Safe bet or breaking the mold? Critics debate the arrival of Robert Pattinson as the new James Bond

rss · La Tercera 2026-11-17T16:07:13Z es
Just as Sean Connery, Roger Moore, Timothy Dalton, or Daniel Craig once did, the celebrated James Bond, agent 007, will have a new interpreter. This time, the role will fall on the shoulders of Robert Pattinson, the box-office star who became known for playing Edward Cullen in the Twilight films. Over the years, Pattinson managed to move beyond that rather adolescent register and had the chance to take on more complex and mature roles, as in The Lost City of Z (2016), Good Time (2017), or High Life (2018). But it was his acclaimed role as the bat man in The Batman (2022) that ultimately gave his career another layer of depth and consolidated him as more than just a trendy face. Added to this are his role alongside Jennifer Lawrence in the drama Die, My Love; and his role as the villainous Antinous in Christopher Nolan's monumental The Odyssey. So now the one who will introduce himself as "Bond, James Bond" will be none other than Pattinson. The media's take The reaction from the experts has not been long in coming. In the Spanish daily El País, they point out that this is a "safe" choice, betting above all on a massive audience response. "What will Robert Pattinson bring to this list? For starters, strong performances and box-office reliability, which is probably why director Denis Villeneuve, who already knew him from Dune (the screenplay will be by Steven Knight), and the producers Amy Pa…
Just as Sean Connery, Roger Moore, Timothy Dalton or Daniel Craig once did, the famous James Bond, agent 007, will have a new interpreter. This time, the role will fall on the shoulders of Robert Pattinson, the box-office actor who became known through the character of Edward Cullen in the Twilight films. Over the years, Pattinson managed to move beyond that rather adolescent register and had the chance to take on more complex and mature roles, as in The Lost City of Z (2016), Good Time (2017) or High Life (2018). But it was his acclaimed role as the bat man in The Batman (2022) that ultimately gave another layer to his career and consolidated him as more than just a fashionable face. Added to this are his role alongside Jennifer Lawrence in the drama Die, My Love; and his role as the vile Antinous in Christopher Nolan's monumental The Odyssey. So now the one who will introduce himself as "Bond, James Bond" will be none other than Pattinson. Kimberly French The media's take The reaction of the specialists has not been long in coming. In the Spanish morning daily El País, they point out that this is a "safe" choice, betting above all on a massive response from the public. "What will Robert Pattinson bring to this list? For starters, good performances and box-office reliability, which is probably why director Denis Villeneuve, who already knew him from Dune (Steven Knight will be on the script), and producers Amy Pascal and David Heyman, to whom Amazon Studios has given command of the project, selected him." "It's obvious that for Amazon Studios it is the best choice, taking as given that when Pattinson finishes Batman II he will never again play the lord of the night (no one in the industry doubts it). He has signed for three films, cementing the development of his role... although he is already 40 years old (meanwhile, his rivals in the screen tests, Jack Lowden —the purists' favorite—, Callum Turner, Josh O'Connor and Nicholas Hoult are all the same age, 36)." That said, the Spanish daily points out a not insignificant detail that will surely bother purist fans: "(Daniel) Craig took the character to absolute physicality, exactly what Pattinson is not, although he got in shape for The Batman." Kimberly French For James Hibberd, in the ever-attentive The Hollywood Reporter, the verdict is: "Robert Pattinson is the smart but safe choice to play James Bond," and he points out that the decision must have been "incredibly reassuring for the top executives at Amazon MGM," and breaks down why. "He may not be as tough as Daniel Craig or as elegant as Sean Connery, but Pattinson has a combination of qualities that make him a sound choice... He possesses that combination of movie-star appeal and indie film credibility. Pattinson has also hinted at his spy chops in Tenet and has proven he can lead a franchise in Twilight and Batman. Moreover, director Denis Villeneuve worked with Pattinson on the upcoming Dune film, so a relationship already exists between the two." The critic notes that the main apprehension with Pattinson's name is that he departs from the "canonical Bond," and leans more toward a more alternative look. "For some, Pattinson's weak point lies in the fact that he comes across as more interesting than attractive or sexy in the traditional sense. His angular figure often conveys nervousness or discomfort, which makes him very interesting to watch, but even his romantic roles tend toward eccentricity... However, Pattinson also projects vulnerability and meets many other requirements: he is a great British actor, a movie star, a box-office magnet, appealing to Generation Z, handsome, a franchise veteran and a team player." Richard Shotwell The critics' take What do the specialists in our country think? For Ana Josefa Silva, it is a hit. "Robert Pattinson seems like a very good choice to me. If we manage to forget about Twilight, his filmography is amazing! And it attests to Pattinson's infinite acting versatility." And it is that trajectory that, according to the critic, gives Pattinson the depth to put on the 007 suit. "Let's review: Good Time (2017), by the Safdie brothers, a moving antihero of the NY criminal underworld; The Lighthouse (2019), a dark and suffocating horror film in the Robert Eggers style, where he shares solitude with Willem Dafoe; Tenet (2020), where Christopher Nolan plunged him into action, that of escapes and stunts beyond belief. The same Nolan added him to the extensive cast of The Odyssey (2026), in a highly relevant role, that of Antinous, the antagonist par excellence. He was also in that singular fantasy film that is Mickey 17 (2025), by Bong Joon-ho, and in another that is its opposite: the unsettling psychological drama with certain thriller elements that is Die, My Love (2025). He also worked