation was based on emails, internal investigations, board meeting minutes, compliance files, and employee chat logs, which shed new light on the career and leadership of CEO Sewing, an insider who took the helm in 2018 and who is widely credited with bringing the bank, often at the center of scandals, from the brink of ruin to record profits.
The FT sifted through documents dating back to the early 2010s, along with over 200 journalists from around the world representing dozens of publications, including Daraj, Der Spiegel, Manager Magazin, El Universal, Financial Mail, Kyodo News, Le Monde, The New York Times, and Paper Trail Media. The investigation was coordinated by Barracuda Media, a South African non-profit organization, with technical support from the Data and Research Center (Darc) in Germany.
"Privately, the man who had promised to end a series of scandals pushed for taking greater risks, harshly criticized compliance procedures, and hid some of the bank's problems from shareholders. The 'Inside Deutsche Bank' investigation also reveals accounting maneuvers, financial communications bordering on deception, and previously unknown details about the bank's relationships with pedophile Jeffrey Epstein and U.S. President Donald Trump," writes the FT, recalling that in a statement whistleblowers claimed they acted "in the public interest." Following the 2016 U.S. presidential elections, the documents then reveal that the bank questioned the reputational risks related to the relationship with Trump, who owed it $331 million. Subsequently, in 2017 and 2019, Deutsche Bank identified suspicious payments involving Trump's companies originating from the Azerbaijani Laundromat as well as from a Russian money laundering network linked to Kremlin-aligned oligarchists. However, when reporting these operations to U.S. authorities, it did not indicate that the beneficiaries were the president's companies.
Finally, the channels opened between the bank and the Russian oligarchy came under particular scrutiny. "Under Sewing's leadership, Deutsche planned an expansion of its notorious activities in Russia, ignoring the fears of its compliance team regarding the bank's clientele linked to the Kremlin, while the clouds of a geopolitical storm were gathering," writes the FT.