92% of the Cuban doctors surveyed avoid posting criticism on social media "frequently" or "always," according to the report "Digital Surveillance in Cuban Medical Training and Service," prepared by the association Roots of Hope in Spain.
The study links that level of self-censorship to a system of control that combines administrative rules, surveillance of communications, restrictions during international missions, and threats of reprisals against relatives who remain in Cuba.
The research is based on encrypted surveys and testimonies from health professionals, medical students, and doctors who participated in missions abroad. The report maintains that the restrictions are not limited to posts on Facebook, Instagram, or WhatsApp; they also extend to conversations in private groups and interactions with critical content.
According to the document, respondents identified as causes for concern the consequences of posting political criticism, denouncing shortages in hospitals, or expressing disagreement with working conditions. All participants classified their concern about these possible consequences as "high" or "extreme."
The report places Decree-Law 370 of 2018 among the regulations that contribute to this self-censorship. The legislation punishes the dissemination, through public data transmission networks, of information considered cont…
AI Brief
Your highlights
92% of the Cuban doctors surveyed avoid posting criticism on social media for fear of sanctions, according to a report by Raíces de Esperanza. (EFE/Yander Zamora/Archive)
92% of the Cuban doctors surveyed avoid posting criticism on social media "frequently" or "always," according to the report "Digital Surveillance in Cuban Medical Training and Service," prepared by the Raíces de Esperanza Association in Spain. The study links that level of self-censorship to a control system that combines administrative rules, communications surveillance, restrictions during international missions, and threats of reprisals against relatives who remain in Cuba. The research is based on encrypted surveys and testimonies from health professionals, medical students, and doctors who participated in missions abroad.
The report maintains that the restrictions are not limited to posts on Facebook, Instagram, or WhatsApp; they also extend to conversations in private groups and interactions with critical content. According to the document, respondents identified as causes for concern the consequences of posting political questions, denouncing shortages in hospitals, or expressing disagreement with working conditions. All participants classified their concern about these possible consequences as "high" or "extreme."
Surveillance covers private messaging groups and sanctions interactions as simple as a Like on critical posts. (REUTERS/Alexandre Meneghini)
The report places Decree-Law 370 of 2018 among the rules that contribute to this self-censorship. The legislation punishes the dissemination, through public data transmission networks, of information deemed contrary to the social interest, morality, good customs, or the integrity of individuals. According to the analysis by Raíces de Esperanza in Spain, the breadth of these concepts allows a criticism about medicine shortages, hospital conditions, or delays in care to be interpreted as an infraction. The sanction provided in Article 68, section i, includes a fine of 3,000 Cuban pesos (USD 124) and the confiscation of the telephone, computer, or other device used for the alleged offense.
The possibility of losing one's cell phone or computer adds to the economic fine, in a context where devices are also the main means of communication with relatives, especially for those serving in medical missions outside Cuba. The report also notes that administrative sanctions are subject to internal appeal mechanisms, before authorities within the same structure that imposes the measure. The administrations of polyclinics and hospitals reprimand workers who expose shortages of supplies or the impact of blackouts. (EFE/Yander Zamora)
The testimonies collected describe a control that begins during university training. Students surveyed indicated that they avoided discussing political issues in Telegram or WhatsApp groups for fear that screenshots would reach the academic administration or the Union of Young Communists. The report identifies the "Integralidad" (Comprehensiveness) parameter as an evaluation tool that, according to the testimonies, can affect grades, residencies, and access to medical specialties. It also records cases of students questioned for following critical pages or for not participating in political activities.
After graduation, the study places surveillance in polyclinics and hospitals. A doctor cited in the report stated that he received instructions not to disseminate images or comments about working conditions. Another testimony relates that a nurse shared photographs on social media of long lines of patients and was then summoned by the administration. Even a "Like" on a critical post about the hospital situation can lead to a reprimand, according to one of the accounts included in the research. In another case, professionals who commented on Telegram about how blackouts affected medical care later received a warning about the responsible use of social media.
The report also analyzes Decree-Law 35 and Resolution 105 of 2021, which regulate telecommunications and the state's response to cybersecurity incidents. According to the document, these rules include figures such as "harmful dissemination" and the "media echo of fake news."
Decree-Law 35 and Resolution 105 authorize cutting internet services to users accused of harmful dissemination. (Lisette Poole/The New York Times)
Decree-Law 35 enables the suspension or interruption of internet services for users who publish content considered false or harmful. Raíces de Esperanza in Spain warns that this framework can move a workplace complaint, such as the lack of gloves or supplies at a health center, into the realm of national security.
During international medical missions, the report records complaints about stricter controls. Some professionals recounted that they had to hand over their phones upon arriving in the destination country or that they could only use them under supervision. Others mentioned limited internet access, message checks, and fear of their own or their relatives' posts. A doctor on mission, cited anonymously, summarized that climate of caution: "Many also began asking their relatives in Cuba to avoid comments on social media so as not to get into trouble."