under the orders of Werner Herozg in Queen of the Desert (2015). And a long etcetera." Silva also dwells on the reservations the name has generated, given that it does not fit so well with the "Bond profile." In her view, that is an advantage: "While he has the good looks required for a character like 007, he is not the pretty boy (like, for example, Jacob Elordi or Henry Cavill), and at the same time he is nothing like his predecessors. This is very relevant: now that we are past the first quarter of the 21st century, James Bond is a character that requires a reset, an even more radical one than the one we saw with Daniel Craig. And Pattinson can achieve it." For Sol Márquez, of radio 13C, Pattinson's name struck her as "the obvious choice," and she explains why. "He has worked with Denis Villeneuve, who is the director committed for at least the first film, and I imagine he may even have been a decisive factor for a commitment that, from what has transpired, would include three films on the actor's part." "Pattinson is a very talented actor, with a career where the diversity of roles and the commitment to complex, different and even detestable characters is a fundamental characteristic. He is also the most famous of all the names that were floated, and the announcement of him as Bond was going to have the media impact we are seeing unfold. And that is very important for a franchise that is reinventing itself and changed owners in these years. There is an investment that must be recouped, and while Pattinson is not necessarily synonymous with box office, he is the best-known name in the group and is part of very successful films. I would like to think that his taste for more independent cinema will not disappear and that in parallel to the Bond project, which should take a decade, he will be able to do smaller projects and continue." Márquez even raises her bet and asserts that the London actor's interpretation could go down in history. "Pattinson, who has fans who have followed him since the 2000s, will be able to introduce the character to new generations and has the possibility of becoming the third best Bond in history or the best of this century, depending on how you look at it. For me, the canon established by Moore and Connery is unsurpassable. Although in the fight over the best Bond I am team Connery, despite knowing that for most people Moore is the best." Also weighing in is film journalist Paula Frederick, Culture editor at radio Duna and columnist for Culto, who applauds the new 007. "I think the choice of Robert Pattinson as James Bond makes a lot of sense." That is because, for Frederick, the actor more than measures up. "In recent years he has had an extraordinary acting evolution, with very different projects from one another, he has taken risks with complex characters and has become one of the most interesting actors of his generation. And if we think of films like The Drama, Primetime or The Odyssey, it is hard to believe that all that experience and recognition could play against him. I think it should be exactly the opposite. He is a kind of hinge actor, who can bring new generations closer to James Bond without necessarily alienating those who have followed the character for decades. And I think that is precisely what the franchise needs today." In her view, the reservations about Pattinson's figure are within what is to be expected. "All this controversy he has generated is nothing new, because practically all the actors who have played agent 007 were criticized when they were chosen, and later ended up becoming icons. Sean Connery, for example, was rejected even by Ian Fleming himself, the author of the novels, because he found him too rough. Daniel Craig was criticized because he was blond, shorter than his predecessors and did not have the look expected of James Bond. Perhaps the only one who was spared all this was Pierce Brosnan. So the fact that Pattinson generates so much criticism could even be a good omen, considering how things went for the previous ones." That said, she points out: "What seems to play most against Pattinson right now is not his talent, but his fame. Because he has already headlined two popular franchises, Twilight and The Batman, and there are those who believe he is too well known to play James Bond. Historically, the Broccoli family, the saga's historic producers, had as a rule that the actor could not be more famous than 007 himself." In any case, Frederick asserts: "It seems much more attractive to me to see what Robert Pattinson can do with James Bond than to see another actor trying to resemble the James Bond we already know." For Rodrigo González, film critic at Culto, Robert Pattinson "is the first 'emo' James Bond." And he explains why: "He is the secret agent of the millennial generation, and more than one will make the joke that he will be a fragile 007, alluding to the generation to which he evidently belongs. I think in that sense, the choice of Pattinson is coherent with the times we live in, though somewhat out of step, since there once again seems to be a culture that reclaiming brutal masculinity as a weapon of struggle." "However, let's not fool ourselves, the Albert Broccoli franchise always played the cards of sophistication and coolness —adds the critic—. And, from that point of view, Robert Pattinson is the right choice. He is a ductile actor, who was able to begin charming many in the role of a true emotional 'flan' in the Twilight saga and who evolved to the point of headlining complex characters in films by David Cronenberg and the Safdie brothers, up to that role of an infamous and abject being that is Antinous in Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey. That shows he has a great dramatic range and that he should bring a good number of nuances to the new James Bond." What will his place in history be? González states: "Compared to his illustrious predecessors, it must be said that the bar of Sean Connery will always be very high, since he was a great actor and an authentic star, belonging to an era of glory in Hollywood. I don't know if he will surpass it, but I have hopes that he will at least be at the level of Pierce Brosnan and Daniel Craig, and, of course, above Roger Moore and Timothy Dalton."

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Highlight